Ethics and Environmental Impacts Essay

Submitted By braziliancowboy
Words: 1129
Pages: 5
Open Document
COLLEGE OF BUSINESS
GRADUATE DIVISION

Case Project – Ethical Dilemma

SUMMARY OF FACTS: Agriculture and food industries play a very important role in the U.S. economy. Lately, the new trend of the food industry self-claimed organic and/or natural started raising some questions where your food comes from and how it is raised. Large corporations from this trend such as Whole Foods, describe in their organizational values and believes reports that consumers are realizing that organic and natural products are better for them and for the world. They claim that this type of food is safer, more nutritious and better for the environment. But is that true? The new trendy grocery stores and restaurants have been utilizing many misleading information on their marketing strategy towards consumers and profiting over them.
The majority of their claims involve animal food production and environmental impacts. Publicly, they denounce that every large-scale livestock producer is not responsible and doesn’t follow any type of animal welfare guidelines during the food production timeline. Also they support the idea that these practices are negative for the environment due to utilization of technologies and due to the size of the operations.
Based on these new grocery stores codes of conduct, they use only organic/free-range/natural/grass-fed/etc. type of merchandise because they claim these products as the most healthy, environmentally friendly and humane production systems for the present modern world.

ISSUE RAISED: Are these organic and natural food retailers being responsible and ethical when presenting facts to the general public while promoting their own products and beliefs?

CONCLUSIONS: No, based on ethical theories described in the Badaracco and Beatty books, these companies are not being ethical due to the fact that they do not utilize reliable sources of information on their marketing strategies such as unbiased peer reviewed research papers, or any type of scientific background that compares conventional and organic/free-range/natural/grass-fed production systems. In addition, no environmental or animal welfare studies are presented by these companies to backup the majority of their claims on animal production practices and environmental impacts. Therefore, they are misleading the consumers and profiting over them.

REASONING: Philosophically defined by the Aristotle theories, ethics are defined by rules of optimal conduct that would ultimately improve human well-being. This is the field that deals with the right and wrong, the good and bad of our actions. According to Machiavelli’s theories, these ethics subjects are not only related to principles but also responsibility to improve society, therefore the claims made by certain food companies may be questionable on the sense of doing the right thing and having responsibility with society matters.
An example of questionable actions by organic and natural food businesses is the utilization of vague concepts such as sustainability, organic, natural and locally grown on their marketing campaigns. During their ads, these companies commonly describe their beliefs about their own products and try to challenge and antagonize conventional modern agriculture. However, frequently it is common to find no proof or scientific data that agree with their concepts of sustainability, environmental impacts, organic practices and food safety and quality. Is it ethical to make affirmations that are not proven to be completely truthful to the society and consumers in general? Don’t these actions break the code of conduct of these companies in regards of social responsibility? Don’t they create a conflict of interest by doing that? Aren’t these actions controversial with their organizational values?
Ethics in modern agriculture like in any other segment is a very complex subject. Some unethical situations in agriculture can be considered black and white, such as engaging in fraud with farming
Show More

Related Documents: Ethics and Environmental Impacts Essay

Corporate Social Responsibility

Corporate Social Responsibility: What is it? In essence, corporate responsibility entails the operation of a business in such a way that it (business owners) bears responsibility – or accounts – for the environmental or social impacts that arise as a result of its creation. Socially responsible businesses not only develop policies that incorporate responsible “Do's and Don’ts” into their everyday business operations, they also report on the progress made toward the implementation of these practices…

Words 1080 - Pages 5

Sustainable Business Assigment XINGYUN QIAN Essays

environment of destinations, therefore, it may be said that sustainable tourism includes minimizing the negative impacts and maximizing the positive impacts. According to Weaver and Lawton (2010), tourism is tend to be one of the fastest growing sectors in the world and it brings economic, socio-cultural and environmental benefits to many countries, which have prompted increasing needs for greater impacts of sustainability. International tourist arrivals got 880 million in 2009 and it tend to be forecast to…

Words 3855 - Pages 16

Lecture: Sustainability and Environmental Literacy Essay

Lecture_04 -­‐ Environmental Literacy (09-­‐02) 1 8/30/13 ON THE ROAD TO COLLAPSE What lessons can we learn from a vanished Viking society? Case Study – Viking Se�lers in Greenland History – Viking se�lers from Norway established camps and eventually villages in Greenland. They relocated their old way of life to…

Words 1268 - Pages 6

Impact Of Business Ethics

In evaluating the impact of ethics and social responsibility on companies, it is imperative to establish the underlying conceptualization of the terms 'ethics' and 'social responsibility.' Essentially, this provides a better comprehension of how they may impact businesses. The concept of ethics is based on moral judgments of what is considered right or wrong. In the context of the corporate world, ethics is concerned with the examination of moral principles and issues that a company may face or that…

Words 1626 - Pages 7

Ethics: Ethics and Optimal Ethics Systems Essay

How have you educated your boss, peers, or direct reports about what you are learning in class? We hold bi-weekly team meetings to ensure cohesive communication. Over the last month, I presented the ethics benchmarks to our team and we discussed how it applied to our organization. The staff became highly engaged in these exercises, as it brought us together to think about how our organization conducts itself in a more ethical manner. The owner of our organization, also present in the meetings, was…

Words 963 - Pages 4

Ethics And Social Responsibility

Ethics and Social Responsibility Successful companies have well established code of ethics. Members of an organization with high ethical standards are held to these standards, including the decision makers responsible for making strategic plans that affect the organization and its surrounding communities. Maximizing shareholder wealth should not be the only priority when developing strategic plans. However, an organization will need to generate revenues to be profitable and successful. Ethics and…

Words 881 - Pages 4

coca colA Essay

toxic conditions, and other violations of their code of ethics. Using the Pyramid of Social Responsibility, I think it’s safe to say that Apple's actions against unethical and illegal conduct is to better society. Apple has done a tremendous job concerning environmental issues that range from toxic material removal from its products to the recycling and the use greenhouse gas emission. Not only is Apple exceeding the environmental impact of its products in a positive way, Apple also support Bono…

Words 517 - Pages 3

Ethical: Business Ethics and Ethical Codes Essay

Q1. Business ethics is a form of moral or ethical professional principles for managing their business in a business environment. Business ethics affects all aspect of business conduct and is relevant to the conduct of individuals and entire organisations. Business ethics can arise in relation to human right, corruption, economic growth, investment, corporate governance as well as environmental protection. The behaviours of business may violate with the broader community, human right of their…

Words 692 - Pages 3

Structural Behavioral And Organizational Ethics

Organizational Ethics Organizations want to implement structural behavior and organizational ethics in their organization. They use certain models to implement their ethics to have an effective, honest relationship with their consumers and to improve their organization's performance. The two measuring models that will be analyzed are triple bottom line (TBL) and balance scorecard (BSC). TBL provides a perspective that takes into account the social, environmental, and financial impacts of decisions…

Words 951 - Pages 4

BU354 Textbook Notes - Chapter 1 Essay

and threats in order to maintain a competitive advantage o increasingly, the HR department is being viewed as an equal partner in strategic planning process o HR specialists are expected to be change agents o Role in Formulating Strategy  Environmental Scanning involves identifying and analyzing external opportunities and threats that may be crucial to the organization’s success.  *Details regarding a successful incentive plan being used by a competitor, impending labour shortages, and information…

Words 1099 - Pages 5