Ethics and Oxford University Press Essay

Submitted By estheroluga1
Words: 1676
Pages: 7
Open Document
1.
Is it morally wrong to commit suicide?
In this essay, I will argue if it’s morally wrong to commit suicide. By definition, suicide is “the action of killing oneself intentionally”1 , ‘intentionally’ being the word that tends to cause controversy with this topic, as it implies that the individual is conscious of his actions. Therefore, to argue this statement I will mainly analyse Hume and Aquinas’ arguments as well as other contributions from other philosophical authors. Aquinas’ main argument states the act of suicide is morally wrong to the self, community and God.
Primarily, Aquinas argues that suicide is morally wrong. In his work, Summa Theologica, he outlines his case against suicide. Firstly he argues suicide is morally wrong against oneself that “everything naturally loves itself”2 .As humans we naturally aim to protect ourselves, even nature lower to us does the same, the prey runs from the predator, hides in shelter etc. aiming to preserve its life. The word ‘naturally’ implies that it is part of the law of nature for us to love ourselves; therefore the act of suicide is a violation of the law of nature. Consequently, if breaking a law is a crime, then breaking the law of nature is morally wrong. However, the best way to understand the human , is to look at nature itself. In 1845 in the case of “Singular Case of Suicide”, a dog was seen to throw itself into the water and endeavour to sink by “preserving perfect stillness of the legs”3 , even after the dog was rescued it re-attempted and indeed was successful. This case of animal suicide shows that it’s not natural for us to love ourselves, if it were then why would even nature(a dog) itself try to kill itself. Animal suicide shows that , it is both naturally in us to both love ourselves but also self-destruct, if nature which is lower than us can resolve to suicide, then how much more stronger is suicide on us? Hume, criticises this argument further and proposes “if I turn aside a stone, which is falling upon my head I disturb the laws of nature”4 . We constantly find new ways to preserve our lives, for instance, new medicines, cures to illnesses; isn’t this then a violation of the law of nature. Therefore using the reductio ad absurdum argument, if taking one’s life is violating the law of nature and is morally wrong, then the preservation of one’s life is also a violation and morally wrong. Aquinas argues “every man should love himself”5 . This arguments weakness lies in its subjectivity. Hume says,” no man threw away his life while worth keeping”6 , no one wants to harm themselves as we have a natural horror of death, therefore suicide is a desperate measure ,Ramsden stated “when the body and mind are so damaged by stress and so it leads to self-destruction”7, therefore as Aquinas said ‘happiness’ is not even considered, the feeling of hopelessness overrides the individual.
Suicide may be considered morally wrong due to the fact that “every man is part of a community, and, so as such belongs to the community”8 . According to the deontological argument, the word ‘deon’ meaning ‘duty’, we have an obligation and duty to society, therefore the suicide of an individual brings harm to the society. The flaw of this argument lies in the fact that what if we do not make any contributions in society , then doesn’t this mean we bring no harm to society, as the society we live in is reciprocal. In Durkheim’s study of Suicide, it argues that the community can be the cause of a person’s self destruction when there is too much regulation, so not only can the individual affect the community but the community in some case may be the cause for the destruction of the individual. It is also important to consider the consequentialist argument of ‘happiness for the greater number’. If the rest of the community is being burdened by the individual’s existence then the act of suicide would be in fact helping the community. In the case of
2
Hitler, who was a
Show More

Related Documents: Ethics and Oxford University Press Essay

Systems, Society and Sustainability Essay

CIVIL, ENVIRONMENTAL AND GEOMATIC ENGINEERING Systems, Society and Sustainability The global challenge of sustainable development requires solutions and mindsets that bridge traditional divisions between nature and culture, and the technical and social sciences. Sustainable development requires that engineers and other professionals are able to include social and ecological considerations alongside technical and economic requirements in managing projects and infrastructure. This course outlines…

Words 3727 - Pages 15

Can Consumption Ever Be Ethical

Introduction This paper seeks to unravel the possibilities, likelihood and future of ethical consumption. In order to answer the question ‘Can consumption ever be ethical?’ the definition of ethical consumerism must be deconstructed and operationalized. Ethics is the human measurement of morale, a philosophical framework through which human value can be measured and assessed. Consumption is an interactive process of buy and sell and it is therefore necessary to define which human activities in this process…

Words 2312 - Pages 10

Discrimination and Kumra s. Essay

Liverpool john moores university | 6004BUSHR | Maureen Royce | Equality & Ethics | 462663 | | Hand in date: 16th November 2012 Equality & Ethics Assignment PART A Discuss the definitions and theories of equality and diversity and select one of these theories as the basis for assessing equality practice in an organisation of your choosing. Equality ‘The most intuitive meaning of equality is that everybody should be treated equally. This is referred to as…

Words 852 - Pages 4

freedom of politics coursework Essay

12 February 1804) was a Prussian philosopher who is widely considered to be a central figure of modern philosophy. His thought continues to have a major influence in contemporary thought, especially in fields such as metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, and political philosophy.” Kant, Immanuel; Kitcher, Patricia (intro.); Pluhar, W. (trans.) (1996). Critique of Pure Reason. Indianapolis: Hackett. xxviii. 2 Funk, Rainer (2000). 3 Berlin, I. (1958). 4 Charles Margrave Taylor, is…

Words 2402 - Pages 10

Social Workers Code Of Ethics Paper

the National Association of Social Workers Code of Ethics specific to evaluation and research 5.02. Participants involved in the evaluation of support must receive an explanation for the evaluation, have the right to a written informed consent, rights to withdrawal from the evaluation, and have access to supportive appropriate supportive services (National Association of Social Workers, 2008). National Association of Social Workers code of ethics…

Words 343 - Pages 2

Essay about Literature: Business Ethics

INTERNATIONAL GRADUATE DIPLOMA PROGRAMME Research skills Business ethics is often described as very old new subjects. This might seems like a strange statement, but it reflects the development of the discipline. On the other hand, ethical thinking has its roots in the writings of the great philosophers like Socrates and Confucius. (Roger Bradburn, 2001). As an academic subject it has only come of age since the Wall Street scandals of the 1980s…

Words 568 - Pages 3

Essay about Privacy: National Security Agency and Privacy Rights

to abuse their power and strip citizens of rights for reasons that may not be justified. Now, some people will surely argue that giving up a few privacy rights is a small cost for making sure our country is safe. In his essay, “Invisible Man: Ethics in a World Without Secrets,” philosopher Peter Singer suggests that people will be more honest and altruistic if they feel that they are being watched, referring to Focault’s idea of the “panopticon” as an ideal model.1 Human beings are easily influenced…

Words 1800 - Pages 8

Ethics In American Politics

Louise Barnum Jennie Hensarling English 101 March 8, 2015 Ethics in American Politics The ideas of ethics in American Politics have long been not only believed by the public but skewed by the individuals in office. It is in this mindset that we question exactly why we put the government in charge so frequently and where the morals have gone. We find that we have duties to ourselves, commitments to others, and obligations to our life as a whole. We find that we are often strung between what may…

Words 593 - Pages 3

Ethics and Canadian Nurses Association Essay

Critical Thinking for Nurses: Reflective Journal Two George Brown College NURS 9184 October 14, 2014 Critical Thinking for Nurses: Reflective Journal Two What are the roles of the code of ethics for nurses, the standards of practice, and the laws in making nursing decisions? Since the inception of morality from the era of the great thinkers like Plato, Socrates, and other celebrated philosophers of the time; and presently to the highest seat occupied by a public trustee; to the office of the integrity…

Words 874 - Pages 4

Thrasymachus Definition of Justice in Plato's Republic Essay

The remaining fragments of Thrasymachus’ writings provide few clues about his philosophical ideas. They either deal with rhetorical issues or they are excerpts from speeches (DK 85b1 and b2) that were (probably) written for others and thus can hardly be seen as the expression of Thrasymachus’ own thoughts. The most interesting fragment is DK 85b8. It contains the claim that the gods do not care about human affairs since they do not seem to enforce justice. Scholars have, however, been divided whether…

Words 1177 - Pages 5