Ethics Case Study Essay

Submitted By bard1993
Words: 1046
Pages: 5
Open Document
Part A
Utilitarianism
In terms of utilitarianism theory, key stakeholders would include Tom, Tom’s parents, the company, co-workers in the company, charity. The below table would list the consequences (benefits and harms) by whether Tom exaggerate his work experience or not.
Stakeholders
Exaggerate-Benefits
Exaggerate-Harms
Not exaggerate -Benefits
Not exaggerate-Harms
Tom
Retained by the company and provide the life-saving sponsorship for children.
He may lose job when the truth comes out and it would affect his future when he seeking a job.
He does not need to worry about any worse situations which may happen on him.
He would not obtain the job and cannot provide the sponsorship.
Tom’s parents
They could not support Tom and improve their financial position.
They need to continually support Tom.
They do not need worry about Tom’s characters.
Supporting Tom under a not good financial position.
The company
They may get a potential good employee.
They may get a potential bad employee.
They would not hire a dishonest employee.
They probably hire other person who is worse than Tom.
Co-workers
Working with a good graduate.
Probably affected by Tom in the work.
Completing job well with an experienced person.
Maybe work with a person worse than Tom.
Charity
Get the sponsorship from Tom.
None
None
Cannot get the sponsorship from Tom.
Weighing each stakeholder’s harms and benefits by Tom exaggerates his work experience on his curriculum vitae that appears the benefits of consequence are outweighing harms. A potential fact should be considered is that Tom has good GPA on accounting, so he might be capable to complete his job well and would minimise the risk to his job. So the harms may not happen if Tom does his job well.
Overall, I think Tom’s behaviour is ethical by weighing consequences.

Kantian ethics
By testing Tom’s duty for universal acceptability, he would fail it. Firstly, he exaggerates his work experience on his curriculum vitae in order to get the job, so he cheats the company and telling lie. Tom would break universal law if he does so. Furthermore, Tom’s behaviour would not meet the consistently universal, because of the company must be in trouble if everyone do this. According Kantian’s ethics, everyone should tell the truth, that is the universal consistent law.
For the respect part, he would fail it. Tom’s behaviour is telling lie, which is not showing the respect to the company.
Overall, truth telling is a vital factor in Kantian’s theory. So Tom cannot meet both principles of universal acceptability and respect because of telling lie. He does not follow duties and against categorical imperative as well.

Virtue ethics
For virtue ethics, I am going to apply sincerity in expression (truthfulness) in Tom’s dilemma. Tom’s action is against the virtue in terms of truthfulness, he is not telling truth when he exaggerating. Moreover, Tom’s action turns him into means rather than ends, because he telling lie in order to get a job. Telling lie is actually against truthfulness and is not a virtuous person in this situation would do.
In brief, Tom’s action is not ethical under virtue ethics.

Ranking of ethical theories
In my opinion, the most useful for resolving my own ethical dilemmas is virtue ethics theory, and then is Kantian ethics theory and the least useful theory is utilitarianism. In comparison with Kantian ethics theory and utilitarianism, virtue ethics theory can address most ethical dilemmas, and also can meet other two theories in most situations. I think most of time I just need follow a virtue and take the consequence and be honest into account, and then most of situation can be addressed ethically. The disadvantage of Kantian’s ethics theory is some time we must telling lie when we meet some extreme situations. The principle in this theory is not flexible like virtue ethics theory, and truth telling is also being included in virtue. Utilitarianism may
Show More

Related Documents: Ethics Case Study Essay

Essay Ethics Case Study

Ethics Case Study Yesenia Echavarria HCS 335 October 13,2014 Beryl Keegan Abstract In present day’s health care culture certain individuals are accessible to assume illegal medical actions based on individual guidance; but ethical and legal concerns result one’s activities if he/ she is not authorized to make such choices. The situation of Jerry McCall is an instance of such a situation in present day’s health care atmosphere. While Jerry is qualified as a medical assistant and a licensed practical…

Words 725 - Pages 3

Formal Ethics Case Study

1. Is Formal Ethics Training in Organizations Merely Cosmetic? I disagree that Formal Ethics Training in Organizations is merely cosmetic. Formal Ethics Training is used in organization to communicate the standards and procedures of the organization, as well as other key factors of the ethics and compliance programs. (D. E. Warren, J.P. Gasper & W.S. Laufer 2014). However, does it really mean that Formal Ethics Training is merely cosmetic, which means it just improved the image of the Organization…

Words 1855 - Pages 8

Marketing Ethics Case Study

Marketing ethics Case Study Lei FENG 1187662 Table of Contents 1. Background 2 2. Ethical issues 2 3. Stakeholders 4 4. Stakeholders analysis 6 5. Recommendations 7 6. References 10 1. Background In this age, the development of the world can not without oil. British Petroleum (BP) is the largest energy cooperation…

Words 1970 - Pages 8

Ethics Case Study: Verizon

with existing customers. Furthermore, ethics exist to help minimize the negative effects of employee behavior while insuring a company sustains healthy competition as well as socially responsible behavior. Moreover, an organization can only preserve ethical standards by upper management setting ethics as top priority. Therefore, ethical standards is a continuous effort that requires professional and workplace training. Most importantly, a strong ethics culture should be built over time with management…

Words 107 - Pages 1

Case Study Nasw Code Of Ethics

of cultural competence is; “social workers shall function in accordance with the values, ethics and standards of the NASW Code of Ethics…("NASW cultural standards," n.d.).” Unfortunately the social worker in this case study was found to have violated the code of ethics. She did not receive appropriate consent to work with the students. It would be important for the social worker to read the NASW Code of Ethics to better understand informed consent. She should also seek supervision where she can receive…

Words 244 - Pages 1

Nursing Ethics Case Study

Isfahan University of Medical Sciences. Conflict of Interest: None REFERENCES 1. Jhonstone MJ. 4th ed. Sydney: Churchill Livingstone Publisher, 2004. Bio Ethics: A Nursing perspective, pp 120-4 2. Chitty KK, Beth BP. 5th ed. St Louis: Saunders Elsevier, 2007 Professional nursing concepts and challenge, pp 522-5. 3. King CA, Broom C. Ethics in perioperative practice-values, integrity, and social policy. AORN J. 2002,76:1047-53. 4. Abaszadeh A, Abedi HA, Sharif F, Ghofani F. A model of develop and…

Words 427 - Pages 2

Sexual Ethics Case Study

Sexuality is a sensitive topic in today’s societies due to the prevalence of sexual assault and harassment against men and women in everyday life. This issue has been underreported and the arduous legal process involved with prosecution allows perpetrators to walk free, breeding a culture which accepts such acts. Harry is certainly a contributor to this problem, made especially troubling by his position of power as CEO of a large corporation. Many adults struggle with finding jobs to support a basic…

Words 1229 - Pages 5

NASW Code Of Ethics Case Study

Code of Ethics “offers a set of values, principles, and standards to guide decision making and conduct when ethical issues arise.” In the case of the Doe family, there are many conflicting issues presented that requires attention. As a social worker providing the necessary services to further assist this family is an essential and professional role to perform. In dealing with is case study the standards of “Informed Consent” and “Commitment to Clients”, stated from the NASW Code of Ethics, will be…

Words 592 - Pages 3

Essay about Ethics Case Study

Case Study 12/9/12 The last job I had was at a busy call center. We had a strict attendance policy. During the probationary period an employee was allowed to have four “occurrences” (the way it counted to human resources depended largely on the situation, but if you missed work it was an occurrence none-the-less) before an employee was terminated. One of my employees did not make it for reasons that should not have counted against her. She did miss a lot of work but each time it was for a…

Words 1511 - Pages 7

Essay on Ethics Case Study 1

Jenya Karpitskiy Professor Middleton Business Ethics 14 February 2014 Case Study 1: Violent Video Games Public expectations for businesses fall under immense pressure and can easily impact the image of any company. Video game producers are highly affected by social responsibility for the negative effects of video games displayed by the users. Studies have shown that violence has a “positive link with more aggression while others show no correlation” with violent behavior linked to video games1 (Rae…

Words 870 - Pages 4