The Evolution Of The Doctrine Of Direct Effect On EU Law

Submitted By taiyabh
Words: 2470
Pages: 10
Open Document
Critically discuss the evolution of the doctrine of direct effect and whether the current case-law of the Court of Justice is satisfactory for individuals who wish to have their EU rights enforced vis-à-vis other individuals before national courts.

Module: EU Law
Word count: 2512

Aims
The following assignment will administer an analytical view of one of the central elements of European law; the doctrine of direct effect & assess how legal uncertainty arises for an individual who wishes to exercise a right against an individual before the national courts. This project will measure the position of the Court of Justice in its implementation of EU law on member states and how this may question the credibility and sovereignty of national law.
Introduction
First and foremost, one must understand the doctrine of supremacy to fully comprehend the principle of direct effect. Developed by the European Court of Justice(ECJ), it ensures the supremacy of EU law over national law of member states. The principle stems from the case of Flaminio Costa v Enel1 which referred to Article 5 of the European Economic Community Treaty(EEC); ensuring the fulfilment of a member's community obligations arising from the Treaty and abstain from any measure which may jeopardise this. Thus, national law conflicting with EU law is automatically inapplicable, and renders any new legislation, incompatible with EU law, a similar fate; a prime example in the form of Amministrazione delle Finanze v Simmenthal Spa 2
However, Ministero delle finanze v IN.CO.GE ’903 suggest Simmenthal did not encompass that national law in such a case of conflict was non-existent, but rather that the national court was obliged to “dissapply” conflicting national law4. In layman's terms, national law will stand but in the occasion were it challenges EU law, it must be ignored.
Doctrine of Direct Effect
To define direct effects is a troublesome predicament due to its complexity and depth, however, it can be summarised as a community concept developed by the ECJ to apply to Regulations, Directives and Treaty Articles. It is the term given to the judicial enforcement of rights arising from provisions of Community law which can be upheld in favour of individuals over national authorities5. Lord Denning's remarks in the case of HP Bulmer Ltd v J Bollinger SA 6 epitomise the authority possessed in direct effects stating;
'Any rights or obligation created by the treaty(European Communities Act(1972) are to be given legal effect in England without more ado'.7
Treaty Articles
The evolution of this concept originates from the case of Van Gend 8. It surrounded the inclusion of custom duty on goods imported from Germany to the Netherlands. This was contrary to the provision of the 'freedom of movement of goods'(currently Article 30 Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union(TFEU); imposing the prohibition of custom duties. The prosecution(importer) brought proceedings to recover the custom duty
The principal matter in this case was the question of the direct effects of Article 12(now 25) which prohibited customs on imports/exports between member states. 9
Does the prohibition of custom duties confer rights to an individual that can be subsequently enforced before national courts?
Affirmative. The ECJ confirmed Article 25(ex 12), was directly effective. The court ruled the Treaty far exceeded an agreement which simply created mutual obligations. Furthermore, it intended to confer rights upon individuals which became part of their legal heritage and impose obligations for that matter10 although some may argue that it undermined the legal authority of member states.
Subsequent developments
Van Gend also established the criteria a provision must satisfy to have direct effect. The ECJ require that the provision: should be unconditional; Not susceptible to further conditions to be deemed functionable. Nor it requires any implementation
Show More

Related Documents: The Evolution Of The Doctrine Of Direct Effect On EU Law

EU LAW Essay

EU LAW Lecture 1- Wednesday 8th October 2014 Before 1957- Second World War (1945) - without US funding it would be difficult for Europe to rebuild itself. France and Germany- extremely competitive European coal and steel community (1951) The ECSC came with the aim of organising free movement of coal and steel and free access to sources of production. In addition to this, a common High Authority supervised the market, respect for competition rules and price transparency. It involved cooperation…

Words 2293 - Pages 10

Essay about Uk Employment Law and Eu Influence

Introduction Over time, both the volume and complexity of employment law that originates in the EU has grown considerably. When the UK joined the European Economic Community (EEC) in 1973, membership brought with it few requirements in the field of employment regulation. The Treaty of Rome contained an article committing member states to enforce the principle of equal pay for equal work between men and women, but this was already in the process of being introduced in the UK at that time. Later…

Words 3322 - Pages 14

Parliamentary Sovereignty Is Relevant To The United Kingdom

over all other institutions, for instance judiciary; the Parliament, therefore, can make or unmake any law, and this law cannot be overridden or set aside by anyone . Some critics argue that the doctrine of Parliamentary supremacy is no longer relevant to the United Kingdom. United Kingdom had become the member of the European Union in 1972, and it can be said that the supremacy of European Union law – as well as UK’s appreciation of human rights – renders parliamentary sovereignty obsolete and a relic…

Words 909 - Pages 4

BUSINESS LAW OUTCOME 1 Essay

BUSINESS LAW 1. Civil and criminal Law Statute Law European Legislation Common Law 2. War Crimes Act 1991 Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 Human Tissue Act 2004 Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 Sex Discrimination Act 1975 3. Judicial Precedent is the most important element of common law. The doctrine of judicial precedent lies the principle of stare decisis (standing by decisions) the decisions of the higher courts are said to be binding on the lower courts. In other words, the judges sitting in lower…

Words 383 - Pages 2

General Principles of European Union Law Essay

Community law………………………………………………………………...3 Interpretation of Community law…………………………………………………………….3 Non-discrimination on the basis of nationality/gender as fundamental principle………...4 Principle of proportionality…………………………………………………………………...5 Human rights in the European Union………………………………………………………..6 The direct effect of European law…………………………………………………………….7 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………...8…

Words 2882 - Pages 12

The Importance Of Privacy

public. As a result of the importance of privacy, there are privacy protection laws implemented in every country that might differ from one another. Living a life without these privacy laws can be miserable. One only need to read George Orwell’s 1984 to understand how a society without any privacy functions and operates as well as the daily life and psychology of individuals living in such society. There must be protection laws…

Words 1887 - Pages 8

The European Union As An International System Of Law

the European Union (EU) is an international system of law, thus being seen as a unique system of law formally known as 'suigerneris'. That this unique system in this case acts as a monist system, in which means that all states of the European Union are bound by EU law. Within the Treaty of Lisbon, declaration 17 we are told that ' Treaties and laws adopted by the Union on the basis of the Treaties have primacy over the law of member states' subsequently we are told further of EU supremacy In the case…

Words 2194 - Pages 9

Essay about EU decision making

Decision making process in the European Union: The EU in brief: At the heart of the decision making process are the EU Institutions, such as: the Parliament, the Council and the European Commission. Sovereignty Delegation (pooling): Member states delegate some of their decision-making powers to the shared institutions they have created, so decisions on specific matters of joint interest can be made democratically at European level. Created in 1950  built single market of goods and…

Words 3874 - Pages 16

European Union Essay

itself. These different councils set up rules, laws, enforce the rules and laws and try to be as fair for all countries within the European Union. The European Commission proposes legislation and help implements decisions. The current President of the European Commission is Jose Manuel Barroso from Portugal. There are 27 people from every country in the European Union that are on the European Commission and together they work to help create and pass laws while working with European Parliament and…

Words 618 - Pages 3

EU Seminar 4 Essay

art267(2) and (3) ).It’s the prerogative of the ECJ to decide whether a body is a court or a tribunal for this purpose and national law categorization is inconclusive as per the case of Corbiau v administration des contributions. The ECJ takes an inclusive approach as indicated in Dorsch Consult that may include whether the jurisdiction is compulsory,whether it applies rules of law,whether procedure is inter partes..however the case of Cartesio at para56-7 emphasized that a reference can only be made if…

Words 2824 - Pages 12