Euthyphro Essay

Words: 1289
Pages: 6
Open Document
Analysis of Euthyphro
Nikon121
PHI 200
Bob Harris
October 15, 2012

Analysis of Euthyphro Socrates was put to death in Athens for subverting the youth of the city. He was indicted by Meletus and awaiting his trail on the porch of the King of Archon when he met Euthyphro. It was at this point he engaged in a debate about piety. In this paper, I will examine that debate and present my own conclusion about its purpose as well as my own definition of piety.
Holiness, or piousness, is the center of the conversation between Socrates and Euthyphro. Both of the men met on the porch of the King to deal with a legal matter; Socrates the defendant and Euthyphro the plaintiff. Socrates was being charged with …show more content…
This definition falls short in that it does not clearly show the benefit gained by the gods in this perceived business deal. It only seems to suggest that they find the act pleasing, which seems to lead back to the third definition. This definition commits a common fallacy termed Begging the Question. It defines pious as being pious because it is pious, which is not much of an answer. Socrates goal in this conversation is to understand piety, so that he can defend himself in his hearing. However, I believe that this piece has a deeper goal that belonged to Plato. It seemed that he wished to expose piety for the sham that it is to shame those that executed Socrates. I believe this because before Socrates was executed he asked that a goat be sacrificed to the god of medicine. I believe this showed that he believed in an afterlife, which indicates belief in the gods. I believe that this dialogue did not actually happen and was simply written by Plato after the death of his teacher. I think this is shown through the nature of the character of Euthyphro. He was a self-proclaimed expert on piety, as most piety experts are, and he failed to have an intelligent response to any question posed by Socrates. After failing miserably to give a satisfactory answer, he ran off. I believe this demonstrates that Plato was using this piece to put piety itself on trial. I am not a very stout
Show More

Related Documents: Euthyphro Essay

Socrates And Euthyphro

swimmer. Socrates could not be seen as an archetypal social scientist but the archetype for philosophy. In “Euthyphro”, Socrates encounters Euthyphro at the courthouse and embarks on a discussion of why both of them are there. Euthyphro states that he is there to prosecute his own father because of a murder he committed against one of his workers. Socrates persists on questioning Euthyphro on what impiety is. At the end, Socrates never got his answer.…

Words 1280 - Pages 6

Euthyphro essay

people of the flaws in their beliefs, and show them that the only viable relationship is that Piety is a part of Justice. In order to effectively analyze and understand the relationship between Piety and Justice, we must first define Piety. In The Euthyphro, several definitions are put forth for Piety, but the most compelling one to me is this. “Speaking freely, however, I can tell you that if a man knows how to say and do things acceptable to the gods in prayer and sacrifice, those things are holy…

Words 917 - Pages 4

Euthyphro Analysis

Euthyphro Plato’s dialog, Euthyphro, gives an account of one of Socrates many encounters with someone who claims to be wise. Always seeking to increase his own knowledge, Socrates attempts to determine if the man is truly wise and if there is anything that he is able to learn from him. He does this by using the method of refutation, which allows the interlocutor to refute themselves using their own statements and beliefs. The dialog begins with Socrates going to the court of Athens to face charges…

Words 672 - Pages 3

Euthyphro Analysis

In this article ‘Euthyphro’, there are two main characters: Socrates and Euthyphro, discussing and arguing about ‘what is the pious and the impious.’ Because the man indicted Socrates for being impiety, Socrates wanted to find out what exactly are pious and impious from smart young man Euthyphro. So they start talking… First, Euthyphro says that the pious is prosecuting someone who is guilty of wrongdoing, either of murder or temple robbery or anything else of the sort, whether it happens to be…

Words 348 - Pages 2

Euthyphro and Piety Essay

Running Head: Euthyphro 1 Euthyphro Eneasha Ackles PHI208: Ethics and Moral Reasoning Instructor Craig Thompson September 30, 2013 Running Head: Euthyphro 2 Euthyphro Euthyphro, is a quest for wisdom and the definition of holiness/piety. The dialogue Euthyphro was written by Socrates' protege Plato during the weeks leading up Socrates' trial in which he was accused of corrupting the youth in Athens. It features Socrates and religious expert…

Words 1057 - Pages 5

Euthyphro Pious Analysis

In Euthyphro, Socrates and Euthyphro contemplate what it means to be pious. Socrates and Euthyphro discuss what makes an action pious or impious. This is the root of their discussion, but the most important concept that they strive to define is piety. This definition is important to analyze because, specifically within religious beliefs, it weighs heavily on the conscious of men and is the basis on which the gods may punish you for wrongdoing. Unfortunately, the end result is not a clear definition…

Words 785 - Pages 4

Rhetorical Analysis On Euthyphro

Euthyphro focuses on what is pious and impious for this section, describing pious as “what all gods love” and impious as “what all gods hate”. Socrates states, "I give you that all the Gods hate what your father did; I waive the point about one God's hating what another God loves; if you like, say that the pious is what all the Gods love and the impious is what all the Gods hate, so as to be sure that the same act is not both pious and impious. Even so, will your account of piety and impiety stand…

Words 303 - Pages 2

Euthyphro and Socrates Essay

Patrick Shepard Pete Puckett English 101 8/28/2013 “Euthyphro” By Plato The telling of this conversation between Socrates and Euthyphro by Plato is one where Plato was the student of Socrates at one time. Plato identifies Socrates initially seeking instruction from Euthyphro since he’s in jail for impiety and Socrates discovers that Euthyphro is there to put his father away for murder in his own case. Socrates flatters him by telling him that he must be an expert of all religious things. Socrates…

Words 302 - Pages 2

Euthyphro and Mysticism Essay

| Euthyphro and Mysticism | Angela Smoulder | | Philosophy 101-01 | 9/21/2012 | | The definition of division causes a basis of argument in Plato’s “Euthyphro”. While awaiting trial, Euthyphro explains that he has brought his father in front of the Judge with a murder charge. The idea of bring one’s own father to court brings forth room for debate between Socrates and Euthyphro. The main question being what is the definition of piety? The main reason that Socrates asks…

Words 1398 - Pages 6

Euthyphro Vs Socrates

and Euthyphro are in disagreement was the nature of the holy or the nature of the piety. Socrates asks “What sort of thing would you say that the pious and the impious are, whether in murder or in other matters? Isn’t the holy itself the same as itself in every action?” (p7, 5c11- 5d2). Socrates was seeking essential knowledge, seeking to know the inner nature of what is holy, not what it is like, not someone else’s opinion about it, but what is in it that makes it holy or unholy. Euthyphro who…

Words 666 - Pages 3