Evaluating Truth And Validity Exercise

Words: 932
Pages: 4
Open Document
Evaluating Truth and Validity Exercise
PHL/458
July 7th, 2014
Richard Burgoon

Evaluating Truth and Validity Exercise The arguments I choose to assess for truth and validity will be three statements taken from the Application's list 12.2 (a -y) at the end of Ch. 12, “The Art of Thinking” publication. I will start with the statement (j) the premise that "power must be evil because it can corrupt people." Checking the argument for any hidden premises and ensuring it is stated fully and in a clear concise way is the first step. This argument seems to pass the first hurdle, however after checking for errors affecting truth, the argument has flaws. Beginning with, the part of the argument that says power corrupts people is not true …show more content…
The first statement, "Nuclear power is a threat to world peace," is not true as it is written. I would rewrite the statement to read, "Nuclear power used in the production of weaponry is a threat to world peace." There are many peaceful uses for nuclear energy, such as an alternative to fossil energy. The second statement is true; however, it would be placed in the peaceful uses category. This takes us to the step where we examine the argument for validity errors and examine the reasoning that links conclusions to premises. The premise was that nuclear power is a threat to world peace. I determined that statement, how it is written to be false. After inserting the qualifying statement "used in the production of weaponry," the statement is now in a better position to be defended. The conclusion that nuclear energy stations are a threat to world peace because they generate nuclear power is even more indefensible once the first statement has been revised. The qualifying statement "used in the production of weaponry" has changed everything. Unless the nuclear energy station is producing weapons, which most are used for producing clean energy, it is not a threat to world peace. The entire scenario would have to be rewritten, as “Nuclear power used in the production of weaponry is a threat to world peace. Since most nuclear energy stations are only used as an alternative energy source, these stations are not a threat to world peace.” As it says in step four of the
Show More

Related Documents: Evaluating Truth And Validity Exercise

What Is an Essay? Essay

The term "essay" is used in somewhat different ways in different contexts. The clearest definition I have encountered is by Frederick Crews, professor of English at the University of California at Berkeley. Crews defines an essay as "a fairly brief piece of nonfiction that tries to make a point in an interesting way." An essay is fairly brief. While writers will sometimes refer to book-length texts as "essays," the term usually refers to short pieces that might be published in a magazine…

Words 381 - Pages 2

The essay

The essay, The Enduring Appeal of Agatha Christie was very well written, and used a clear essay structure; following the order of writing. The introduction starts with the question “Who does not enjoy a good mystery?” which is a good method to grasp the readers’ attention. The paragraph guides from general to specific ideas, such as stating different authors to effectively influence a diverse group of readers, and creates an organized path to the thesis that is very eye-catching and prominent in…

Words 585 - Pages 3

Essay and Essay Concerning Human

gliauehrlgjhesrAn essay is a piece of writing which is often written from an author's personal point of view. Essays can consist of a number of elements, including: literary criticism, political manifestos, learned arguments, observations of daily life, recollections, and reflections of the author. The definition of an essay is vague, overlapping with those of an article and a short story. Almost all modern essays are written in prose, but works in verse have been dubbed essays (e.g. Alexander Pope's…

Words 729 - Pages 3

Writing and Essay

An essay can have many purposes, but the basic structure is the same no matter what. You may be writing an essay to argue for a particular point of view or to explain the steps necessary to complete a task. Either way, your essay will have the same basic format. If you follow a few simple steps, you will find that the essay almost writes itself. You will be responsible only for supplying ideas, which are the important part of the essay anyway. Don't let the thought of putting pen to paper…

Words 571 - Pages 3

personnal essay

Assignment Templates Don't be surprised if writing a personal essay is one of the first assignments you get upon returning to school. You know, "What I Did on My Summer Vacation." Be prepared. Personal essays are actually one of the easiest assignments, but like all other kinds of writing, there are specific aspects of the essay form your teacher will be looking for. Like not ending a sentence in a preposition. The personal essay is helpful to teachers because it gives them a snapshot right up…

Words 826 - Pages 4

Writing and Essay

An essay can have many purposes, such as an academic essay. You may be writing an essay to argue a point or to explain the steps to complete a task. If you follow a few simple steps, you will find that with practice, writing an essay can be easy to do. The first step in the process would be Prewriting. This is where you will transfer your thoughts onto paper. You will pick a topic, use your own personal experience and observations, read about the topic you choose, and free-write about the topic.…

Words 646 - Pages 3

Citation and Essay

Essay Writing Guide (Credit also to Natalya Hughes, Lawson Fletcher, James Meese and Raya Massie) An essay is a persuasive piece of writing. That means it must have an argument. All of the advice below is oriented towards this basic definition. Submission and Presentation Keep the assignment within the one document. Just start a new page for each section. Cover sheet should precede every digital essay, within the file – it’s no different to a physical one. The essay should be formatted as such:…

Words 2832 - Pages 12

joakim essay

ESSAY WRITING 101 ARGUMENT - What does the essay-question ask for? Dissect the question, define the key words in the question - Am I actually answering the question? - Does each sentence help answer the question (directly or indirectly)? If not, take it out! - How well am I supporting my argument? Is it convincing? - Be precise! Check your facts! There’s nothing more annoying than faulty information. - Make sure that you base your argument on academic sources. STRUCTURE/WRITING Is the structure…

Words 737 - Pages 3

astro essay

emails from your instructor for the date of the exam on this unit. 
Unit 4 Essay Assignment - Worth 2% of the Course Grade 

Now that you have completed all of the Unit 4 Parts and Interludes, a drop box labeled "Drop Box for Unit 4 Essay" will be accessible at the bottom of the Unit 4 table of contents. Pay close attention to the due date on the drop box, as no late essays will be accepted. 

Your assignment: 
Write an essay to summarize your thoughts about the philosophical aspects of the formation…

Words 317 - Pages 2

health essay

There is no pre-test/post-test this week, but please keep me updated with any questions you may have as well as your progress in the course as we move into Week 6. This week you will be writing an essay for the first time. I have included the rubric as a part of the assignments list. For your essays, you are required to write in APA-formatting, using a minimum of three resources. You cannot write this assignment and use yourself as a source; you must conduct research on this week’s topic. Please…

Words 1252 - Pages 6