Fight Club Essay

Submitted By DeanFites1
Words: 793
Pages: 4
Open Document
Dean Fites
Reasons for Fight Club “The first and second rule of fight club is you don’t talk about fight club” (Palahniuk 48-50). Fight Club is the perfect definition of what a film adaptation is. David Fincher’s Fight Club did a great job translating Chuck Palahniuk’s writing style to the screen. The book and the film are a perfect and there is little difference between the two. Although the similarities are clear, there are still some small differences. The ending of the film is the main difference from the novel. It is clear that there is a difference, but why did the filmmaker change it. First off, one difference between the novel and the film is how Tyler Durden and the narrator of the story met. In the book, the narrator meets Tyler on a nude beach while Tyler is constructing a sundial-like watch out of logs (Palahniuk 19). But in the movie they meet while they’re on a plane coming back from vacation when the narrator sees that they have the same briefcase (Fight Club). The filmmakers might’ve done this change because they wanted the film to be more of a family movie and not have them meet on a nude beach. Despite the movie having many lines that came right out of the book, the lines go to different characters than they did in the book. Many people probably didn’t see this difference but it is there. It is likely this was done because the narrator has the majority of the lines in the novel than any other character, though other character’s lines are also given to different people in the film (Radcliffe). For example, in the movie Tyler Durden gave a speech that was originally given by a mechanic in the book. One difference is that after the fight clubs are already underway Tyler and the narrator create something that they call Project Mayhem. The rules of Project Mayhem are much like the rules of Fight Club. In the film the ultimate objective of Project Mayhem is never revealed, but the narrator tells a police officer that he believes their goal is to blow up all the credit card companies (Fight Club). In the novel, Project Mayhem was to slow down humanity's advancement with technology and try to cause another Dark Age (Palahniuk 137). The filmmakers probably didn’t want to reveal the objective of Project Mayhem because they wanted to keep the audience guessing what the real objective was (Rurouni). The main difference between the novel and the film that everyone saw was the different endings. At the end of both the book and the movie the narrator shoots himself in order to get rid of Tyler Durden. At the end of the book, the narrator is found to be a patient in a mental hospital after shooting himself (Palahniuk 154). In the movie, the narrator simply watches as all of the major credit card buildings collapse (Fight Club). The movie entirely removes the scene in the mental hospital (Fight Club). The deletion of this
Show More

Related Documents: Fight Club Essay

Fight Club

The novel fight club is written by Chuck Palahniuk. Everybody have their own dreams and wishes in the world that they want them to achieve, but it is not easy to find out what is important in life and what is unimportant. Some people have difficulties about their lives about what they want, but on the other hand some people knows very well. Narrator in fight club has no idea what he wants and what is the meaning of his life. In the novel narrator was trying to escape from the consumer culture…

Words 1503 - Pages 7

Essay Fight Club

Hero’s Journey Fight Club 1. The World Of Common Day­ Tyler sells soap and is constantly flying city to city. He seems to have to perfect life but, he is not satisfied. 2. The Call to Adventure­ He meets the narrator who later calls himself Jack in an airplane. His world seems to have crumbled and it seems like a perfect opportunity for Tyler to start something. Tyler has always done the same thing; selling soap and constant travelling why not take this opportunity to change this? 3. Ref…

Words 521 - Pages 3

Masculinity In Fight Club

The novel Fight Club by American author Chuck Palahniuk presents many themes throughout the book. Some may be more noticeable than others. But it depends on the reader to choose what they believe the book is about. An analysis of the novel Fight Club reveals the ambiguity of its themes about identity and masculinity. Fight Club exhibits the contention that men in the present society have been decreased to an age of men that do nothing themselves, yet have moved toward becoming anesthetized…

Words 979 - Pages 4

Essay on Fight Club

Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk Protagonist: Narrator Antagonist: Tyler Durden Opinion I thought Fight Club was entertaining. I felt a bit sorry for the narrator because of his situation with his insomnia. I didn’t really like Tyler’s character because I thought he was too controlling and too angry at the world. I was shocked when I read that both characters were one person. It was a great twist. I would recommend this to guys mostly because I think the majority of girls I know wouldn’t appreciate it as much…

Words 397 - Pages 2

Capitalism In Fight Club

Our minds are everything to us it allows us to think feel and perceive the world around us yet we still underestimate the power it has to help us or deceive us. Fight Club takes advantage of this idea. Fight Club is about a nameless man who has been living a meaningless, dull life and is suffering from severe insomnia. He has been brainwashed into thinking that buying new furniture for his apartment will make him a more fulfilled human. Our narrator then finds himself going to local support groups…

Words 1644 - Pages 7

Fight Club Essay

we are in, each of us has our own desires to do something, to become something, or to have something. When the desire is big enough that we would fight for it, it becomes passion; it is something we are passionate about and also something that makes us the way we are. Both the main characters from two movies Adaptation by Spike Jonze (2003) and Fight Club by David Fincher (1999) have their owns desires and something that they fear. By analyzing these two movies, we can see how each individual character…

Words 1684 - Pages 7

Materialism In Fight Club

consumerism- the belief that it is good for people to spend a lot of money on goods and services. The film Fight Club, directed by David Fincher, is an anti-consumerist film that depicts Americans as materialistic consumers that are byproducts of society’s consumerist culture. Fight Club successfully portrayed the consumerist culture…

Words 713 - Pages 3

Identity In Fight Club's Fight Club

In modern society, the search for one’s identity and the impulse to be someone of significance drives all thoughts in actions in everyone’s life. The men that fight in Fight Club rediscover themselves and their primal nature. The personality of Tyler and the narrator seem so different, yet their character traits align throughout the novel. The physiological effects of having another identity within himself cause the narrator to ultimately collapse. The love triangle that the narrator describes…

Words 1261 - Pages 6

Fight Club Quotes

Age 8, First game: “Mom, I'm nervous, I” -- I was sincerely cut off by his mother when she said; “Jake, it will be okay, you can do this, go out there and score some goals.” She encouraged, then spoke again, “You can do it, dad and I both know you can, you just have to believe, remember when you told us you want to play for the Boston Bruins?” “Well If you put your mind to it and never give up, thrive to be the best and a good role model and leader you could be there one day, Imagine it…

Words 498 - Pages 2

Fight Club Monologue

“Abby,” I hear Pete yell as he jumps on my back. “Get off of me,” I said. That’s Pete, my best friend, we met two years ago. I remember one day when I was walking around town and I heard people fighting, not arguing but a full on fist fight. I walked around the corner to see two guys beating up this small boy. Not wanting to leave him to get beaten, I ran over and yelled at the two boys. They were embarrassed to be yelled at by a girl, so they left. I helped Pete up and I remember looking at him…

Words 1044 - Pages 5