Film Critique Essay

Submitted By macker10
Words: 1450
Pages: 6
Open Document
Film Critique

The film “In Whose Honor?” discusses Chief Illiniwek as the mascot of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and the effects it had on Native American people. The mascot and symbol was associated with the university’s intercollegiate athletic programs for over 80 years and was portrayed by a student dressed in Sioux clothing. The student performed dances during football, basketball and volleyball games to entertain fans and help build school spirit. Chief Illiniwek was the center of controversy for over 20 years because many thought that the Chief misappropriated Native American culture and brought about harmful racial and ethnic stereotypes. In the film, graduate student Charlene Teters explains the impact that the Chief had on her and her children. After facing ridicule and much criticism, Charlene Teters is able to successfully lead the initiative in retiring Chief Illiniwek as the mascot and symbol of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Also included in the film are many interviews with various members of the university’s trustees, students, alumni, fans and community members.
Early in the film Charlene Teters talks about taking her children to a University of Illinois Fighting Illini basketball game. Before the game starts, a student dressed up as Chief Illiniwek goes out on the court and does a dance. Teters describes the sadness and hurtful emotions that she and her children experienced when watching the dance as they are taught growing up to respect the Chief and the ways in which he is shown are degrading towards Teters and her children. When University of Illinois Trustee Susan Gravenhorst is asked about Chief Illiniwek and how he could be seen as promoting an inaccurate image of Native Americans, she responds saying, “I can’t imagine that the Chief, who deports himself, whomever serves as the Chief, deports himself with such dignity, and such solemnity. I can’t imagine that that can be perceived as a racial insult or as a slur on the Native American community. To me, it’s a compliment” (Rosenstein). This insensitivity shown here by trustees like Gravenhorst demonstrates the ignorance that they have towards respecting the Native American culture. Gravenhorst and others throughout the film claim that Chief Illiniwek was a revered symbol that represented the great spirit of a great university. While they may have thought that Chief Illiniwek was a focal point for university games that drew everyone together, it actually distanced Native Americans further from everyone else. Recognizing and understanding other peoples cultures, in this case Native American culture, is important in today’s society because of the role representation plays in identifying culture production. In the article “The First Americans” by Matthew Snipp, he confirms this by saying, “Preserving their culture and identity is an especially pressing concern. However, urban Indians have successfully adapted to city environments in ways that preserve valued customs and activities—powwows, for example, are an important event in all cities where there is a large Indian community” (Andersen and Collins 199). I agree with Snipp here that maintaining the Native American culture is something that is very important. Native Americans continue to be one of the smallest minorities groups and are at a disadvantage in terms of people understanding their culture and traditions. They are continually looked down upon and often overlooked when it comes to issues of race and ethnic stereotyping. Many people may not realize it, but the treatment towards Native Americans causes pain and suffering to people like Charlene Teters and her family. Taking a more concerned effort to learn about them and appreciate them will help enable them to flourish and feel valued as members of our communities. Diversity is becoming more apparent of American culture today; and realizing that how we treat people that are
Show More

Related Documents: Film Critique Essay

Film Critique Paper

deception. Viola shows everyone that she is a girl by showing off her breasts in front of the whole audience. The coach agrees to let Viola keep playing and tells the Cornwall coach that Illyria does not discriminate based on gender. At the end of the film, Duke and Viola are on the same soccer team at Illyria. She’s the Man shows many different concepts we have spoken about in class. Gender roles, male behavior, and images of women are specific themes that are displayed through this movie. Gender…

Words 1903 - Pages 8

Vampyr Film Critique Essay

Mary Film Critique Vampyr May 6, 1932 Directed by: Carl Theodor Dreyer Produced by: Tobis-Klangfilm Starring: Julian West, Maurice Schutz, Rena Mandel “The Dead, not at peace because of the terrible deed they did while living, rise from their coffins…” Vampires. In a world of shadows and darkness, they creep through the dark seeking a victim’s blood. The protagonist, Allan Gray, studied vampires and other horrors of the night never thinking the supernatural could come into his own world…

Words 1827 - Pages 8

Final Film Critique Essay

Final Film Critique Richard Hogan ENG 225: Introduction to Film October 25, 2011 Final Film Critique Introduction The movie, The Shawshank Redemption (1994), is based on a character Andy Dufresne. Andy is a young and successful banker who is sent to Shawshank Prison for murdering his wife and her secret lover. His life is changed drastically upon being convicted and being sent to prison. He is sent to prison to serve a life term. Over the 20-years in prison, Andy retains optimism…

Words 2441 - Pages 10

Marketing: Film and Film Critique Assignment Essay

Film Critique Assignment: The “Revew” The assignment provides an opportunity to start writing about film (one of the student’s choosing), the only caveat being that the word ‘I’ cannot appear in the review. Hence, ‘revew.’ Shying away from phrases such as ‘I liked this…’ will force students to start to articulate their thoughts about film in a manner closer to the critical essays to come, while still remaining in the comfort zone of a more surface level evaluation in the form of a traditional,…

Words 521 - Pages 3

Film Critique 1 Essay

Megan Kolbe CSDS 1220 5 October 2014 Film Critique #1 The King’s Speech 1. What is the plot of the film? The King’s Speech tells a story of a man who becomes the king. George, better known as “Bertie”, takes the throne after the abdication of his brother. Bertie is very hesitant about this big step. He feels he is not fit to be king due to his stutter. His wife seeks help from an Australian speech therapist, Lionel Logue, who we learn later, has not attended prestige schooling and has very untraditional…

Words 837 - Pages 4

Flight Film Critique Essay

Flight Film Critique You can fly in planes all the time and try to experience a crash landing for yourself, or you can watch Flight and feel like you are in the plane that is crash landing. Flight was written by John Gatins and directed by Robert Zemeckis. Key cast members were Denzel Washington, Kelly Reilly, John Goodman, Don Cheadle, and Justin Martin. Flight is based on true real-life events “occurred in 2001, when Canadian Captain Robert Piche skillfully glided a fuel-less Airbus 330 to a safe…

Words 1276 - Pages 6

Miss Ever's Boys Film critique Essay

Introduction Miss Ever’s Boys is a docudrama film that was produced by the HBO cable network. The movie explores ethical and social issues involved in the infamous Tuskegee Study. The study was about untreated black men with syphilis. The U.S. Public Health Service is said to have conducted a study among 600 black Americans from the years 1932 to 1972. This study was done in Macon County. This paper will exclusively explore the critique the Miss Ever’s Boys film using ethical frameworks. The ethical framework…

Words 1010 - Pages 5

Essay on Death and the Maiden Film Critique

Roman Polanski’s production of Death and the Maiden assuages and refines the tormenting and vulgar play by Ariel Dorfman into a guiltless viewership. The horrors of a tortured mind remain placidly hindered by a film screen as Rafael Yglesias sands the play into an unambiguous, verging on facile, screenplay of one woman’s quest for justice in post-dictatorial regime. The reproachful, introspective nature of the original play is resigned in favor of a cookie-cutter portrayal of victim, criminal, and…

Words 2715 - Pages 11

Legally Blonde: Film Critique Essay

Legally Blonde Summary Elle Woods (Reese Witherspoon) goes through many tolls to get her ex boyfriend Warner Huntington III (Matthew Davis) back after being dumped on a night she expected a proposal. Warner, focused only on being a successful senator, dumps Elle because she doesn’t fit the profile of a “smart trophy wife”. Elle decides to show Warner that she can be serious by applying to Harvard. Unfortunately, over the summer Warner found a more serious girlfriend and proposed to her leaving…

Words 1142 - Pages 5

Hamlet Film Critique Rough Essay

hurriedly, and swallow less of the words than is the general rule with Shakespearean productions. Even though Zeffirelli cuts out many of the words in Hamlet, it does not seem like he did in the Shakespearean productions. Other then the fact that his films are shorter. Without a doubt, I understand Hamlet better now that I've seen Zeffirelli's version. For example, just as the play-within-the-play mirrors the major action, so too does Laertes mirror Hamlet and his situation when he lets Claudius…

Words 511 - Pages 3