SEMESTER I
2009-2010
BATTLESHIP POTEMKIN vs. PLEASANTVILLE
Number of words: 1048
Battleship Potemkin is a 1925 silent film, whereas Pleasantville is a 1990’s movie
based on a story that is set in the 1950’s .
Many different techniques have been used in order to create special effects
outlining the main ideas of both movies. The purpose of this essay is to compare and
contrast the use of colours, sounds and the movements of the cameras that suggest the
political theme in both films.
Firstly, I am going to be discussing the different colours used in both movies. Its
use is fundamental in putting across the basic message of the films: In Pleasantville it
suggests that change is an indispensable part of life, whereas in Battleship Potemkin the
use of only black and white colours emphasizes the fact that it is an old movie. It is
entirely a black and white production that shocked for its use of violence, but also a silent
one that “reaches the emotions on a visual level”(Mayer, 1990). It explains the story of
the crew of the Russian battleship Potemkin that revolted against their executives
representing the Tsarist system. This sequence suggests the desire for freedom and
autonomy of the Russian empire. In Pleasantville, the director, uses colours to show the
differences between two worlds. Black and white images represent a world of morality
where people must respect the law. For example, the idea of sex is meaningless to them.
Colours are used to express a world of opportunities: an exciting place where rules are
broken and new things are discovered, like the pleasure of reading. Colours also represent
the modern society, while black and white are related to the traditional society, ruled by
strict conventions.
Once the two siblings (Bud and Mary) appear, the pleasant world, presented in a
TV sitcom becomes to change. They bring new conceptions into the world converting the
black and white background and people into enriched ones, contrast that defines aspects
of human conditions. In the clip that shows the court case, the people in black and white
have power whereas those that are portrayed in colour are segregated in the upper part of
the room. This can be seen as discrimination and racism, a common problem in the world
today, too. The court case was caused as a consequence to the fact that the pleasant world
started to change and rules began to be broken. . More and more people started to do
something they desired and this desire went beyond the limits of society. By discovering
the joy of life or the feeling of a disappointment they turned coloured. Those that didn’t
accept any change in their lives, like the mayor, saw this as an immoral and unusual fact.
Different colours that are used have different meanings. For example, in this clip of the
court case Bud wears a blue T-shirt, which could be associated with a reasonable and
confident person, qualities that help him say what he thinks in front of some of the
citizens of Pleasantville. This relates to the political theme of the movie by presenting all
the important people in the town that take decisions gathered altogether.
Secondly, the use of camera and the editing play important roles in making movies. In
Battleship Potemkin, the director expresses his own theory, known in film language as
“montage”. The so-called “the Soviet montage” could be clearly seen in the most famous
scene in the film, known as Odessa steps. It shows the mass execution of the citizens of
Odessa by the Tsar’s representatives, as an episode of the Russian Revolution. This clip
has a dramatic effect on viewers; its purpose is to portray Russians as a powerful and
influential nation, after a catastrophic loss in the First