Film: What Makes You Your Gender?

Words: 1330
Pages: 6
Open Document
Isaac, another kid from the documentary, offers an answer to those questions. He too began transitioning at a young age like Ariel. He cut his hair, started wearing masculine clothes, and began taking testosterone hormones at age fifteen. It’s “a super fun drug in some ways,” Isaac said, “without doing anything, you just grow like more muscle. It gives this sort of deep booming voice, and all this extra hair you can play with” (Isaac Preiss, What Makes You Your Gender?). He revelled in all of his new physical characteristics. However, unlike Ariel, Isaac had the privilege of hindsight at the age of nineteen. He knew that he was a boy mentally, but he wanted to become one physically as well. And that was why he turned to testosterone. After …show more content…
He said that at age 16, he “essentially ended up rejecting the idea of gender entirely” (Frontline). He finally had the masculine features he wanted, but there was no longer the need to perform. In this way, Isaac was like Preciado, who used hormones to not change his gender, but to hack it. Preciado says that “I’m not taking testosterone to change myself into a man or as a physical strategy of transsexualism; I take it to foil what society wanted to make of me…” (Preciado 16). Preciado and Isaac both receive a fair amount of backlash due to their use of testosterone in a nonconventional way. Many people thought that Isaac was “self-hating and delegitimizing anyone who has undergone medical transition” (frontline) and others judged Preciado because he “took testosterone outside the aegis of a medical protocol, without wanting to become a man..” (Preciado 56). Both used testosterone in a way that pleased them and their needs. The writer Gary Greenberg, who discusses the advantages and setbacks of defending the biological causes of homosexuality versus the belief that homosexuality is a choice in his essay “The Science of Sexual Identity”, uses a term that describes the action of personally molding one’s characteristics: “self-reconstruction” (Greenberg …show more content…
All the kids in the documentary are in some way, reconstructing their biological makeup. Greenberg writes that sexual orientation, and even gender identity, “is inborn and immutable” (Greenberg 3). And yet, the need to take hormones to adhere to one’s internal identity makes it seem as though transitioning is some sort of illness that must be fixed. The majority of the kids felt like, as Preciado puts it, “gender dysphorics” (Preciado 55). Gender dysphoria occurs when one’s body does not match the gender that they feel to be true. Ariel and Isaac felt as though their bodies needed to match with their internal genders, or else they would feel unsatisfied with their lives. That dissatisfaction, many critics of transsexualism believe, is simply because they are deviating from the norm of cisgender. Cisgender means that one feels and identifies with the gender they were assigned at birth. Like the ex-gay men from Greenberg's writing who decide to stop being gay, many people, including the parents of some of these children, believe that transgender people have the decision to be trans or not. That is not true, as Greenberg explains, because reparative therapy or denial only “leads people to repress rather than change their natural inclinations” (Greenberg 3). He also writes that sexual orientation, like being trans, “is so deeply woven into a person’s identity that it is inseparable
Show More

Related Documents: Film: What Makes You Your Gender?

The Secret Life Of Bees Evaluative Essay

Bees Evaluative Essay Imagine a scene where you are around four years old again. You have an object in your hand that feels incredibly heavy, but you’re not quite sure what it is. You extend your arm to hand to your mother, this cold, dense and oddly shaped object. All of the sudden it slips a little in your hand and you squeeze your grip to keep a hold of it. In that same moment, the object explodes and falls out of your hand. When you look up at your mother, she has a blank expression on her face…

Words 1258 - Pages 6

Montage: Reference and Film Essay

Jonathan Cohn Film Analysis Paper • 5-­‐6 Pages • Due Thursday April 3 ! • Choose two similar scenes from two different films and compare how they present one specific theme. • Analyze these two scenes at the level of cinematic technique in order to address how the two films grapple with…

Words 2721 - Pages 11

Night The Moon

Australian films such as Radiance and One Night the Moon. Good evening teachers, educators and distinguished guests, some of you may or may not know me as Rachael Perkins the director of ‘One Night the Moon’, currently one of the films available to be studied under Module A: Experience Through Language, It is a great privilege for a director to have an opportunity like this to express my thoughts and emotions while making the film. By the end of this presentation I aim to have deepen your understanding…

Words 1210 - Pages 5

Whale Riders Film Analysis Essay

When choosing a film for this assignment, my original choice was Bend It Like Beckham because I had heard of it and I had a general idea what it was about. I then decided that I wanted to take on a more challenging film, one that I had never heard of, and one that I would really have to study to understand its full meaning. After looking into a few of the listed movies, I ended up choosing Whale Rider, a drama filmed in New Zealand in 2002. After watching the movie two times, I feel that I now…

Words 1395 - Pages 6

Taming Of The Shrew And Petruchio's

Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew is a comedic play that centres on the gender and class inequalities of the Elizabethan Era. To highlight these inequalities, the play depicts the volatile relationship between the two central characters- Katherina and Petruchio. Modern transformations of this infamous text, particularly the film versions created in 1999 and 1967, have enabled contemporary viewers to access these overt messages of masculinity and feminity and to contextualise the events described…

Words 1236 - Pages 5

Gender Performance In The Media

Gervais Lake Forest College Introduction The topic discussed in this paper is the use of gender performance as a form of entertainment for a heterosexual audience. From this topic, arise many different questions. I have been lead to wonder: what forms of gender performance are there? What makes a performance geared towards heterosexuals? How do these performances affect the queer agenda? How is gender performance in the media viewed by queer culture as well as heterosexual culture? This topic…

Words 3962 - Pages 16

Disney Media's Influence On Adolescents

Kindergarten. We’re taught that hitting won’t get us what we want, naps are imperative, and we shouldn’t judge books by their covers. It truly is important that we’re exposed to these life lessons at such a developmental stage because they sculpt the way we view the world around us for years to come. It’s no secret that kids also learn a great deal about their society from the media, whether it is video games, TV shows, or even movies. Animated films, particularly the ones produced by Disney, have been…

Words 1790 - Pages 8

Miss Representation Essay

positions of power and influence in America. Building off the themes of the film, MissRepresentation.org is organizing tens of thousands of individuals to unite around a common, meaningful goal and spark millions of small actions that will ultimately lead to a cross-generational movement to stop sexism and create lasting cultural and sociological change. Here are a few campaign activities that we are excited to work with you on: • Women and girls are speaking out, telling their stories and influencing…

Words 3547 - Pages 15

Gender Stereotypes In Walt Disney's Fairy Tales

“The film allowed viewers to momentarily forget the Great Depression, the rise of fascism, and otherworldly horrors and, at least for an hour or two, focus on happy endings and the triumph of good in the world” (Patel). Today, Disney and their portrayals of fairy tales remain immensely popular and influential. The Walt Disney Company, has a monopoly on children’s minds. According to the Box Office Charts, the Walt Disney Company’s films “account for 26 of the top 150 highest box office films” (qtd…

Words 1161 - Pages 5

Women In Comedy

If there is one thing in comedy that will, without fail, make me roll my eyes, it’s when a man dresses up as a woman. The entire audience could be laughing at the straight man putting on a dress and a wig while talking in a high pitched voice about makeup, but it just has never resonated with me. Since I was young, I never understood why people found it funny, but I laughed along as to not seem lame or without a sense of humor. But, as I grew older, and became more aware of the position that women…

Words 1094 - Pages 5