Essay on Final Argument

Submitted By mattmtz
Words: 1118
Pages: 5
Open Document
Final Argumentative Essay Assignment
Phil 156.003
Summer 2013

Carl Sagan’s view of The Difference
Between Science and Religion is Not Accurate

Carl Sagan was an American scientist who died from pheunmonia at a relatively early age. He studied astronomy, astrophysical science and cosmology. Wrote several articles that popularized science and science communication in astronomy and natural science. Sagan was one of the few who brought science to the forefront and helped untangle the issues of science versus the issues of religion. Needless to say, these controversies created much controversy amongst scientists. Much disagreement was due to his dismissal of credit of a god-like creator and glorification of rationality. He was applauded for his use of logic and inspiration but criticized for his lack of distinction between assumptions and facts. Based on these factors, it is easy to find fault with his arguments because his scientific beliefs are based on solid provable scientific data while his religious beliefs are based on faith and data lacking evidence. Sagan’s view of the difference between science and religion cannot then be accurate. Sagan was probably best known for his television series “Cosmos A Personal Voyage” Developed while at Cornell University. Although he liked to write for professional scientists, he also enjoyed writing for the general public. He made frequent visits to TV talk shows. In the books listed below he presented scientific theories, philosophies, and scientific inquiries on social, political, religious, and historical events. Sagan received numerous awards for his work. It is fascinating to see that Sagan, in his book The Demon-Headed World,” He clearly indicates that we should always use logic and reasoning for decisions although he believed strongly in extraterrestrial life without proof that it existed (Sagan, 2006:114 & Sagan & Shklovskii, 1966:418). He justified his belief by utilizing methods of science and fusing them from different fields. “Sagan thinks that science replaces religion’s function of temporarily filling gaps in our understanding, but leaves religion’s benevolent social roles intact.” (Carl Sagan's Religion of Science - Aware ness's blog. (N.d.). Retrieved from http://davidhuerta.typepad.com/blog/2010/07/carl-sagans-religion-of-science.html). Sagan has made a unexpected connection between religion and science. He sees religion more as a form of sociology than a science. He feels that religion does not critically examine its evidence and each concept is as good as the other. Personally, I do not see how there is a way to do this. In the previous paragraph, I attempted to show how the two sciences can be alike and at the same time be so different. I find more differences than similarities between the two. These discussions have taken responsibility for long periods of time, and they still seem to function as two different sciences. There are many examples of how these two sciences have proven to be changed even within them. Scientists such as Newton, Pasteur, and Einstein have come up with specific theories not ever duplicated. Even set instruments have been developed to prove their belief. In the religious sector, we have volumes of the time that show how different faiths have practiced many different life structures.

There are many practices, and that appear to be closely related, and some are majorly different in beliefs and intensities of differences and similarities. There are occasions when religion causes us to obtain information without questioning its validity, so we just redesign. The one that comes to mind is the movement that Sagan alludes to one faction that redefined the “end of the world” when 1914 Passed without the world physically ending. (3, p. 284). According to
Scripture the Bible uses this phrase “last days” to refer to the conclusion of time leading up to a
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Final Argument

Final Argument Paper

Full-Body Scanners in Airports Kaylah Loftis ECPI University Abstract In this paper I will discuss why it is ethical to have full-body scanners in our airports. Full-body scanners are used for security to stop terrorists from coming into our country. The devices do not pose a threat to our health. So far, they have been an effective counter terrorism tool to our country. The price on the full-body scanners is expensive but they are worth the price. On September 11th, 2001, we lost thousands…

Words 1700 - Pages 7

Argument Essay Final

Would the Legalization of Marijuana Benefit the Economy? One of the hot topics of today is the legalization of marijuana. Some states have approved medical marijuana use. While I do not care for the substance, I believe that marijuana should be legal to purchase and use for recreational purposes. The sale of cannabis would benefit the state financially and put illegal dealers out of business. The state economy would benefit from the sale of marijuana. The state of Colorado issued amendment 64 in…

Words 461 - Pages 2

Argument Essay Final

English 102 20 October 2014 Argument Essay Raising the Drinking Age Recently in the news, have been rumors of raising the drinking age to 25 years old, shocking people around the country. Despite the negative public reaction to this possible change in age, but I believe 21-year-olds are still too naïve to be legally allowed to drink alcohol. In my opinion, the drinking age should be raised to 25 because of constant binge drinking by 21-24-year-olds. The abuse of alcohol these young adults displays…

Words 816 - Pages 4

Argument Essay Final

allows individuals to make an impact on a socioeconomic scale, an impact that would be lost without neutrality. Despite the advantages of an unhindered Net, many individuals believe neutrality is not the best course for the Internet. One common argument against neutrality is that ISPs are better equipped to remove illegal materials, such as pirated songs and leaked government information, than the FCC (Wasserman). While ISPs may have more manpower and time to vet information on the Web, as the FCC…

Words 1810 - Pages 8

Final ADHD Argument Essay

Prince Singh Professor Schaub Univ. 112 - 103 April 25, 2012 ADHD: Fallacious Conformity “Often has difficulty awaiting turn, interrupts or intrudes on others, blurts out answers before questions have been completed, talks excessively”, this is a mere preview into an array of “qualifications” one may check off to legitimatize ADHD, or Attention Deficit Hyper-active Disorder. The only problem with this is that majority of ADHD diagnoses occur between the age of three and six, when children are…

Words 1624 - Pages 7

AMB argument paper final draft

Alex Boreen Brad Brothen ENGC 1101 77 October 20, 2014 An Eye For An Eye Imagine that a person just killed multiple people. Does it make sense for him to live when he has taken so many lives? The death penalty helps this nation because if a seriously heinous is committed the person who committed the crime the person shouldn’t be breathing. It doesn’t make sense that the criminal should live off of all of the taxpayers and live in jail, especially when the prisons in the U.S. are being overcrowded…

Words 1074 - Pages 5

Classical Argument Essay 3 Final

Stereotyping and Profiling – The Negative Effect on Society Glenn A Smith ENG102 Sullivan University Composition 102 Abstract This essay shows the negative effects society encounters from stereotyping and profiling and some solutions to how, we as a nation, can overcome this plague. Stereotyping is the act of making an assumption or generalization of a particular person or group of persons based on misconceptions usually extending to how they might act or what they represent or just…

Words 3056 - Pages 13

To Remember 9/11 or not. Research Argument Final Essay

English 2010 Section 606 October 24, 2012 Proposal for Research Argument Final My Proposal to Learn Purpose As an emergency medical technician, I have always held life to be important and sacred. The purpose of all EMs is to save all lives possible when called upon. In my training I was taught in a unit how to handle mass casualty incidents and mass victim situations. At first, we studied the collapse of a newly built bridge in Germany, where to many people decided to start jumping up and down…

Words 2663 - Pages 11

Argument Piece final draft 1 Essay

Argument Piece Dear Mr I.M Balding, I am writing to you because I believe that your article ‘Looking a Gift Horse in the Mouth’ published In the EDP on the 14th of December is very provocative and pressuring to parents. I have many issues with your article: First, I think that your point that children should attend state education is absurd for many reasons. My main point being that not all children are lucky enough to live ‘normal’ lives. Some, unfortunately are born with disabilities and…

Words 828 - Pages 4

Billy Craft Causal Argument Final Essay

Billy Craft Professor Gregory Hazleton WRC 1023 Section 060 27 March 2015 Effects of Steroids Throughout Sports The “Elixir of Life”, a potion created by Charles Brown-Sequard, was the earliest known performance-enhancing drug in American Sports and was made with some sort of animal testicle. Pud Galvin of the Pittsburgh Alleghanys, a baseball team in the late 1800’s, used the elixir and won the following game. This win was cited as early evidence of the elixir’s power. The first scientifically…

Words 1640 - Pages 7