Essay about Final Free Will

Submitted By lostkeys87
Words: 1474
Pages: 6
Open Document
Hunter J. Benson
Eng. Composition
Final Paper

Free Will vs. Omniscience
How Is Free Will Compatible with Omniscience?

Many Christians have posed the question, “If God is omniscience, how then can we have free-will?” To assert that God is not omniscient is contrary to traditional Christian views of free-will under compatibilism. Compatibilism can be defined as the belief that free-will and determinism are compatible ideas. (Cowburn, 144) Here we must define what it is that we are discussing.
To say that one has free will must be that a person has in his or her power at any given moment the right to do as he or she wills. (Erasmus, 12) While it may be uncomplicated in thought, it is misleading in regards to the concept of free will as defined by Christian doctrine. The free will to which we must adhere to (according to Christian doctrine) is this; Free will is free in and of itself. However, our choices are not determined by the will itself but rather by the mind. This free will is guided by our knowledge and understanding as well as driven by our motives. The great American theologian Jonathan Edwards is credited with the most refining ideas on free will. He wrote explicitly about motive-based free-will. Edwards first defines the will as “the mind choosing”. (Edwards, 34) Our choices are determined by what we think is most desirable at any given moment.
We then come to issues of the illusion of free will that we have been trying to compare with omniscience; and that nature is undeniably open for God to see (omniscience). Therefore, a God existing temporally would know the nature of the being and the will of the being. So if a being is slave to its nature, the will of the being is not free but subject to the omniscience of its God. But that is not saying that we are not free to do otherwise, because every intention of the heart is known to God. He knows our every act of will and what every act of will will always be. Therefore, we find that both the will of man is free to do as he may, but the omniscience of God is not challenged. However, if there is no free will in and of itself, then it does not harm Gods omniscience in any shape or form. So if we then find ourselves more in a position in line with Arminianism and unwilling to totally reject free will, we then must put forward an argument that makes both the omniscience of God and the supposed free will of man compatible, or we must accept that God is not omniscient. Once established that free will must exist we arrive at the following argument.

1) God knows before we are born everything we will do.
2) If God knows before we are born everything we will do then it is never in our power to do otherwise.
3) If it is never in our power to do otherwise, then there is no human freedom.
4) There is no human freedom.

We push forward the notion that God exist eternally in such a way as He has no beginning or end, and exists outside of time and therefore is not subject to universal laws. God is then viewed as infinite and endless and entirely present to Himself. (Poe, 77) As such, God is “present” at all times and subject to none. This removes the thought of fore knowledge. Because God is not established at any one point of time, He can never foreknow anything, for that implies God is inside of time. According to both philosophers Boethius and Aquinas, “nothing happens in time that God is not aware of and as such he sees everything at all times in a glance.” (McInerny, 100) It is compared to how we see the present in a glance as we know the events that are unfolding before us; so does God look on all events as they happen and as they have happened. God does not have foreknowledge because He is not in position to do so, yet he knows past present and future in its entirety. Edwards states “If there be any such thing as foreknowledge of the volitions of free agents, that foreknowledge, by the supposition, is a thing which already has, and long ago had, existence; and so, now
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Final Free Will

Eco 561 Final Exam Free Essay

ECO 561 Final Exam w/ corrected answers 1) Suppose that in the clothing market, production costs have fallen, but the equilibrium price and quantity purchased have both increased. Based on this information you can conclude that A. the supply of clothing has grown faster than the demand for clothing [B. demand for clothing has grown faster than the supply of clothing] C. the supply of and demand for clothing have grown by the same proportion D. there is no way to determine what has…

Words 1415 - Pages 6

Freedom shown through the mirror of Shakspeare Essay

through the mirror of ShakspeareWilliam Shakespeare’s epilogue in The Tempest shows the parallels between the main character Prospero and Shakespeare himself. During the process of writing The Tempest, he himself believes that this is his final play or at least his final one written on his own. Therefore Shakespeare: the skillful writer uses the character Prospero seen as a skillful magician to communicate his farewell to his audience and the theater. You can see this message coming across in the following…

Words 461 - Pages 2

Analysis Of Birches

13. The final association of birches is with love beginning in line 55. 14. He fini13. The final association of birches is with love beginning in line 55. 14. He finishes the poem with an outstanding example of meiosis: "One could do worse than be a swinger of birches." This is the concluding line to a poem that exults the life of one who is a swinger of birches. 15. 2-Paragraph Analysis of "Birches" by Robert Frost 16. Feel free to use my findings. Cite them correctly. There's a good chance…

Words 316 - Pages 2

Essay on Phil Exam 2

brain or any other bodily function Therefore, the mind is immaterial Aristotle’s 4 causes Man Stone of David Material Flesh, blood, bones Stone, marble Formal Human form (soul) Idea in M.A. mind Efficient Parents reproduction Chipping & chiseling Final Actualize one’s own human potential Artistic, appreciated Plato’s 3 parts of the soul Cardinal virtues Cardinal virtues Reason Wisdom Rules in accord to what is right Spirit Courage Obey & follow reason appetites Temperance Obey & follow reason…

Words 753 - Pages 4

Store: Infant and Microfleece Jumpsuit Carter Essay

Store Item Quantity Price Total Khol’s Summer infant bath sling 1 tub 9.49 9.49 Dollar General Johnson’s first touch bath gift set 1 set 10.25 10.25 eCrater.com (free shipping, no tax) Luvs ultra leakguard diapers size 1 252 diapers 32.99 32.99 Walmart Pampers Baby Fresh Wipes 504 wipes 10.97 10.97 Walgreens Luvs ultra leakguard diapers size 1 96 diapers 7.49 14.98 Walgreens Similac Advance Infant Formula 1360oz 5.79 86.10 Walmart 3pk 8oz. Playtex Nurser Bottles…

Words 319 - Pages 2

Douglas Polly: The Trial Of 1851

This trial commemorates an important case which challenged slavery from 1851. One Mr. David Campbell owned them before selling them to a free black man. They were kidnapped and forced into slavery, eight free children from Ohio, Lawrence County. In fifty-one a civil dispute began by a General Assembly, lasting 162 years after their kidnapping. It took two life times before the Polly saw any recompense. First Freed The Polly family was once a slave family in Kentucky owned by David Campbell. On January…

Words 561 - Pages 3

Essay on Course: Chemistry and Chemical Equilibrium

presence of a common ion. Understand the concept of entropy and its relationship to reaction spontaneity. Calculate the change in entropy for system, surroundings, and the universe to determine whether a process is spontaneous. Use the Gibbs free energy to understand the connection between enthalpy and entropy changes and spontaneity. Understand the principles underlying voltaic cells Understand how to use electrochemical potentials to determine spontaneity of electrochemical cells. Use the…

Words 940 - Pages 4

Osmosis Experiment

It hosts many processes liking protein synthesis, making of different chemicals using RNA and the most important of all; osmosis. Osmosis is the diffusion of free water across a selectively permeable membrane from a region of higher free water concentration to a region of lower free water concentration. The process was discovered by Henri Dutrochet in France. This process is used to maintain homeostasis to regulate what enters and exits the cell. The job is assigned to…

Words 1115 - Pages 5

Trellis Analysis Essay

individual with final approval. * Sometimes the final approver is not in IT. Coming out of a rough recession one thing that most organizations strengthened was their strategic sourcing operations. Budgets are being slashed and big capital purchases are under a microscope. In order to control spending, strategic sourcing organizations were formed to assist with large purchases. In many organizations, including those that we interviewed, the sourcing organization controlled the final approval.…

Words 1535 - Pages 7

Chris Mccandless Research Paper

wilderness. Despite numerous offers of assistance from others, Chris carried on to his final destination– and final resting place. McCandless’s firm belief in self-reliance and anti-materialism ran far back into his childhood, and some could argue hindered his relationship with his parents. The myriad of people touched by Chris’s journey and beliefs cannot be ignored, as it represents the path of a truly free human…

Words 261 - Pages 2