Essay Ford Pinto Case Review

Submitted By 99jimbob
Words: 598
Pages: 3
Open Document
Case Review #1: Ford Pinto

1.) FACTS
• Ford was aware of gas tank defects on their Pinto model
• Ford ignored the safety concerns, positing “safety doesn’t sell” (p. 66)
• Ford based their decision off a cost-benefit analysis o Determined the “cost” of trunk alterations outweighed the “cost” of enhanced safety
• There were over 40 incidents involving Pinto passengers dying or being severely maimed

2.) ETHICAL ISSUES
• Is it morally right to sell a car with known, potentially fatal, defects?

3.) PARTIES
• Ford Motor Company
• Ford Management
• Ford Design Team
• Ford Quality Control
• Ford Pinto Drivers

4.) CONSEQUENCES
• Utilitarian Principle: Ford’s decision should have maximized the benefits and minimized the harm for consumers.
• The standard implicit in their decision was that since it was only a minority being injured, and they would reap a significant profit (with a majority of consumers being unaffected) their decision was permissible.
• Potential Consequences by party: o Ford Motor Company – potential public backlash/potential legal action/potential monetary penalties/potential loss of credibility with the public o Ford Management – potential loss of profits to rival manufacturers/potential jail time/potential loss of position/potential loss of credibility o Ford Design Team- potential job loss/potential compensation penalties/potential jail time o Ford Quality Control – potential loss of credibility/potential loss of jobs o Ford Pinto Drivers – potential loss of life/potential injuries or disabilities from vehicle operation
• It would appear that every obligation would UNDERMINE the decision to proceed forward with production of faulty vehicles

5.) OBLIGATIONS
• Kant’s “categorical imperative” would be applicable in this scenario
• The action here – allowing potentially fatal vehicles to put into production – would not be willed into a universal law. Conversely, universal law would state that a manufacturer should ensure that all products made available to the public would be aligned with the highest safety standards
• Obligations by Party: o Ford Motor Company – ensure all vehicles they produce are in the highest spirit of safety, with no exceptions o Ford Management – maximize their efforts to ensure they company they run holds customer safety in the highest regard o Ford Design Team – ensure all designs meet the most rigorous safety requirements o Ford Quality Control – disallow any design that does not hold up to the highest safety scrutiny o Ford Pinto Drivers – purchase a car they have determined to be of utmost safety
• It would again appear that every
Show More

Related Documents: Essay Ford Pinto Case Review

The Recall Of Both Ford And General Motors Essay

The Recall Of Both Ford And General Motors And the Ethical Implications. Leander Andreas Zapheriou Lindsey Wilson College Business Ethics 4/25/14 Author Note Leander Andreas Zapheriou, Student Athlete, Lindsey Wilson College. Leander Andreas Zapheriou is currently studying Business Administration concentrated in Management. Abstract This paper discusses the events leading up to the recall of both the Ford and General Motors. Both these vehicle companies dispatched faulty vehicles…

Words 2457 - Pages 10

Tort and White Collar Crime Essay

harm or loss from another tortious conduct (2) to place the cost of compensation on those parties compensatory damages- intended to compensate the plaintiff for his injury punitive damages - intended to punish or make an example of the wrongdoer in cases where the defendants conduct was intentional and outrageous showing malice or a fraudulent or evil motive,must be proportional to harm caused nominal damages - usually 1.00 , may apply…

Words 4115 - Pages 17

intermediate accounting 2 test bank Essay

Intermediate Accounting Kieso 15th Edition Test Bank Click here to download the solutions manual / test bank INSTANTLY!!! http://www.solutionsmanualtestbanks.com/2013/05/intermediate-acc ounting-kieso-15th-edition-test-bank.html Intermediate Intermediate Intermediate Intermediate Accounting Accounting Accounting Accounting Kieso Kieso Kieso Kieso 15th Edition Test Bank 15th Edition Test Bank Weygandt Warfield 15th Edition Test Bank Weygandt Warfield 15th Edition Test Bank…

Words 8328 - Pages 34

An Introduction to Intercultural Communication Essay

An Introduction to Intercultural Communication Intercultural communication is of importance to international businesses as it examines how people from different cultures, beliefs and religions come together to work and communicate with each other. Demands for intercultural communication skills are increasing as more and more businesses go global or international. They realize that there are barriers and limitations when entering a foreign territory. Without the help of intercultural communication…

Words 29173 - Pages 117