Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Probable Cause Essay

Submitted By tasty23

Words: 338

Pages: 2

Open Document

Jazmine Hunter

Criminal Procedure 9am

February 21, 2012

County of Riverside V. McLaughlin

Statement of the facts: Plaintiff McLaughlin initiated a class-action lawsuit, alleging that the County’s practice of combining arraignment with a determination of probable cause for people subject to warrantless arrest was not valid regarding the fourth amendment. Gerstein v. Pugh, also was allegedly violated mentioned as a reference case forcing the courts to define “prompt”. Where the court agreed it violated the fourth amendment. There was a second amended complaint by Hyde, Simon, and James regarding the same disregard to promptness, which eventually was remanded. Generally, arraignments must be within forty-eight hours of arrest. However, weekends and holidays are not included as days. Persons arrested at the end of the week could have as many as seven days before arraignment and a probable cause determination. The County moved to dismiss the complaint, asserting that McLaughlin lacked standing because the time for providing him a prompt probable cause determination had already passed and he had not shown that he would again be subject to the allegedly unconstitutional conduct.

Legal issue: Did the county violate McLaughlin, Simon, Hyde, and James fourth amendment right for a prompt probable cause determination hearing?

Holding: An individual (or individuals) arrested without a warrant must know the probable cause for their arrest from law enforcement officials within 48 hours.

Reasoning: The court established a compromise

Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Probable Cause Essay

what the reasonable person standard is. This is a phrase to denote a hypothetical person in society who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct and who serves as a comparative standard for determining liability. Next we will define probable cause as apparent facts discovered through logical inquiry that would lead a reasonable intelligent and prudent person to believe that an accused person has committed a crime. As we discuss this cases these are the two definitions that will affect the…

Words 841 - Pages 4

Blank: Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Probable Cause Essays

The Fourth Amendment has been held to mean that generally a warrant must be judicially sanctioned for a search or an arrest. In order for such a warrant to be considered reasonable, it must be supported by probable cause and be limited in scope according to specific information supplied by a person (usually a law enforcement officer) who has sworn by it and is therefore accountable to the issuing court. However, a dissenting school of thought often found in the opinions of Justice Antonin Scalia is…

Words 316 - Pages 2

Pros And Cons Of The Fourth Amendment

The fourth amendment was added to the United States Constitution in December 1791. This amendment is the section of the Bill of Rights that protects Americans from unreasonable search and seizure. The fourth amendment was based on abuses the English experienced with the British. This amendment is still being debated in the Supreme Court today. The fourth amendment was introduced into the Constitution as a part of the Bill of Rights on September 5, 1789. It was ratified by three-fourths of the states…

Words 597 - Pages 3

Case TLO V. New Jersey

Civics Essay If Katz had the right to privacy in a public phone booth, then why do we give up that right in a public school? TLO should be not guilty her 4th amendment rights were violated and she should have been innocent. In the case Katz v. United States, Katz was suspected of involvement of illegal gambling activities, and he was relaying gambling information across the phone in a public telephone booth. It was ruled unconstitutional because the FBI needed a warrant to listen in to Katz's…

Words 673 - Pages 3

Essay about Criminal Procedure

CJA/364 Tuesday, May 26th. 2015 Jason Huskey Criminal Policy The Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth amendment guarantee many rights to the people of the United States. This paper will explain the key elements that are secured by these amendments. It will also discussed how these policies have impacted criminal procedures are excercised by courts and police officers. Critical elements needed to meet the end state of this paper are the fourteenth amendment and the Bill of rights. The pursuit of the American dream and…

Words 1402 - Pages 6

Essay about Drones: Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Professor Page Psc

autonomously, without human control or beyond line of sight. Drone elevates a Constitutional issue. Though the Constitution doesn’t specifically states that there is no express right to privacy, this invention will contradict with the Fourth Amendment. The Bill of Rights protects the people of the United Stated from being searched. Law Enforcers or the government has to have a probable cause to even watch a person. The person has to give officials reasons to watch or search them. To do so the government…

Words 557 - Pages 3

4th Amendment Case Study

Under the Fourth Amendment of the U.S Constitution, it protects anyone from unreasonable government searches and seizures which this can be expanded to the protection to your computer and cell-phones. Probable Cause causes a problem with the Fourth Amendment, since it gives the policeman a probable cause to search you if they suspect you may be in possession of anything that can be against the law. Luke Duke argues that he was violated of his rights under the constitution, where Sheriff Rosco P…

Words 673 - Pages 3

4th Amendment Case Study

The Fourth Amendment gives people the right to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures and that no warrant can be issued without probable cause (Constitution Center). Selective incorporations gives the courts the rights to make universal rules about the 4th amendment defining what search and seizure mean. The court case Smith v. Maryland identified when a search warrant is needed and that there has been an understanding of when a search warrant…

Words 510 - Pages 3

Informative Essay: The Fourth Amendment

“The Fourth Amendment wasn't written for people with nothing to hide any more than the First Amendment was written for people with nothing to say.” The Fourth Amendment was written to ensure the privacy the U.S. citizens are entitled to. Without this amendment, the government would have too much power over people’s personal belongings and information. This protects the right to people’s privacy; and it prevents prevents unreasonable search and seizures. When this country first formed, the Constitution…

Words 1190 - Pages 5

Essay On Probable Cause

Define probable cause. How does the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution apply to probable cause? Discuss what happens if an officer arrests without probable cause. How does an officer prove probable cause to obtain a search warrant? Can an officer be sued if they make a lawful arrest or obtain a search warrant based on probable cause? How is probable cause different from reasonable suspicion (Terry v. Ohio, 1968)? Probable cause “is a level of reasonable belief, based on facts that can…

Words 476 - Pages 2