Framing Of Immigration Analysis

Words: 917
Pages: 4
Open Document
The Framing of Immigration Language is considered to be a mysterious apparatus of communication in our everyday life, where well chosen words posses the power to inform, educate, and influence others. Specifically framing, which presents facts surrounding an issue that requires a solution, is one of the main instruments used in politics to persuade the masses. “The Framing of Immigration,” an article published by George Lakoff and Sam Ferguson tackles such misuse of framing by specifically criticizing former president Bush’s speech on immigration. The article mainly claims that immigration will continue as an issue because of the weaknesses of current frames caused by the prevalent use of negative language and scapegoating of immigrants. Language, …show more content…
The authors criticize such stagnated themes in the existing frames and argue that immigrants do not come to a foreign country just to exploit its resources but to escape the domestic problems of their home country. The article specifically reinforces this theory through the use of conceptual “fantasy” frames such as the framing of globalization. The use of globalization in the context of immigration evokes confusion in the beginning because globalization personifies interaction and integration among individuals, companies and nations. Such primarily positive ideologies get overshadowed through the economic, profit seeking aspect of globalization. Specifically, companies, who seek maximum profits, need immigrants as low-paid workers in order to reduce the costs and increase their sales. To validate the existence of this vicious cycle, Ferguson and Lakoff specifically use the economic changes during the Bush regime as evidence because they showcase a steep growth in corporate profits without any change in the wage rate. The authors used such specific conceptual frame because it injects guilt into individuals, who partake in this constant demand for lower prices of goods and services. By changing the perspective, Lakoff and Ferguson shift the weight of the immigration issue from the immigrants to the ordinary people, which creates an emotional connection with the readers. The authors however, maximize such emotional pressure on their readers by further implementing the idea of the “American Dream.” The use of this ideology criticizes specifically the “dehumanizing” terms “alien” and “temporary worker” because they contradict the symbolized ideals of the “American Dream.” The authors warrant their argument by suggesting that immigrants
Show More

Related Documents: Framing Of Immigration Analysis

Politics in Classroom Essay

but that is just how it is sometimes in a college classroom setting. Immigration and gay marriage are two of the topics that come to me off the top of my head. We discussed these in class throughout the semester at some point and time. Whether they follow the basic “guidelines” of the article “Putting Politics Where It Belongs: In The Classroom” was a little bit unclear before reading the article. There are three types of framing when it comes to discussing such topics in the classroom. The first…

Words 883 - Pages 4

Immigration From A Sociological Perspective Analysis

my understanding of "immigration today" has grown significantly. At the beginning of the course, my perspective was limited, and primarily influenced by the current media portrayal of immigration as a crisis. However, as we got deeper into the theories of Mills, Gans, and others, my understanding broadened to understand the complex socio-political and economic dimensions of immigration. Using C. Wright Mills' concept of the sociological imagination, I began to see immigration not just as a series…

Words 2239 - Pages 9

Humor And Persuasion

My recording unit was any comment, discussion, or joke that focused on framing the issue with negative, positive, or neutral intent. I defined negative jokes as anything intended to make the target of the humor look incompetent or evil. Examples of this would be police depicted as using extreme force unnecessarily. I then…

Words 2360 - Pages 10

The Organic Ethnologist of Algeriani Migration Essay

Adelmalek Sayad passed away two years ago at this writing, leaving behind him one of the most original and fertile contributions to the anthropology of immigration of the past century. Throughout his voluminous and varied writings ?close to a hundred publications, including eight books spanning the destruction of Algeria's traditional peasantry at the hands of French colonialism, the dynamics of migration chains from Kabylia to France, the impact of decolonization on the reception of Algerian workers…

Words 2912 - Pages 12

Second Generation African Americans

This article dives into the narratives, experiences, and perspectives of second-generation Mexican teenagers living in San Diego during a period of heightened immigration debates and protests in 2006. Taking into account the experiences of second-generation youth and the impact of immigration policies on the identities and social belonging of immigrant families as a whole. This article also observed how the characterization of their family members as criminals impacts their…

Words 2594 - Pages 11

Fuentes Latina Syllabus Updated 1 2 Essay

Latinas and US Immigration: Gender, Race and Boundary Crossing LALS 31107M -82942 Prof. Norma Fuentes-Mayorga Lectures: Tues, Thurs 11:00am -12:15pm Office: 6/108C NAC Classroom: 379 Shepard Hall Office Hours: 4-6pm Course description: This course explores the immigrant and integration experience of Latina women in the US and the significance of gender and race in their socioeconomic life chances. The course bridges literatures on international migration, Latino studies, gender, race and boundary…

Words 3252 - Pages 14

Managing Out: the Public Sector in the Community Essay examples

psm unit 2: MANAGING OUT: THE PUBLIC SECTOR IN THE COMMUNITY |MINOR ASSIGNMENT – ASSESSMENT RESPONSE SHEET FOR ESSAY | Participants – complete your details and submit this sheet with your minor assignment. Your assessor will provide feedback and your grade on this sheet. |Participant to complete…

Words 2680 - Pages 11

Essay about Risk

Risk This assignment will critically evaluate theories of risk, and consider the approaches to practice for the role of a local authority social worker in the identification, assessment and management of risk of social work with children, young people and families. There will be consideration given to the impact of social work practice on service users and carers including my understanding of anti-discriminatory and anti-oppressive practice. The idiom ‘damned if you do and damned if you don’t’…

Words 4352 - Pages 18

Essay Change Summary

amplify students’ understanding of how meaning of the concept is shaped. While some of these texts may be suggested by teachers and explored in class, it is important for students to choose and study texts individually to develop skills of independent analysis and investigation. The texts students choose should reflect a range of types of texts and contexts. This enables students to concentrate on different ways in which meaning is made. Key Terms in the Study of English This syllabus uses some…

Words 9417 - Pages 38

Managing In Latin Americ Common Issues And A Research Agenda

America is a paradoxical region. It has unique conditions that make it one of the most attractive contexts worldwide for doing business, but it also faces serious challenges that severely underscore these opportunities. We apply a simple framework of analysis to describe the Latin American business environment and detect research opportunities. For that, we focus on four aspects of the region: (1) the institutional context, (2) the macroeconomic environment, (3) the consumer profile, and (4) the natural…

Words 9928 - Pages 40