Free Will In Homer's The Odyssey

Words: 1027
Pages: 5
Open Document
Essay Assignment: The Odyssey
In The Odyssey, the gods and humans are faced with decisions that will shape their destiny. Gods, the most powerful beings in existence, are the nature that shapes the humans’ surroundings. Unlike the humans, the gods have complete control over their actions and are only influenced by emotion and each other. The humans rarely have anything that they are in complete control of other than their individuality. Their surroundings, encounters, and journeys are the gods’ interventions in their lives. While the gods manipulate the situations the humans are in, the humans’ choices prove to be of their own free will. The actions of the gods influence the people's’ fate, but ultimately, humans are responsible for their …show more content…
free will. Fate is the destiny that the gods influence, but free will is when the humans have their own decision to make. The gods control the physical situations the humans are in, but do not directly control the humans’ choices. “Temptation had its way with my companions, and they untied the bag. Then every wind roared into hurricane; the ships went pitching west with many cries; our land was lost.” It might have been fate that led to Odysseus receiving the winds from Aiolos, but the greed of his companions is what caused their downfall. It was of their own free will they decided to open Odysseus’s bag, not fate. “Son of Laertes, versatile Odysseus, after these years with me, you still desire your old home? Even so, I wish you well.” (p87) Kalypso is giving Odysseus the choice to leave or stay, which is free will. The gods controlled the situations that led up to his choice, but ultimately it is his decision to stay or leave. “‘Come, we’ll cut out the noblest of these cattle and once at home, in the old country of Ithaka, if ever that day comes - we’ll build a costly temple and adorn it with every beauty for the Lord of Noon. But if he flares up over his heifers lost, wishing our ship destroyed, and if the gods make cause with him, why, then I say: Better open your lungs to a big sea once for all than waste to skin and bones on a lonely island!’”(p221) Odysseus’s crew is desperate for food, so they decide to eat Helios’ cattle. They know that there will be possible consequences and Odysseus has warned them against it, but they do it anyway by their own free will. This was not controlled by the gods, because it was their own decision to sacrifice the cattle when Odysseus wasn’t there to stop them. Many events influenced by the gods lead up to human actions, but their choices are never directly affected by the gods, and are always made of their own free
Show More

Related Documents: Free Will In Homer's The Odyssey

Odyssey And Free Will In Homer's Odyssey

These struggles and solutions can help you build character. Adventures have the ability to show parts of you that have remained hidden throughout your life. You can learn who you are and what kind of a person you are. In the abridged version of the Odyssey, Odysseus is asked for his name by a Cyclops holding him and his men captive.“Cyclops, you ask my honorable name? Remember the gift you promised me, and I shall tell you. My name is Nohbdy: mother, father, and friends,…

Words 714 - Pages 3

Odysseus Free Will In Homer's Odyssey

In this quote from the Odyssey, Odysseus discloses to his wife, Penelope, that he should leave Ithaca again to satisfy his fate, or his destiny. Odysseus' decision to face his destiny and take after the way forecasted to him demonstrates his grit and quality as a legend. Odysseus took each test the divine beings tossed at him, including the savage Cyclops' refuge, the captivating hold of the Sirens, and notwithstanding setting off to the Underworld. While any man could have avoided his destiny, Odysseus…

Words 531 - Pages 3

Odysseus Free Will In Homer's The Odyssey

In the epic, The Odyssey, Odysseus and his man are faced with the task of getting off the island with the Cyclops, Polyphemus. Odysseus develops a plan to get off the island, with the help of his men. This story can be compared to an event in my life. The escaping of the cyclops is like playing high school soccer because it requires a plan of action, the skill and talent to pull it off. Playing soccer is like escaping the Cyclopes because it requires a plan. In soccer we had to one up with a…

Words 553 - Pages 3

Odysseus 'Free Will In Homer's Odyssey'

James Fair Mr. Curran English IV 4/10/24 Fate and the will of the gods hold more sway over Odysseus than free will because even when Odysseus thinks he is making a decision, Athena forces him to make that decision. Odysseus was talking to Amphinomus, and he tried to save him. May spirits guide you home, so you do not meet him when he comes. When he confronts the suitors in this hall, there will be blood." Line 147 - "The 'Standard'" Pg. 413). See also Odysseus knows he will die if he stays, so he…

Words 469 - Pages 2

Theseus 'Free Will In Homer's Odyssey'

When Theuses heard of the minotaur he was determined to do what he believed was morally right, to kill the minotaur. Theseus argued to King Minos, the creator of the ritual and Minataur, that If I prevail, I warn you, O Minos, that we Athenians are free people and a tribute shall cease. If I die, I die; but the tribute is unjust (Coolidge 207). From this passage, one might argue that the hope of killing the minotaur blinds him to the tragic potential consequences that might follow attempting to kill…

Words 1233 - Pages 5

The Free Will Of Odysseus In Homer's Odyssey

All you gods are full of cruelness and lack compassion, you're all stony hearted. When the lion hearted Odysseus reached my island all I wanted was some companionship after spending such a long period of time by myself. Not only do you Gods want to see me in misery but you are hypocritical too, this love and connection between me and Odysseus has personally come from the God of love Eros himself and it is in his desires and wish that we be together. Odysseus and I have a strong unbreakable bond…

Words 472 - Pages 2

Fate And Free Will In Homer's Odyssey

individuality, democracy, and fate. Your fate was directly related to what your character or how they acted. No matter what your character would lead you to make decisions and choices that led you to whatever your fate was. For instance like a cyclops in the Odyssey the fate that he had was for him to meet Odysseus and have his eye blinded. This happened because he did not follow the laws of Zeus and properly treat them when they came into his home. This was his fate because his character being a cyclops did…

Words 416 - Pages 2

Fate And Perseus Free Will In Homer's Odyssey

Perseus is too strong to be kept down and on an island, so it is fitting that his fate is to go on adventures and quests and to be helped by gods. He fits the heroic model of an honorable man overcoming all obstacles to reunite his family and do justice. It is interesting to note that the story does not indicate whether fate or Zeus guided Perseus's box to the island. As in the Creation of Earth, the reader must wonder who is in charge. Is there a difference between fate and Zeus, and if so, what…

Words 403 - Pages 2

Homer's Odyssey: Homeric Heroes And Free Will

Homeric Heroes, And Free Will In Homers Iliad and Odyssey the characters constantly battle with themselves. The main characters are multidimensional and are given free will but it is expected by the gods to accept the punishment when they dishonore them or the customs of the society they live. Mortals usually blame the gods for their misfortunes; “Mortals! They are always blaming the gods for their troubles when their own witlessness causes them more than they are destined for!” (Odyssey 1.36)Although…

Words 936 - Pages 4

Comparing Homer's Odyssey And Sirens Song

P1. Intro While some differences between Homer’s Odyssey and Sirens Song are pronounced, the similarities are noticeable. The Odyssey can have many different views on how Odysseus was portrayed depending on who tells the story, and anyone can see this in the two passages. They both feel that these creatures have intriguing but deadly voices. These voices call to every passerby and are irresistible to anyone that hears it. P2. Tone In Atwood’s “Siren song” , the Siren tone is intriguing and persuasive…

Words 390 - Pages 2