Free Will: Lawrence Kohlberg's Stages of Moral Development Essay

Submitted By haydensucks
Words: 1489
Pages: 6
Open Document
Exactly what it sounds like – I teach and tell.
What I Taught Today
HomeWhat I’m Doing and Why
« Habituation – from the Behavioral PerspectiveFirst- and second-order change »
Kohlberg’s stages of moral reasoning

Lawrence Kohlberg, an American psychologist, developed a well-known theory about how people make decisions about right and wrong – that is, moral behavior.

At the preconventional level, decisions about right and wrong are made based upon a “what’s in it for me” mentality – that is, people make moral judgments to advance their personal interests or advantage, with no regard for the consequences of those decisions for other people.

At the conventional level, moral decisions are made with consideration for the fact that people are embedded in social systems. That is, a person brings their relations with their loved ones, associates, and the formal and informal rules of their societies to mind when deciding the appropriate course of action to take in a morally-ambiguous situation.

At the postconventional level, people come to understand that formal and informal rules are generated through the living activities of societies, and of their members. Therefore (since people and societies are imperfect and impacted by forces such as history, resources, power, and goals) the standing rules of a society may or may not be designed to respect the appropriate balance between individual rights and freedom of choice, and collective experience and opportunity to pursue a fulfilling life. People make moral decisions based upon a deeply held personal conscience, but that conscience represents an internalized idea about the proper functioning of society.

To teach this (and before explaining these stages), I had students consider what they might do in the following situation:

I assign a paper on Erik Erikson’s socioemotional stages (another theory I taught today). You, the student, Google the topic, and a website pops up where you can purchase a prewritten paper that perfectly fits my paper requirements. It even allows you to purchase a paper at your expected level of performance (A, B, C, etc.) to help conceal your cheating. It costs $40 to download. Do you purchase the paper or not, and why?

I had students discuss their reactions to this situation with each other, assuring them that their answers would have no consequences whatsoever for my personal opinion of them (since it’s just a hypothetical class exercise). They played along, and came up with some really fun answers:

“I would definitely not buy the paper, because I know I’d get caught, and I don’t want to be expelled!”

“I wouldn’t buy the paper, because I can do a lot better things with $40.”

“I wouldn’t buy the paper, because I wouldn’t get to learn from the exercise, and then what would happen on my test?”

“I would consider it, depending on how busy I was that week – and if my grade depended on it, I might!”

The conversation could have gone on for quite a while – the students really jumped in on this one. Then I told them that it really didn’t matter whether they said they would or wouldn’t buy the paper – what psychologists are interested in is how they made their decision. That is, how do they justify one course of action or another? I then explained Kohlberg’s theory, and had to inform them (with a smile, because it always comes out this way) that most of their reasoning was at a preconventional level – in Kohlberg’s view, a very immature and self-centered way to decide what is right and wrong.

Are some kinds of moral judgments inherently “better” than others, like Kohlberg would seem to say? What pushes (some of) us to make decisions at a “higher” level than others do? Unfortunately, this theory alone is merely descriptive, and can’t help us pick out who will make decisions in any particular way in a given situation. However, my own view is that moral reasoning connects directly to our individual concern for either fair
Show More

Related Documents: Free Will: Lawrence Kohlberg's Stages of Moral Development Essay

Essay on Jean Piaget and Students

and rehabilitative devices for people with disabilities Authentic Assessment Measurement of important abilities using procedures that simulate the application of these abilities to real-life problems. Autonomous Morality Stage at which a person understands that people make rules and those punishments are not automatic. Bilingual Education Schooling in which those who are not fluent in the standard or national language are taught in their own language. Bloom’s…

Words 2765 - Pages 12

Sigmund Freud Essay

learn culture. There are at least four big questions presented in this chapter. First, to what degree is socialization necessary for human development? In other words, is human development more a product of NATURE or NURTURE? A second question presented is HOW do we develop? Is our PERSONALITY basically determined at birth – or do we go through STAGES OF DEVELOPMENT and grow into the person we are today – and when do we stop developing our personalities? Do we stop developing after puberty (as Freud…

Words 1634 - Pages 7

Essay about Personal life portrait

The human development is a continuous process and remains continuous throughout our lives. For every action in our lives there is a reaction and the outcome would never be the same. Always think before you action because the consequence that we may end up paying in the end may not always be rewarding. The stages of the human development can be stated best explain by Erik Erikson’s theory of development through various stages in life. Erikson was the first theorist to study human development and how…

Words 4281 - Pages 18

Business Evnironment Responsbility Jou Essay examples

Environmental Responsibility in Taiwan — Moral, Legal or Negotiated ABSTRACT. This study explores both the negotiating styles and moral reasoning processes of husiness people and governmental officials in Taiwan, so as to provide a footing for "outsiders" when negotiating with Taiwanese over environmental concerns. Findings imply that Taiwanese husiness people and governmental officials can and will reason hoth at the conventional level and at the postconventional level of moral judgment. But, results of this…

Words 5552 - Pages 23

What contributions have different perspectives in psychology? Essay

What contributions have different perspectives in psychology? There are many approaches in psychology. An approach is a perspective that is not as clearly outlined as a theory and 'provides a general orientation to a view of humankind (coolican et al., 1996 as cited in Alberry et al., 2008:15). The three major approaches chosen in this essay are the behaviourist, the humanistic and the cognitive approach. Behaviourism changed the subject of psychology from mind to behaviour and emphasised the…

Words 2016 - Pages 9

Ethics Midterm Notes

of those in a profession; laws and expectations of society Definition of Ethics The discipline dealing with what is good and bad, with moral duty and obligation A set of moral principles; a theory or system of moral values; the principles of conduct governing an individual or a group; a guiding philosophy; a consciousness of moral importance A set of moral issues or aspects Reasons to study ethics Simple beliefs may be inadequate for complex issue The study can help a person sort out these…

Words 3955 - Pages 16

Family Counseling Approach - Narrative Therapy Essay

Family Counseling Approach – Narrative Therapy Kristi Sabbides Moos Liberty University Marriage and Family Counseling I May 13, 2011 Dr. Suhad Sadik, Instructor Abstract Narrative therapy focuses on helping clients gain access to preferred story lines about their lives and identities and takes the place of previous negative and self-defeating narratives about themselves. An overview of the Social Construction Model, Narrative Therapy, is presented, as well…

Words 2803 - Pages 12

Psychology and United States Essay

either be a member of the biological branch or the psychoanalytical branch. Ivan Petrovich Pavlov Born September 26, 1849; Died February 27, 1936 Russian Pavlov’s Dog—conditioned a dog to salivate upon hearing a bell ring Showed behavioral development is dependent on conditioned responses to life events and the unconscious thoughts of an individual control behavior Psychoanalytic Sigmund Freud Born: May 06, 1856 in Freiberg, Germany Died: September 23, 1939 in London, England Austrian…

Words 4573 - Pages 19

Essay Social and Emotional Development

Child Development: Social and Emotional Development Child Development - Social and Emotional Development Introduction: As we grow older we change; these changes are most visible during infancy and childhood. From birth, babies grow larger and show noticeable development in both their social and intellectual competence. The study of age-related changes in human behaviour is referred to as developmental psychology. Child development refers to the psychological and biological changes that…

Words 10353 - Pages 42

CNPS 427 Lecture Essay

accredited supervision of doctoral degrees related programs Teaching and research (see also: specialization; scientist-practitioner model) Professional development All of the memberships in prof associations do come with a number of attached things: Show what you have done (Read, researched) in the meanwhile in order to keep up w/ the latest development In teaching – advantageous position: What they do everyday = research new articles, new findings. People not in educational capacity – less advantageous…

Words 8815 - Pages 36