Jim Markson Vs Gay Law

Submitted By erickadelro
Words: 1039
Pages: 5
Open Document
Brief: For 15 years of a committed relationship with his partner, Tim, Jim Markson has been rejected to the right on filing jointly towards Federal Taxes due to the fact they are not recognized by the federal government with legal marriage. According to the state of New York, my client, Jim has been legally married to his husband since December 2011, in New York. Due to that, the married couple are not recognized to them as married. My client, Markson will be suing the federal government for the money that has been lost in the past 15 years for not being recognized as a married couple. Adding to that, Jim also wants the right to file taxes with his partner in the future, giving them the advantage to get their money back as well. By the 5th amendment, Markson’s views makes him believes that his constitutional right is being violated by the Defense of Marriage Act, as known as the DOMA. The DOMA states that same-sex-couples cannot be considered married on the purposes of federal benefits as in, joint taxes. By this, Markson believes he has the right for equal protection with the law under the federal government as being a violation because the 5th amendment states the words, “any person, which also includes the homosexuals. Adding to that, the 5th amendment also states, “No person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law…”, supreme court found this clause to add onto equal protection rights under the law. Similar to the Brown v. Board case, this is also found to be true in Bolling v. Sharpe, lessen the District of Columbia where federal laws do apply. Markson wants DOMA to be repealed and not enforced because it does take many civil rights from the homosexuals, such as the joint taxes. The government should recognize married same-sex couples as married, as same as the straight and give them the privledge of filing joint on taxes and many other things.
Issues on Gay Rights: What they have been effected by the federal government
No right to file taxes jointly by homosexual couples
Right to be recognize by the federal government to be known as a same-sex married couple
Receive money that have not been given for the 15 years on taxes
Holding:
1) Court must recognize that a married same-sex- couple must have the right to file taxes jointly, including the DOMA is known as unconstitutional for forbidding to do so. 2) Court must recognize that the DOMA did not state their amendment clearly and is unconstitutional because it states that the federal government does not have to awknowledge same-sex-couples. It violates civil rights for same-sex-couples. 3) Mr. Markson must receive the money he has lost due to taxes only for the year that he has been legally married in New York.
Rational:
1) Court agrees the fact the married same-sex-couples will receive the same treatment as married couples which gives them the ability to file their taxes jointly, as any straight marriage would receive. Also, DOMA will state that, “In determining the meaning of any Act of Congress, or of any ruling, regulation, or interpretation of the various administrative bureaus and agencies of the United States, the word ‘marriage’ means only a legal union between one man and one woman…” which prevents married same-sex-couples to be awknoledge by the federal government, therefore the same-sex-couples don’t get the ability to file joint on taxes. Because of that, DOMA violates the civil rights given to all people by the 5th amendment. The 5th amendment states, “no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law…” this was found to be known for everyone will receive equal protection rights under the federal government in Bolling v. Sharpe. If a straight couple can file their taxes jointly, and homosexuals cannot; that is not equal protection, that is discrimination. With a similar case, Windsor v. United States, a woman sued for
Show More

Related Documents: Jim Markson Vs Gay Law

Gay Rights Essay

when I would have to hide who I loved. Gay men and women have been around since the beginning of time, it’s just that they had to stay in the world’s closet. I am a gay woman and I am very thankful for the gay men and women before me that have fought this war to have equal rights. I want to take you back to where the gay movement began…. It was December 10, 1924 and Henry Gerber founded the Society for Human Rights, out of Chicago. This was the first gay-rights organization as well as the oldest documented…

Words 1066 - Pages 5

Gay Rights Essay

Being “Gay” in America has always been a problem for many individuals in communities across the nation. There has been a constant debate on whether to grant them equal rights or to treat them as lesser members of society. A main issue with homosexual rights is discrimination in the workplace. Having a federal law to protect the gay citizens of a community, to make them feel comfortable to be themselves in their everyday, environments is still not in place. The gay communities in America are having…

Words 855 - Pages 4

Gay Rights Essay

Gay Rights By: Torian Portier Thesis statement: Gay rights is even is an even more controversial topic than women’s rights and African American rights. Works Cited: 1) http://www.datehookup.com/content-the-argument-for-and-against-gay-marriage.htm 2) http://www.religioustolerance.org/denomchg2.htm 3) http://www.enderminh.com/minh/civilrights.aspx 4) https://rcclibrary.wikispaces.com/GayRights 5) http://topics.nytimes.com/top/refere…

Words 2984 - Pages 12

gay rights Essay

Gay rights The gay rights movement in the US can be traced back to the Stonewall Riots that occurred following a police raid on the Stonewall Inn in New York City at 3 a.m. on June 28, 1969. Police raids on gay bars were commonplace, but on this occasion the gay and lesbian patrons fought back and sparked days of protests. The Stonewall Riots marked the beginning of a political movement for gay rights during a time when it was illegal to have homosexual sex in all states except for Illinois. [21]…

Words 477 - Pages 2

Essay on Gay Rights

Gay Rights I have a very strong opinion on gay marriages, because most of my friends and family are homosexuals. A lot of people are fighting the courts because the courts are considering legalizing gay marriages. Because of religious opinions regarding gay marriage, the government is stopped from passing the issue even though it is a division between church and state. In 2011, President Obama has been undecided about legalizing gay marriages. Chief Justice Roberts states regarding Obama’s decision…

Words 757 - Pages 4

Gay Rights: The Struggle For Civil Rights

While with the struggle for civil rights and social justice for African Americans and Hispanics, the determination for women's equality and gay rights have both energized and fractured America's religious institutions. When it came to gay rights, two issues in particular have stood out for their levels of contestation: the ordination of gays and lesbians to the ministry and the ceremonial blessing of the same-sex unions. As a United Methodist minister in North Carolina, Jim Creech became a local…

Words 408 - Pages 2

Gay Rights Research Paper

Gay Rights The Declaration of Independence says that we hold these facts to be ourselves, that everyone is equal, and that they are gifted by their Creator with certain unalienable rights. These words were written over two-hundred years ago and even back then, the people believed in the significance of equality. All people are created equal, and therefore there should not be any discrimination. History shows the discrimination of African-Americans and how our fellow countries have progressed regarding…

Words 436 - Pages 2

Gay Rights Research Paper

Gay Rights Amanda Jenkins It is my belief that gay marriage should be legal everywhere because homosexuality is not the only sin in the bible that the majority of people commit, homosexuals cannot control their sexual orientation, and we have accepted many other things so why not accept homosexuality? Think about this: A couple that is constantly arguing, and constantly has adultery issues, and who only want to be married to each other because they have children, are allowed to…

Words 923 - Pages 4

Pop Culture And Gay Rights

Culture & Gay Rights How did we go from a majority of Americans opposing marriage equality, with a Supreme Court Justice comparing laws against same-sex marriage to laws against bestiality, to gay marriage being legal in over half of the U.S states? How did public opinion on gay marriage change so quickly? Some might say that people like Ellen DeGeneres and the cast of Modern Family are responsible for the growing rate of people accepting gays in society. Millions of Americans may have accepted gay individuals…

Words 615 - Pages 3

Essay on Gay Right

This paper talks about racism and why and how people go about doing it. The paper also talks about the different types of racism. The chapter this paper is based on even went further by saying a person can be a racist without even noticing or knowing it. Some examples that were given are white privilege, ethnocentrism and stereotyping. After reading this chapter and what we learned about racism in class, I thought about some historic events that had to do with racism and my personal involvement and…

Words 562 - Pages 3