Girl: Jamaica Kincaid and Daughter Advice Essay

Submitted By CCooksey7

Words: 428

Pages: 2

Open Document

Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” is about a mother giving her daughter advice. She tells the girl about cooking, cleaning, men, and life in general. She calls girl a “slut” rather freely through the whole story. It’s almost as if she sees her daughter becoming a slut, rather than the woman she intends her to be. “Girl” is something different then I have ever read before. It’s almost as if you’re reading a set of instructions with very few responses of the girl who is receiving them. “Girl” not only reads as a set of instructions, but also reads at a poems stand point. I did like reading it, because “Girl” was very different from anything I have ever read before. All mothers seem to have a different perspective on how they want their daughters to become. In Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” it is a mother telling girl how to cook, clean, dress appropriately, how to get a man, and gardening. She also asks girl if “it is true that you sing benna in Sunday school?” “Benna” is a West Indian’s musical genre. Girl only interrupts her mother twice. Once to defend herself telling her mother “that she does not sing benna on Sundays at all and never in Sunday school.” At the very end of the story girl asks her mother “what if the baker don’t let her feel the bread?” Through the whole time her mother is telling her you must act this way, or you must cook and clean that way, girl only interrupts the mother twice. To me this shows that girl has complete respect for her mother. Yet the mother still

Girl essay

Analysis of the short story Girl Jamaica Kincaid’s short story, “Girl,” (1978) describes a mother that is simultaneously berating her daughter and teaching her what’s expected to be and do as an Antiguan woman. There's no traditional plot, no action, no character descriptions, and no setting. Only two voices, and it takes us a while to figure out that they are mother and daughter. The girl only responds twice to the mom and thats to ask, “but what if the baker won’t let me feel the bread?,”(Kincaid 484) and also to defend herself by saying…

Words 1161 - Pages 5

Family and Jamaica Kincaid Essays

Stepan. B ENG 102 Prof. Davidson Peter Meinke “Advice to My Son” and Jamaica Kincaid “Girl” The Rules to Picking a Good Wife The poem Advice to My Son by Peter Meinke, is a perfect example of how old sayings do not always reflect life. In this poem Meinke is giving his son advice on choosing a wife; he advises his son to “Therefore, marry a pretty girl after seeing her mother;” “To be specific, between the peony and the rose plant squash and spinach, turnips and tomatoes; beauty…

Words 526 - Pages 3

Jamaica Kincaid's GIRL

In the short story GIRL, Jamaica Kincaid insists that the mother see the daughter as a depiction of herself, and fears all that has happen to her may curse her daughter as well. It is clear that the mother is reverting back to her past and is now displacing her past errors onto her daughter vicariously. In this short story the mother dispenses, what is considered, helpful advice that is essential for daily living and what would help her daughter survive as a woman. Although the mother is giving…

Words 592 - Pages 3

Girl By Jamaica Kincaid Summary

The story “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid shows a story of family values. The author clearly shows a series of practices and moral principals that a mother is trying to pass along to her daughter. This mother wants to give her daughter advice about how to be a respectful woman in society. The theme of this story is about devotion to family, the relationship with between mother and daughter and sexual reputation as well. The story brings a lot of discussions about how the daughter should interact with…

Words 551 - Pages 3

First-person Narrative and Story Essay

Gray 1 English 1302-188 Spring 2014 Paper 2 Final Draft Rules of Becoming a Proper Lady In “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid a mother gives a list of expectations of how her daughter should act. The passage is a long sentence of what her daughter should do in different situations. The advice is meant to keep her daughter from becoming a slut, varies randomly with no real pattern and with very few behaviors that lead to becoming a slut. The girl’s chief concern…

Words 528 - Pages 3

Essay on Family and Barbie Doll

individuals who are out of a relationship will try to jeopardize others because of their insecurities or jealousy. In “Cinderella,” “Girl,” and “Barbie Doll” the main characters’ relationships have a positive or negative outcome on their lives that will lead to wisdom or sorrow. In Cinderella by Anne Sexton, the speaker portrays a well known fairy tale story about a young girl who had no family bond, but created her own fantasy that made her feel loved by a man. Cinderella felt that her new family did…

Words 912 - Pages 4

America Kincaid Girl Essay

“Boys will be boys”, “Girls cook, clean, and take care of the house” and “Boys are rough and tough”. All of these sayings are controversial in the generation we are in now. Women trying to become more equal with men in the world, and then men speaking up about mental health, not just for women. There are many scenarios that people can think about that have happened in their lives, but one reading I felt I connected best with this prompt was Kincaid's poem, “Girl”. In the text "Girl" it is about a mother…

Words 937 - Pages 4

Girl By Jamaica Kincaid Analysis

One-Way Communication Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” consists of pieces of advice and admonishments a mother gives to her daughter. The fragments are compiled into one long sentence, separated only by semi-colons, which allows the piece to be governed by the mother’s overwhelming sense of duty. It is this duty that makes communication between the mother and daughter virtually impossible in this piece, which is shown through the format of the story itself as well as through the mother’s fear-mongering…

Words 949 - Pages 4

Girl By Jamaica Kincaid Analysis

Dianelis Almonte Essay #2 Draft “Girl” By Jamaica Kincaid uses a unique narrative structure which conveys a long list of commands to show that the mother’s domestic actions to highlight her understanding and authority. The mother who is the main speaker worries that if her daughter continues with her current behavior, will turn out to become a “slut”. The mother wants the daughter to be able to run a household and live a respectably life. The way the structure of this poem is presented…

Words 644 - Pages 3

Essay on It's No Time for Idle Abuse

obtain a good, caring husband that will provide for you and love you for the rest of your days. This is the life that the mother in Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” stresses for her daughter. However, in Hurston’s “Sweat” we see a contradiction to that idea. So which woman is the “correct” woman? “Girl” is a list of ‘advice’ that a mother is passing onto her daughter. The list is focused on basic domestic duties and obligations that…

Words 1094 - Pages 5