Essay about Government's Role in the Financial Crisis of 2008

Submitted By jclark4525
Words: 3000
Pages: 12
Open Document
A Government
Failure, Not a
Market Failure
The financial collapse has its roots in a series of government actions that have distorted and obscured the true nature of home ownership.
By John H. Makin

As a people we need, at all times, the encouragement of home ownership.
HERBERT HOOVER, 1932

\ /—~i
1/

I

N~1 HE IDEA that home ownership
\ J confers special benefits on American society is deeply embedded in our culture—so much so that our national tax policy confers a special benefit of its own on it. Home owna ership is granted an advantage over all other forms of ownership in the form of an enormous deduction on the interest payments most individuals incur in financing their homes. Nothing else in
J O H N H . MAKIN is a visiting fellow at the American

Enterprise Institute and a principal at Caxton Associates.

16

the tax code comes anywhere near that deduction in scope or size. We have decided, as a nation, that home ownership is not only a good thing for an individual or a family, but that it is beneficial for the public at large and the country as a whole. Otherwise, why would it be necessary for the government to give it this kind of preferential treatment? Without it, clearly, we believe that the national rate of home ownership would be lower, and that a lower rate of home ownership would be deleterious to our common weal.
After 2000, the national push toward home ownership intensified in three dimensions, leading to a doubling of housing prices in justfiveyears' time. First, the Federal Reserve Board's interest-rate policy drove down the cost of borrowing money to unprecedented lows. Second, a common conviction arose that home ovraership should be available even to those who, under prevailing conditions, could not afford it. Finally, private agencies charged with determining the risk
July/August 2009

This is not to say that there is no such thing as market failure. There are many instances of market failure. Someone may possess information that others do not, as in insider trading, and thereby gain an illegitimate leg up. There may be too few players in a given market, which allows them to manipulate, hoard, and toy with prices. Capricious government intervention in cases where it is neither required nor appropriate constitutes another condition that may create a market failure.
There are also cases of market failure in which some people get a free ride while others bear a disproportionate burden. This is the case in national defense, for example, in which soldiers bear a burden non-soldiers do not. Consequently, a government subsidy for national defense is necessary for the maintenance of security and power, and the overwhelming majority of citizens acknowledges it and does not complain about it. National defense is a public good, perhaps the original public good.
Owner-occupied housing is something else that has been deemed a public good. Herbert Hoover's affirmation of the need for encouragement of home ownership "at all times" came in 1932 at the fiercest stage of the Great Depression. Others have made powerful arguments that homeowners make better citizens and contribute to stable communities. Why renters do not and cannot offer the same contribution to the public good is never specified, but existing homeowners, homebuilders, mortgage lenders, and mortgage servicers have all seized on the idea that subsidizing home ovraership is "Parieto optimal."
It isn't.
Subsidies for home ownership—in the form of full deductibility of mortgage interest, lower mortgage borrowing rates derived from government guarantees
CCORDING to The New Palgrave Dictionary of for mortgage lenders like Fannie Mae and Freddie
Economics, an invaluable collection of pre- Mac, and deductibility of local real-estate taxes—have
-cise summaries of virtually every topic in the long benefited those who own homes at the expense dismal science: "The best way to understand
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Government's Role in the Financial Crisis of 2008

Fannie Mae And Freddy Mac Case Study

growth, besides it ability to provide liquidity in financial crisis of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Recently, Federal Reserve Board Chairman Alan Greenspan commented in his U.S. Senate Banking Committee testimony on the Government…

Words 518 - Pages 3

Executive Pay Research Paper

public debate over executive compensation for decades. However, concerns over executive compensation have increased in recent years due to the financial crisis of 2007-2008 and rising income inequality. Economists mostly agree that executive pay arrangements contributed to the excessive risk-taking of companies during the years leading up to the financial crisis. Many companies paid their executives excessive bonuses and compensation, which rewarded, and even encouraged, risky behavior. Additionally…

Words 519 - Pages 3

Obam The Culture Of Irresponsibility Lead To 2007 Financial Crisis

Obama: ‘the culture of irresponsibility’ caused 2007 financial crisis How did culture of irresponsibility lead to 2007 financial crisis? Introduction: America President Obama said that the culture of irresponsibility was the most important cause of 2007 financial crisis (CBSNEWS, 2009). He pointed out that it was a failure of the entire system, mainly the failure of government and the irresponsibility banks. He also said ‘millions of Americans who have worked hard and behaved responsibility…

Words 2134 - Pages 9

Investment Banking Essay examples

Investment Banking in 2008 Group Report 1. Failure Analysis: Identify the major factors that contributed to Bear Stearns’s failure? Who stood to benefit from its implosion? How did Bear Stearns’s collapse differ from the ‘Long Term Capital Management’ failure a decade earlier? What could Bear Stearns have done differently to avoid this fate? In the early 2000’s? And during the summer of 2007? And during the week of March 10, 2008? (1) Identify the…

Words 4025 - Pages 17

goverment crisis Essay

Navar Alvarado Bus 100 Ford 21October 2013 The U.S. subprime mortgage crisis was a set of events and conditions that led to a financial crisis and subsequent recession that began in 2008. It was characterized by a rise in subprime mortgage delinquencies and foreclosures, and the resulting decline of securities backed by said mortgages. These mortgage-backed securities and collateralized debt obligations initially offered attractive rates of return due to the higher interest rates on the mortgages;…

Words 1073 - Pages 5

Refer To The Article: US Growth Expected Slow Amid Looming Stagflation

Stagflation Write a concise report in which you address the following issues: 1. Examine the cause of the US Economic Crisis in 2008. In the financial crisis of 2007-2008, also known as the global financial crisis and the financial crisis of 2008, many economists believe that it is the most serious financial crisis since the Great Depression of the nineteen thirties. It threatened to large financial institutions to complete collapse, the bank bailout by the national government, and in the world of stock market…

Words 4707 - Pages 19

Government's Role in an Interconnected Global Financial Market Essay

now to regulate markets to ensure economically efficient solutions. This essay will argue that the 2008 financial crisis has brought to the forefront of global political consideration what some economists have known for some time. This is that 1) The global financial system is inherently flawed and cyclical recessions are a product of its nature 2) The interconnectedness of the global financial system means macro-management cannot fully buffer an economy against these cyclical recessions 3) Policy…

Words 3011 - Pages 13

Essay on What Is Sovereign Debt?

Introduction International financial markets have been beset by the European sovereign debt crisis during 2010-2012, leading to high volatility of financial market and recession of the economies as well. The reason why the extensive impacts on financial markets could be triggered by the government debt problems from a few relatively small economies causes a heated discuss. In this essay, we intend to discuss the contagion effect of sovereign debt crisis among financial markets by analyzing the prior…

Words 1864 - Pages 8

The Euro in Crisis: Decision Time at the European Central Bank Essay

“The Role of the European Central Bank in the Financial Crash and the Crisis of the Euro-Zone” Report based on a WEED Expert Meeting Franziska Richter Peter Wahl 1 Imprint: Richter Franziska, Wahl, Peter: The Role of the European Central Bank in the Financial Crash and the Crisis of the Euro-Zone. Report based on a WEED Expert Meeting Published by: WEED - World Economics, Environment & Development Assoc. Eldenaer Straße 60 D-10247 Berlin 2011 All rights reserved This publication has…

Words 2159 - Pages 9

Monetary Policy and Investment Bank Bear Essay

Turnitin Submission – NO HARD COPIES Before 12.00pm COURSEWORK TASK: After reading this document you are required to answer ALL FOUR tasks: THE CREDIT CRUNCH CRISIS OF 2008 In October 2008, the world financial system came within a whisker of complete meltdown. In September 2008, the US government had decided to allow the investment bank Lehman Brothers to go bust, and in October the UK government nationalised Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) and Bradford & Bingley, and…

Words 1365 - Pages 6