Group Project Final Draft Essay

Submitted By ashleyxoslow
Words: 2000
Pages: 8
Open Document
Group Project: Recommendation Report

Submitted by: Ashley Low, Syeda Zehra and Syed Shah
Submitted to: Professor Massecar
Submitted on: Sunday October 26th, 2014
Course code: PHIL*2600 DE
Introduction
The GAP has been confronted with a serious ethical dilemma that affects the wellbeing of numerous stakeholders. As a company, we have faced previous obstacles with child labour in the production of clothing that has damaged the company’s reputation and required considerable damage control.1 A similar issue has arisen where child labour is used to produce cotton in Uzbekistan. This report will analyze different options for action using ethical theory and conclude that the best course of action is to reduce the purchase of Uzbek cotton as well as make considerable initiatives towards corporate social responsibility.

Option 1: Continue purchase of Uzbek cotton As a large multi-national corporation, the GAP has economic, legal, ethical and philanthropic expectations.2 The economy is the basis for all subsequent corporate social responsibilities, as its stability is required for the good of the other parts.3 Therefore, we must first consider the most viable option for economic sustainability. Due to globalization, the economies of both countries depend on our decision. First, the low price of cotton in Uzbekistan allows our spending to remain low, receive a great return on our investments, provide Western employees with good wages and provide customers with reasonable prices. Therefore, it is in the Western economy’s best interest to continue purchasing Uzbek cotton. In comparison, it is also in the Uzbekistani economy’s best interest to continue the business. Uzbekistan is the second largest exporter of cotton in the world but its Gross National Income (GNI) per capita is extremely low.4 Although the working conditions are undoubtedly dismal, the economy would be even worse if we took away a main source of income. Currently, the issue of child labour regarding cotton occurs during harvest-time once per year.5 If we do not continue the purchase of cotton, it could be used throughout the year in even worse conditions to provide enough economic growth to support the nation. Furthermore, our economy is driven by shareholders attempting to maximize profits.6 Even if the GAP stops purchasing from Uzbekistan, other companies may not and our attempts to stop child labour would be ineffective. Unfortunately, the premise of boycotting the purchase of cotton does not support the conclusion that child labour and poor working conditions will be alleviated. In order to stay in business and keep all of the stakeholders happy, it is essential that the GAP makes profits. Accordingly, our costs would be higher than the benefits if we decide to purchase materials from a country with a higher cost of cotton. If the GAP chooses not to continue the business with Uzbekistan, it will not make a positive difference to the nation’s conditions, nor will it be beneficial for all of the stakeholders. The second required component of corporate social responsibility is legality.7 The International Labour Organization’s (ILO) Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention ensures that Canada has child labour laws in the country’s legislation.8 However, Canada does not have laws preventing companies from purchasing from countries that use child labour. In September 2008, the Uzbekistan government signed ILO conventions banning child labour and children under the age of 16 from picking cotton.9 Therefore, the GAP purchasing cotton from Uzbekistan should not technically be illegal. However, it is clear that the government is not abiding by these laws, which creates a deeper issue than legality. According to ethical relativism, ethical decisions are based on personal character and culture rather than abstract moral principles.10 Although Canada has strong moral concerns regarding child
Show More

Related Documents: Group Project Final Draft Essay

Essay on Wesley Rupe Group Course Project Draft Genetic Engineering Wk 6 Layli Final Edits 4 15 15

Genetic Engineering Wesley Rupe, Jawad Rana, Layli Stroia, Charles Taiwo, Mariella Velasquez, Mark Young DeVry University Genetic Engineering Table of contents Title page ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 1 Table of contents ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 2 1. A brief description of the technology and an explanation of the associated science (Mariella Velasquez) ………………………………………………..……………. 3 2. Psychological considerations and sociological…

Words 8837 - Pages 36

English: Writing and Review Drafts / Strategy Essay

different documents and conducting research 11. Be presented with an explanation on writing drafts and proofreading; and will be expected to proofread their work before submission 12. Be responsible for their performance in class on individual and group levels 13. To develop an understanding of and respect for individuals and their ideas Specific course objectives: Students will create ten (10) graded projects. The assignments require different mediums based on the rhetorical situation. These writing…

Words 1402 - Pages 6

SGMA 217: Term Group Project

SGMA 217 – Term Group Project Final Plan Assessment Group Number 25 Through delegation and teamwork, group 25, also known as TB Pac managed to complete, bind, and hand in a final report on time. By assigning two points to each member, along with one general objective (e.g. Summary/Introduction), the group work was distributed evenly and each member knew their responsibilities clearly. Although the final goal was achieved, it took a much different turn then we had initially envisioned. While making…

Words 382 - Pages 2

General Expectations For All Members Of A Team

are the general expectations for all members of the team? 1. Correspondence and meetings will be conducted through the team forum. Every team member should make the effort to participate daily, allowing for each members opinion to be heard and for projects to be finished in a timely manner. Team members who know they will be absent on particular days should post any ideas, topic choices, or individual submissions prior to their absence. 2. Any e-mail communication between members regarding course material…

Words 760 - Pages 4

project portfolio Essay examples

Project (PORTFOLIO) INTRODUCTION: FINAL PROJECT Throughout the quarter, each of you will choose an issue in social psychology to research. This project will provide you an opportunity to practice research skills which are important for your professional careers. The resulting data evaluation skills will serve to improve your ability to make decisions. Topic areas for Social Psychology include: Aggression Altruism Group Process Prejudice and Discrimination Gender Self-Identity You will write a white…

Words 1389 - Pages 6

Essay Linux Vs Mac

Linux vs. Mac Project Plan [Note: Text enclosed in square brackets and displayed in blue italics (style=InfoBlue) is included to provide guidance to the author and should be deleted before publishing the document. Or, one can hide the text for viewing and/or printing because it is set as hidden-text.] 1 Introduction Our Team will compare the contrast between Linux and Mac Operating Systems to see which operating system outweighs the other in relations to the better system usage [Briefly describe…

Words 396 - Pages 2

2014 Fall Business Comm Calendar Wyatt Essay

(Labor Day) W Cover Letters F Personal Statements • PAR Statements, Realistic Goals, Personal Plans Quiz 1: Career Documents Résumé Draft 3 M Sep. 8 Interview Skills W Word Processing: Templates, Styles, Page Setup, Settings… F Word Processing: Headers/Footers, Automation, Collaboration Quiz 2: Word Processing Basics Cover Letter and Personal Statement Drafts 4 M Sep. 15 Assembling and Managing Teams W Personal Pitches and Mock Interviews Personal Pitch Evaluations (in class) F Intro to…

Words 612 - Pages 3

Boobies: Writing and Microsoft Publisher Essay

Question: How can classic literature and writing be made appealing to modern audiences? Task and End Results: • Answer the driving question! • In a small group, create a front page of a “newspaper” for one section of the Odyssey. • As a class, create a modern day newspaper gallery retelling the story of the Odyssey. • Present the gallery to a group of critics who will judge whether or not your product makes classic literature (the Odyssey) and classic writing styles (newspapers) appealing to modern…

Words 2498 - Pages 10

Essay on Mike Jansen Research Proposal

Proposal Assignment Authorization and Background My project idea focuses on how recent advancements in technology have changed communication in the workplace. The changes in technology have had a monumental impact on the workplace over the last 15 years. Communication is certainly essential to the success of a business. In today’s modern world, technology is a staple within every workplace. Identify the Audience Since I am a part of group B, you will be the primary reader. Define the Problem…

Words 334 - Pages 2

Minimum Wage Essay

492, 493 (WI): Senior Design for Materials Engineers Department of Materials Science and Engineering Drexel University Fall, Winter and Spring Quarters, 2008-09 Lecture: Wednesdays, 11:00 - 11:50 am, Randell 121 (with ECE Dept.) Group Meeting: Wednesdays, 12:00 - 12:50 pm, Randell 328B MSE Department Coordinating Instructor: Dr. Richard Knight Office: LeBow 335; Phone: 215-895-1844 E-mail: knightr@coe.drexel.edu Office Hours: By appointment WIT Tutors:…

Words 3275 - Pages 14