Groupthink Theory

Submitted By GusWeinstein
Words: 1175
Pages: 5
Open Document
Theory Paper: Groupthink

August Weinstein
Ithaca College

STCM 10300
Section 1
February 5, 2015

The Oxford Dictionary defines theory as a system of ideas intended to explain something; especially one based on general principles independent of the thing to be explained. Irving Janis, a research psychologist from Yale University, developed a theory that described the systematic errors made by groups when making a collective decision. “Groupthink is a concurrence-seeking tendency among group members of high prestige, tightly knit policy-making groups” (Yetiv, 2003, p. 420). According to Rose’s Diverse Perspectives on the Groupthink Theory (2013), groupthink occurs normally when there’s a strong sense of “we” within the group. People would rather be on “good terms” with the group members than make an educated, well thought out decision. According to Yetiv’s paper published in the British Journal of Political Science (2003), groupthink is most likely to occur in groups that are cohesive or exhibit a high level of teamwork. Irving Janis wanted to understand how a group of individuals came up with excellent decisions one time and another time totally mess up. So what is the groupthink theory? According to Yetiv (2003), groupthink is when a homogenous highly cohesive group is so concerned with maintaining unanimity that they fail to make evaluate all their alternatives and make the wrong decision. Janis believed there is a turning point in a group’s decision-making process when the priority shifts from finding the best solution to coming to a unanimous decision (Janis, 1991, p. 248). How does the groupthink theory work? Remember the last time you were part of a group, perhaps during a school or work project. Imagine someone offers up an idea that you think is pretty awful. However, everyone else in your group agrees with the person who suggested the idea. Do you voice your opinion? In many cases, people engage in groupthink and their opinions just seem to disappear. Group members place emphasis on everyone agreeing and not feeling threatened, that’s why decisions are sometimes underdeveloped, scattered or just plain wrong (Rose, 2013, p.4). When does groupthink usually occur? According top Yetiv (2003), groupthink usually happens during a fiasco or a high-stress level situation. Groupthink has some benefits. When working with a large number of people, it often helps the group complete tasks, make decisions, and finish projects quickly. Groupthink also eliminates disagreements and inner-group conflict, which can save time in the long run. However, this theory also has s. The suppression of individual’s opinions and thoughts can lead to underdeveloped and sometimes poor solutions (Janis, 1991, p. 250).
The three types of antecedent conditions that can affect a group’s decision-making process are organizational structure faults, situational factors and cohesion of the group. Some examples of organizational structure faults are insulation of the group, lack of impartial leadership and lack of methodical procedure (Rose, 2013, p. 2). Situational factors include, but aren’t limited to, high stress from external threats, temporary low self-esteem after a bad idea, excessive difficulties or moral dilemmas (Rose, 2013, p. 3). Cohesion of the group can be the most detrimental variable, if the group members like each other too much or have sometime of emotional connection, they are less likely to voice their opinions and disagree with the majority (Janis, 1991, p. 251). These three variables are the most detrimental to the outcome of the group’s objective.
Groupthink has affected some of the most important historical events of all time, the Bay of Pigs, Challenger space shuttle, the Pearl Harbor attack. One of the most infamous invasions of all-time failed because of groupthink. The Bay of Pigs was a planned invasion of Cuba by Cuban exiles to overthrow Fidel Castro, approved by President John F. Kennedy and his
Show More

Related Documents: Groupthink Theory

Queer Theory Paper

this paper will be about queer theory and transgender studies. It will talk about the struggles that people who identify as transgender face every day while attending school or even just out in society. Most of these struggles are caused by other people not being accepting of what this person identifies as. It will go into detail about a few different topics in that happen in schools such as policy, bathroom use, and bullying. Then it will end with a conclusion that discusses how this paper is connected…

Words 2031 - Pages 9

Watson Theory Paper

Watson's Theory of Caring Jane Padilla NUR/403 January 15, 2013 Julie Ann Hankins This paper will talk about Dr. Jean Watson, her theory background, and will provide the concepts of her theory. Furthermore, I will connect the theory to person, health, nursing, and environment of the caring moment and apply a transpersonal relationship and relate these issues within my Practice, skills and experience. Dr. Jean Watson was born in a small town in West Virginia in 1940s. She began…

Words 1720 - Pages 7

Adult Theory Paper

Learning Theory Paper INFT 101 August 15, 2013 Summary Adults learning has long been an area of study. When they feel others imposing, ideas or action on them adults learners resist learning (Fidishun, 2000). Adults have specific ways of learning that may be different ways because we are older. There are conflicting perspectives on adult learning as it relates itself from early childhood development practices and overall approaches to learning. “Adults learning theories provide…

Words 772 - Pages 4

Communication Theory Paper

Communication Theory paper Spiral of Silence theory Brown. Sharon Public Speaking Spiral of Silence Theory I will be informing you about The Spiral of silence theory which describes the process by which one opinion becomes dominant because those who recognize their opinion to be in the minority are less likely to speak up out of fear of isolation. The debt of one's social environment may not always be correct with reality. First…

Words 1236 - Pages 5

Adlerian Theory Paper

Adlerian theory “recognizes and stresses the effect of social class, racism, sex, and gender on the behavior of individuals,” (Corey, 2013) which is a multicultural approach that is appropriate when counseling clients of diverse backgrounds. Again, this theory focuses on wellness not pathology and places emphasis on one’s ability to shape and define their own goals, while addressing “social equality issues and social embeddedness of humans.” (Corey, 2013) It is a fact that “race, ethnicity, and culture…

Words 1065 - Pages 5

Communication Theories Paper

Communication theories paper Amanda Haring Com 310 Communication is defined as a process by which information is exchanged between individuals through a common system of symbols, signs or behavior. Communication helps us understand one another. ("Communication", 2011). Communication is broken down into theories. Three examples of these theories would be the social penetration theory, cognitive dissonance theory and the uncertainty reduction theory. The social penetration theory was created…

Words 1167 - Pages 5

Examining Theory Paper

Examining Theory Paper In this paper I am going to go with the video for social structure theory when covering the following topics. I will introduce how the video supports a social structure theory, the primary subject and content, major principles of the sociology theory addressed and social issues discussed. I am going to discuss, in the last part of this paper, what are some possible consequences for a social policy change. The video that I have chosen to do this paper on will be the “Pelican…

Words 2242 - Pages 9

Attachment Theory Paper

growth and has an immense impact on their overall well-being. The paper explores that attachment patterns are impacted not only primarily by biological factors but also by cultural customs and practices, which leads to variances among cultures. The paper seeks to emphasize the relevance of cultural context for comprehension and application of attachment theory by exploring the limitations of its Western-based research background. This paper aims to offer a link between cultures and patterns of attachment…

Words 2296 - Pages 10

Labeling Theory Paper

Two major well-known sections of theories in the field of criminology are labeling theories and life course and developmental theories. Labeling theory discusses what it means to be a criminal, as well as how one specific behavior could lead to a dozen reactions. These theories also discuss the aftermath and the impact labeling theory has on a person’s life. Life course and developmental theories focus on a person and their life’s trajectories, onset, persistence, desistance, childhood, and cognition…

Words 976 - Pages 4

Communication Theories Paper

Communication Theories Paper Communication theories are important to learn and understand. Learning these theories helps us apply the theory to our own life. It helps our critical thinking skills as well as benefits one to understand the value of research that has been accomplished in this field. Understanding communication theories can help us make sense of our daily life experiences. There are three Communication theories that I have studied that have touched on my personal and professional…

Words 1905 - Pages 8