Guns, Germs, And Steel By Jared Diamond

Submitted By kuher1
Words: 2643
Pages: 11
Open Document
Katherine Uher
POSC 102, Section 003
April 16, 2013

International Development

American scientist Jared Diamond published a novel, Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fate of Human Societies in 1997 in attempt to explain the discrepancies in human development since the beginning of time. Diamond addresses regional differences in global development, how and why the Western world – known as the global North or developed states – became modernized before other parts of the world, still viewed as “developing” – known as the global South or developing states. It has been a common ideal throughout history that the states of the global South would socially, economically, and politically “catch up” to the global North. However, many states have been unable to establish such stable socio-economic constructs. International development – also known as globalization - is the process that, ideologically, will alleviate the gaps between states. Scholars only disagree on how effectively and efficiently make globalization a reality. Global inequality stems from lack of uniform progress throughout history. It has become a worldwide objective to close the gap between the rich and the poor countries and to involve all nations in what is referred to as a “global market”. In a global market, all countries (regardless of stage of development) play a role in international trade. The major debate is how the gap should be closed and the priorities involved. The majority of scholars concur that foreign aid is not enough to inflict permanent change. In order to change the economic condition of a nation, social and political reforms need to occur simultaneously. Bruce Scott published an article “The Great Divide in the Global Village” in Foreign Affairs magazine in 2001 focusing on economic inequality worldwide. Scott asserts that though average income throughout the world is increasing, so is the income gap between the rich and poor. The article focuses on the “self-serving world-view” (Scott, 2001) implying globalization assumes the way the Western world developed will be effective for countries attempting to undergo economic reform. Furthering economic development requires a change in the way we approach it. Foreign aid from the Western world to “third-world”, or developing, countries is usually more detrimental than beneficial because of the conditions the lending country implements. Foreign investment is also not practical as 70% occurs between rich countries (Scott, 2001). Renovation of institutions and economic situations in developing nations can only occur in combination with social and political reform. Scott backs his theory with evidence of the development of the Western world. Capital-rich countries today had to undergo an arduous route to achieve their current status, which focused on a transition to complete government liability. Scott also notes capital-rich countries did not develop with the pressures and competition the global market offers today. He concludes by saying economic reform should take a “country-by-country approach” (Scott, 2001).
Moíses Naím approaches the condition of global economics by addressing the misconceptions of international inequality in his article “Our Inequality Anxiety”. Naím believes The focus of the global economy should not be on the discrepancies between developed and developing countries because that percentage has not changed significantly enough in the past several decades. The more prominent issue is lowering the poverty level by helping provide higher standards of living – education, health care, clean water, job opportunities, etc. (Naím, 2006). Yasheng Huang presents on the question “Does Democracy Stifle Economic Growth” in a TED Talk aired in 2011. Huang compares Asian countries – primarily India and China – to observe the effects of government style on economic conditions. Huang testifies democracy can be a hindrance because growth is always delayed compared to Authoritarian governments,
Show More

Related Documents: Guns, Germs, And Steel By Jared Diamond

International Relations Theory

2.2.2 Historical development of International Relations The narration of international relations as a distinct discipline can be marked out back to a number of years past; Buzanand Little for instance, believe the relations of very old Sumerian city-states, early in 3,500 BC, as the primary fully-fledged international arrangement (Barry & Buzan, 2000). The King Wladyslaw IV official portraits dressed in Polish, French and Spanish fashions replicate the multifaceted politics of the Polish-Lithuanian…

Words 1616 - Pages 7

International Relations Theory

Kristin Hollander Professor creed Hyett International relations 202 17 February 2014 International relations theory’s What is a theory? How do theories fit into international relations? A “theory is a set of propositions and concepts that combine to explain phenomena by specifying the relationships among the propositions.” (Mingst and Arreguin-Toft 76) Theories are used to predict and explain why things have happened. When looking at international theories we find ways to help us understand…

Words 980 - Pages 4

international relations Essay

Oct 22 Domestic politics: hierarchal institutions and law International politics: lack of hierarchal institutions and law --LEVITHAN-- No logic of anarchy-Hobbes Anarchy breeds insecurity, self-help, egoism Anarchy is what states make of it (some adapt and excel, some perish) many possibilities and factors Ex: College is a relative anarchy (some kids excel and some fail) Ideas have power because people talk about them (regardless of their practicality or relative truth) Hobbes is everywhere…

Words 1063 - Pages 5

international relations paper

The once thriving and healthy lives wildlife possessed all throughout the planet are diminishing rapidly. The presence of humans and our actions have had an immensely prominent role in affecting species and their natural habitats. The way we treat the environment, directly or indirectly, has a huge impact on species and eventually may drive them to extinction. Species are threatened every day throughout every continent. The rate of extinction has increased drastically since the early 1900’s, starting…

Words 1541 - Pages 7

International Relations And Foreign Policy

PL2153 International Relations and Foreign Policy Minor Essay Subject Coordinator: Dr Surin Maisrikrod Present by： Yizhi Cao 12657488 Introduction The earlier international relations history can be tracked back to 1648 of the Peace Treaty of Westphalia. It is a milestone that marks the beginning of the modern state system development. Stanley Hoffman once remarked that international relations theory is both an old and young discipline1. The study of international relations…

Words 1862 - Pages 8

The Politics Of International Economic Relations

Politics of International Economic Relations The purpose of the essay is to draw out the conceptual differences of Liberalism, Realism and Marxism. Each author stands for different approach among the three readings. Deundey and Ikenberry are liberals, Gilpin researches for Realism, David Harvey is a typical scholar of Marxism. The perspectives of three authors overlap on three issues but have different view on them. The first issue is what are the main actors involved in economic relations according…

Words 1515 - Pages 7

Essay International Relations Debates

International Relations Debates That we should deploy troops in Iraq We = West (US, UK, AUS) – Australia in collaboration with Gulf States (Qatar, Kuwait) + Iran (30 000 current troops)/Saudi Arabia. Affirmative Case: Background: Destruction of cultural heritage in those states. Forcibly take over oil supplies. Beheading people. Sharia Law: Sexual violence, Violent Law, Enslavement (6000), Legal Marriage Age is 9. Any worshipping of Gods/idols is considered bad (Apostasy) – you are an apostate…

Words 379 - Pages 2

Identity: International Relations and Power Essay

Identity Explain the conventional account of the development of the modern state system as founded by the Peace of Westphalia. 1) Peace of Westphalia in 1648 – to end 30 year war between conflict of power between churches & kings over sovereign rule 2) Religious sovereignty OUT, state sovereignty IN 3) 3 key principles: i) State sovereignty (i.e state>church) ii) Self determination (i.e state is highest authority, can make…

Words 2774 - Pages 12

Denied: Philosophy and International Relations Essay

school. The passion I feel for both international politics and philosophy must be fulfilled extracurricularly, usually through personal reading. I have amassed a respectable library for both subjects and spend many hours studying them. I enjoy each for the same reason. Each discipline is based on conflict; international politics is a conflict of polities, economies, and societies, while philosophy is a conflict of ideas and systems of thought. In international politics I consider myself a globalist;…

Words 611 - Pages 3

Hegemonic, And Pluralistic Theories Of International Relations

Cyclical, Hegemonic, and Pluralistic Theories of International Relations: Some Comparative Reflections on War Causation Author(s): Franz Kohout Source: International Political Science Review / Revue internationale de science politique, Vol. 24, No. 1, Power Cycle Theory and Global Politics. Cycle de pouvoir et politique mondiale (Jan., 2003), pp. 51-66 Published by: Sage Publications, Ltd. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1601329 . Accessed: 12/03/2014 22:13 Your use of the JSTOR…

Words 8608 - Pages 35