Essay on Han and Rome DBQ

Submitted By lilangelinabella
Words: 846
Pages: 4
Open Document
Han and Rome DBQ
Han and Roman attitudes towards technology both changed over time for the better. The Han attitude toward manufacturing and labor of technology was more open and positive than the Romans, which had a more organized and class divided society. Documents 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 and 8 are all from government officials’ points of view. Documents 3 and 7 are from a philosopher’s point of view. In short, in the documents 1, 2, 3, and 4, the Han people share attitudes in advancement in technology and its effect on the common people, documents 6 and 8 believed in the use of resources to make remarkable public work projects, and finally 5 and 7 describe that inventors of technology are lesser members of society and that they were taken for granted.
The Han people had well thought out communication that effectively advanced their technology to positively evolve, this can be shown in documents 1, 2, 3 and 4. Document 2 was written by Haun Guan, a government official in the 1st century BCE. He focuses on an analytical comparison between how technology actually devolved. The state became involved and stopped caring about the people, due to them monopolizing the salt and iron trades. In earlier times, families put their heart into making high quality tools. Overtime as the state wanted to gain control and dominate the production of tools, they made the decision to have unmotivated and uneducated convicts produce poor quality and ineffective tools at a much higher price. As a result of poor communication on behalf of the state, the quality of services and products decreased as prices increased. This also had a negative impact on the common people and their faith in the state. Huan Guan is a government official who is opposed to how the state monopolizes and shows a lack of concern for the commoners’ complaints. Document 1 was written by a Han government official in the 2nd century BCE, it urges the importance of waterways and engineering, and how the government should regulate the transition of water to prevent floods. This request was made to organize the system more efficiently and reduce the hard labor of lower class men. This will increase job opportunities and increase the protection of the city. This letter provided a great action plan that properly informed everyone that needed to know what needs to be done and how in order to prevent floods. This demonstrates how communication is essential to improving technology and the importance of government support for it. This government official feels responsible for the disunity of the water ways because he was the one in charge of it. Document 3 is written by Huan Tan, a philosopher. He is listing the progress of technology after the emperor’s first invention. He somewhat over exaggerates the use of the pestle and mortar and how well water power has helped by saying the, “benefit was increased a hundredfold.” However, it actually shows how much the Han focus on the effectiveness of their technology. There is a possibility of bias in Document 4 because the history is sponsored by the government, the general trend would be to glorify an empire, and not to mention that glorification of an emperor was a promotion of Buddhism. It is during the same time the Han lost their Mandate of Heaven. An additional document from a commoner would be helpful in determining Document 4’s validity. Roman government
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Han and Rome DBQ

Han China And Rome Dbq Essay

economic issues that weakened both of their empires. Those political and economic issues resulted in the collapse of the empires. Towards the end of both of the empires they both had faced a problem, high taxes. In document one it talks about how Han China how the taxes became so high that basically people couldn’t afford them, which in result weakened China financially. The result of the high taxes in China hurt China more. In document three it talks about how revolts were formed, raids started…

Words 389 - Pages 2

Han Dynasty Dbq

Han and Roman Technology DBQ The Han Dynasty was one of the most powerful Chinese dynasties to ever exist. It had a huge bureaucracy with approximately 130,000 bureaucrats which explains why the government was involved in everything, especially the use and advancement of technology. The Han Dynasty was made up by about 57 million people, most of which were craftsmen and agriculturists, which helps explain why the Han had such an open and favorable attitude towards the use of technology for production…

Words 1070 - Pages 5

Han vs Roman Essay

DBQ Katherine Lee Period 1 Both the Roman's and Han Chinese had an appreciation for technological advancements, despite the difference in areas where the technological attention was focused on. The Hans appreciated the laboring tools-related more than the Romans, who concentrated on more mathematic and scientific advancements. Han China’s attitude toward manufacturing and labor was more open, positive and looked out for the well-being of the community while the Romans had a more standardized society…

Words 870 - Pages 4

dbq on changes Essay

Joanna Jimenez AP World History October 10, 2013 Mr. D Antonio DBQ Essay Having water has always been a basic necessity for all of humanity since the beginning of life itself. Ways to get it have become more and more advanced as time went on. Without the enhancement of tools and the skill of the workers building these large projects we as a society would still use large pots to draw water out of the river. The Han and Roman Empires often addressed the necessity to create an easier way to…

Words 2357 - Pages 10