Hanna Rosin's 'Battle Hymn Of The Tiger Mother'

Words: 1289
Pages: 6
Open Document
Several parents believe that their parenting style is superior to others. Amy Chua is an excellent example of a superior parenting style. Chua believes that Chinese parenting is the best compared to alternative styles (219-22). Hanna Rosin’s parenting style contradicts Chua’s style. Rosin believes in a laid back parenting style, and give utmost freedom to her children (222-25). There are several aspects of Chua’s parenting style that many do not agree with. Similarly, there are aspects of Rosin’s parenting style that several people do not agree with. Therefore, many parents have adopted a parenting style in between Amy Chua’s and Hanna Rosin’s. Amy Chua’s strict parenting style restricted her daughters, Louisa and Sophia, from attending a …show more content…
Rosin believes that allowing children to explore and have fun is the best way for children to learn and grow (223). Rosin describes herself as the “...weak-willed, pathetic Western parent…” stated in Amy Chua’s comic memoir, Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother (221-23). Rosin’s technique is not to threaten her children, but shower them with encouragement (223). Most parents believe that allowing an excessive amount of freedom is dangerous for children. Therefore, the majority of parents have an equal balance between Amy Chua’s and Hanna Rosin’s parenting …show more content…
One of the several reasons is Chinese parents think their children are forever in debt to them (Chua 221). The reason Chinese parents believe their children are in debt to them is because Chinese parents have dedicated a considerable amount of time to their children (Chua 221). Amy Chua is not wrong. According to Chua, Chinese parents spend a large chunk of their life training, teaching, and developing their children to be the best (221). Chua thinks their children have to repay the time spent perfecting them by making their parents proud (221). Admittingly, Chua is correct when she says, “Chinese parents have sacrificed and done so much for their children” (221). However, Chua’s belief in which children have to spend their lives repaying their parents is incorrect. Rosin responds to Chua’s ideology in which children have to repay their parents (223-24). According to Hanna Rosin, the job of parents is to guide their children in the correct direction, and not expect to be repaid (223-24). A large majority of parents agree with Hanna Rosin’s belief, but also consider Chua’s argument. Finally, after debating on which belief is correct, some parents innovated a solution of their own. The solution is a combination between Chua and Rosin’s beliefs. Therefore creating a way of raising children where they make their parents proud and move forward in life. In consequence, children will not be
Show More

Related Documents: Hanna Rosin's 'Battle Hymn Of The Tiger Mother'

Adapted From Battle Hymn Of The Tiger Mom Analysis

As Amy Chua’s book “Adapted From Battle Hymn Of The Tiger Mother” was published, most people are arguing whether her way of parenting is good or not. The author of “Mother Inferior” Hanna Rosin, and the author of “Amy Chua Is A Wimp” David Brooks are presenting the different way of parenting. These three articles are focusing the difference between Chinese and Western parenting, On the other hand, Parenting is same as cooking, you cannot say which cooking(parenting) style is better, because both…

Words 1630 - Pages 7