Hobbes Vs Rousseau

Words: 454

Pages: 2

Open Document

Like Hobbes, Rousseau also shared the idea that mankind was naturally violent/barbaric, as well as separate influences that may prompt human beings to act particular ways in their theories and explain the reality of human nature (behavior) without these influences. However, unlike Hobbes, Jean-Jacques Rousseau believed that man’s human nature or natural state is peaceful and that society was the reason for altering that nature. Rousseau gives an example of how mankind had fallen away from morality and virtue, and gives into luxury and leisure by discussing how Greece’s society changed overtime as science and the arts progressed, in addition to explaining the dangers it causes. He also believed that sovereign government only benefited the people’s interest, rather than protecting the people from themselves by enforcing law and order.
Rousseau’s statement, “Man was born free, but everywhere is in chains” is accurate. His statement refers to how people have a certain amount of freedom due to the reason that there are laws and orders we must follow. We all have free will and have the ability to make our own choices and act the way we want to behave, but we still must follow the rules. Our freedom is only limited and varies within different places depending where one lives. Even isolated communities have a system of …show more content…
However, our freedom is limited because not all the choices we make are acceptable. I would say our freedom would be more dependent and not absolute. But given that there are various views on freedom and what it means to be free brings about different beliefs or ideas that mankind is or is not really free. So are we actually “born free”, given that we still have the will to make our own decisions? Maybe at some point in this life humankind was free, but for now it seems that the type of freedom we have is a partial

Hobbes Vs Rousseau

societies? Two philosophers as Thomas Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau arrive at the same solution even if intended in a slightly different way: “The Social Contract”. Thomas Hobbes starts his analysis by analyzing the nature of men. Hobbes sustain in his analysis that all men are born into a condition of substantial equality, the differences are so small that they could not be considered relevant into the achievement of their goals. This equality became for Hobbes the cause of differences between men…

Words 1431 - Pages 6

Hobbes Vs Rousseau Analysis

Unlike Rousseau, Hobbes states that if any two men desire the same thing, which only one can have, they turn against each other. This means that people need a common power or need a government to keep them in check. If people fight with each other, the only thing that can stop them is the government or another source of power. To add on, he also mentions that distrust causes people to live in fear and insecurity. As conveyed in his writing, if anyone doubts humans aren’t at war with each other or…

Words 219 - Pages 1

John Locke, And Jean-Jacques Rousseau: Article Analysis

Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean Jacques Rousseau may disagree on which form of supreme power is the most ordered (monarchy vs. democracy), they all claim because an individual’s passions and desires may possibly obstruct the rights of others, some form of government is needed. In order to live successfully, citizens willfully give up their individual freedom for the benefit that a supreme being of power will guarantee their safety and protection through state legislation. The people then can…

Words 606 - Pages 3

Second Semester: History Test Essay

1. Bossuet (16271704) Hobbes (15881679) Locke (16321704) Rousseau (17121778) Time and Background Effect on Perspective Burgundian Catholic bishop, leader of French Academy, tutor of Dauphin, son of Louis XIV, wrote before Enlightenment and French Revolution but in the midst of the English Civil War and execution of King Charles I of England when authority of the monarch needed to be reaffirmed in France to avoid similar fate. Educated Englishman who is…

Words 2157 - Pages 9

Lecture 1 Essay

level, level of education achieved, occupation and area of residence. Ascribed status: attributes assigned at birth. Achieved status: attributes developed throughout life as a result of effort and skill Family structure: Female lone parent families vs. Two parent families Urban rural differences: differences b/w small towns and large cities (access to health care, diversity in entertainment and cultural events) Historical Development of Sociology August Comte: scientist and believed that the…

Words 1380 - Pages 6

Evil Is For Good Men To Do Nothing Analysis

The constituents of living as a human on Earth develop with us both individually and with the rest of civilization. With this, good and evil cannot be simplified into two innate elements of human nature. “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” A quote by Edmund Burke encapsulates the theory and basis of philosophy in the long debated conflict between good and evil. At it’s core, this quote provides the implication that humans can be classified as either strictly…

Words 1680 - Pages 7

A Discussion Upon the Vying Perceived Importance of Soverign Rights Versus Human Rights Essay

modern concept of sovereignty came about after the Social Theory postulations of Thomas Hobbes in his work Leviathan. Hobbes argued that the Sovereignty of a ruler is provided by way of a Contract between himself and his people, a trade of some of their rights in exchange for the Sovereign power to maintain their safety. Various other philosophers have expounded upon Hobbes’ notion of Sovereignty, such as Locke, Rousseau and Austin, however the Peace Treaties of Westphalia of 1648 provide the first practical…

Words 2704 - Pages 11

Introduction Law Society 2 Essay

14-‐12-‐29 Benito Aloe, Business Law and Ethics Selected Legal Terminology • Definitions of legal terms: • See: http://www.lectlaw.com/def.htm 14-‐12-‐29 Benito Aloe, Business Law and Ethics Truth vs. Lies • What every student should read before going out into the "real world". • Navigating between truth and lie. • Harry G. Frankfurt and his essay titled: • "On Bullshit": – http://press.princeton.edu/titles/7929.html • P.S. It is only a coincidence…

Words 2453 - Pages 10

Unit 4 study guide Essay

people are selfish People are born good and given natural rights - Kings power should be limited with a constitutional monarchy Baron de Montesquieu- Wanted a constitutional monarchy Government should be in 3 sections (checks and balances) Thomas Hobbes- Religion should be separate from State Government People are fearful and greedy Believed in absolute power in the state Voltaire- All things can be explained logically Believes in freedom and respect Religion was too powerful and people suffered…

Words 1634 - Pages 7

Sociology Essay

suitable for the modern world - not sure the views of the economist Anomie, moral regulation, and freedom - smith Mandeville Hobbes, Locke, for them the isolated individual is free and society imposes restrictions, erodes freedom - Durkheim you cant be free against society, only within society - cant persist ego to impose self interest - Durkheim draws on by Rousseau (general will), but also Saint-Simon - Durkheim’s view optimistic about freedom in the modern world (hasn’t been achieved really…

Words 2792 - Pages 12