how far Essay

Submitted By archie00000000001
Words: 518
Pages: 3
Open Document
How far sources 2 and 3 support the impression of the Charge of the Light Brigade given in source 1?
Source 1 was written by William Russell for the Times Newspaper on the 14th November 1854. On the face of the source it seems that William Russell is explaining that although there were great losses in the charge, it was worth it due to the astonishing bravery and courage that was displayed on the part of the British. Although from researching Russell and his agenda in the Crimean it can be taken that this source is in fact sarcastic, and that he is belittling the British high command that sent the soldiers into the fatal charge. The tone of the source is one of anger, Russell is angry that lives have been lost for what he can see as being a totally futile reason. This is a view that has been shared over time by many famous Crimean war historians and witnesses, such as in Lord Tennyson’s poem of the charge one famous line says ‘There’s not to reason why, there’s but to do or die’.
Sources 2 disagrees with source 1. Timothy Gowing, who was a serving sergeant in the Crimean war, reflects on the charge, in his book ‘Voice from the ranks’ published in 1895. Gowing doesn’t necessarily disagree with what Russell is saying about the charge, he agrees that it was terribly bloody ‘The field was soon strewn with the dead and wounded’, but Gowing doesn’t sound angry in his source, just saddened by the loss of men, this may be that he can understand better than Russell the nature of warfare, and sometimes in the heat of battles wrong decisions are made, due to the fact that he was a serving soldier and Russell was only a reporter, so he could only see things from a reporters view.
Source 3 is an extract from Mrs Duberly’s War: Journal and Letters from the Crimea 1854-6. Here she describes the events of the events of the 25th October 1854. She describes the charge as
Show More

Related Documents: how far Essay

How Far Could You Go

possibilities... A career in HR takes you further Endless possibilities... rther A career in HR takes you fu 2 How far could you go? u Which direction will yo take? ? How do you get into HR step? What’s the next career ? What skills do you need inter Career journey: Tim Po tions Frequently asked ques ut your career Supporting you througho 4 6 9 10 11 12 13 1 How far could you go? Work anywhere! HR opens doors to jobs in every sector – the world is your oyster. You can build your career…

Words 3688 - Pages 15

How Far Will People Really Go For Love

Colin Bell Hour 1st Tale of Two Cities How far will people actually go for love? A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens takes place in the French revolution era in the cities of London and Paris. Most of the people are living in poverty and the country had little leadership from the high ranks. In the book, Sydney Carton and Charles Darnay show the theme how far people will go for love through the characteristics, love for Lucie, doing the best for the people around you, and putting other people…

Words 651 - Pages 3

How far was the failure of the divorce Essay

Kelsey Nedrick - Homework How far was the failure of the divorce by 1529, the fault of Catherine? Catherine of Aragon married Henry VIII in 1505, after a brief marriage to Henry’s younger brother Arthur. The marriage to Arthur ended quite shortly after they wedded when Arthur died of an illness. The father of Henry VIII and Arthur was not so keen on a Spanish alignment, however, after his death and Henry VIII being the heir to the throne, Henry VIII’s objective was to achieve great notoriety within…

Words 1146 - Pages 5

How Far Does Race Go? Essay

How Far Does Race Go? Wayne and Armand Aubigny Kate Chopin’s “Desiree’s Baby”, written in the late 1800s takes place during a time period where race was all that a person had. Here is an affectionate and sincere woman who was abandoned as a baby. She was found lying asleep by Madame Valmonde and Monsieur Valmonde. Having raised a nice young woman, it did not take long to fall in love. Armand fell in love instantly, “as if struck by a pistol shot”. He and Desiree got married…

Words 1010 - Pages 5

How Far She Went By Mary Hood Analysis

"How Far She Went" by Mary Hood is a tale about an out of contorl teen dealing with the hardship of losing her mother. The story takes place in a rural amaerican town where the girls name. and her grandmothers name is never revealed. The girl is sent to her grandmothers by hr father against her will. The grandmother is very critical of the girls actions and character. The two have a disaproving feeling towards eachother. Eventually the bond strengthens between the two after a vehicle accident that…

Words 94 - Pages 1

Rebellion In Mary Hood's 'How Far She Went'

good cause. In Mary Hood’s “How Far She Went,” the protagonist rebelled for all of the wrong reasons. Her and her granny to pay the consequences. John Updike’s “A & P” Sammy foolishly quit his job for some girl In Amy Tan’s “Two Kinds” is different from the last two. In Two Kinds Jing-Mei is intelligently rebelling to show her mother that she wants to stay the same. All of the three short stories have a protagonist that rebel in some type of way. Whether it be “How Far She Went,”…

Words 281 - Pages 2

How Far Was The Pilgrimage Of Grace Cau Essay

How far was the Pilgrimage of Grace caused by religious factors? (24) The Pilgrimage of Grace was an uprising in York in October 1536 headed by Robert Aske, a lawyer, protesting the Crown’s break with Rome and the dissolution of the monasteries. There are many factors that contribute to the pilgrimage of grace such as religion, social and economy, and politics. In the Lincoln and Pontefract articles of 1536 many articles clearly held religious meaning, suggesting that the Pilgrimage was caused…

Words 729 - Pages 3

Essay on How Far Do You Agree That Stalin

How far do you agree that Stalin’s revolution of led to successful modernisation of Russia? When Stalin came to power he realised he had become the leader of a backwards country which was “50 to 100 years behind the countries of the west” he knew he had to make Russia catch up with the global powers of the west in 10 years or they would crush him, little did he know how right he was as World War Two started within 10 years of Stalin saying his famous line. First of all Stalin had to create enough…

Words 1185 - Pages 5

How Far Did Chadwick Contribute To The Spread Of Cholera

less expensive because the government would not have to pay for the cost of cholera outbreaks. In his report from 1842, Chadwick evidenced the connection between disease and sanitation. It should be noted that Chadwick was a believer in the miasma theory, though this does not change the evidence that he found. His evidence provides a window into the grave conditions suffered by the poor. The poor lived in conditions that made them more vulnerable to disease. According to Mr. Thomas H. Smith, the…

Words 611 - Pages 3

How Far Was The Progress Changed In The Middle Ages In England

How far was the progress made in medicine by the Romans continued in the Middle Ages in England? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: -Public Health -Medical Training You must also include information of your own. [19 marks, 16 + 3 for SPAG] In some ways the progress made in medicine by the Romans was successfully continued in the middle Ages in England. Galen’s theories and teachings, hospitals and learning remained the same and slowly advanced through the middle ages…

Words 913 - Pages 4