Invective for Work and Play Essay

Submitted By Mertillion
Words: 1766
Pages: 8
Open Document
Invective for Work and Play:
A comparison of Catullus and Cicero’s mud-slinging antics

Brent C.
Monday, October 28th, 2013

As far back as people started to express themselves, human beings seem to have always used abusive language to undermine and destabilise others. By using a form of language known as invective, famous orators and writers of the likes of Lincoln and Sir John Falstaff have gained considerable advantage over their social and political opponents. Yet, what exactly is invective? Invective, simply put, is insulting speech meant to either destroy or build up social relations through the use of language that degrades and insults the victim.1 By far, the two most famous (or perhaps infamous) Romans in their use of invective that survives to this day is that of Catullus and Cicero. Catullus, born c.84 in Verona and living until 54 BCE, was a love poet, while Cicero, living c.106 to 43 BCE, was one of the best lawyers and politicians of his time.2 Being contemporary, and being from a similar if not identical background, it is only natural to wish to compare the two, but with it questions arise: Did they both use invective for the same purpose? Did they have a similar style despite using different forms of literature? Who did they chose to insult, how did they chose to insult them, and most importantly, to what ends?

Before tackling what and why, it seems to be reasonable to examine exactly whom these giants of invective were targeting with their insults. Unsurprisingly, whom they chose to insult just happened to correlate directly to their professions. Cicero, being a bigwig politician and lawyer, insulted primarily the defendant as a prosecutor, and (without much surprise) his political opponents. In Catilinam is essentially Cicero insulting Lucius Sergius Catilina repeatedly to expose his plot to overthrow the senate.3 In Verrem, this time persecuting Gaius Verres, is essentially the same.4 He occasionally does have clients to defend as a lawyer, and in this case, such as in Pro Caelio, he, interestingly enough, uses invective to diminish the crime his client “possibly” committed by dehumanising the victim.5
Catullus is a little less, professional, in his antics and consequently, his choice of targets. His invective poetry are divided into two succinct categories; He is either insulting an ex-lover or a potential lover he disapproves of, or he is putting down his male rivals which were occasionally politicians. For instance, XLI and XLIII are meant solely to put down Ameana as being nowhere near good enough for Catullus.6 Similarly, LXXX, LXXXVIII, LXXXIX, and XCI, completely destroy Gellius, a Consul, seemingly without provocation.7
Which leads succinctly to the question of “Why?”. Why would these grand, and very eloquent, orators decide to stoop to the level of childish mud-flinging, and use their schooling and vocabulary to describe such filth? In fact, the nastiness in public discourse was so high, it caused some historians to throw into question the so-called glory of the Roman Empire.8 The reason is quite clear: It was to get ahead. For Cicero, it was to get ahead as a lawyer. The way he destroyed not only Catalina, but all of his compatriots and peers ensured that no one would want to associate with him. Catullus was less career orientated, but his invective and its obscenity helped catapult himself into a state of irreproachable love god-poet hybrid, idolised by both man and woman alike.9

Although so different in form and use, Catullus and Cicero shared a common theme in many of their poems; Sex and masculinity. Unlike today, Romans had an entirely different view of sexuality. It was not the entire rainbow of sex and gender we know of, but instead a very rigid line between the passive “receiver” and the active “penetrator”.10 In addition, from a contemporary viewpoint Romans had a rather unusual relationship with homosexuality. Firstly, lesbianism is
Show More

Related Documents: Invective for Work and Play Essay

Essay about Satire and Personal Satirical Devices

Irony speaks words of praise to imply blame and words of blame to imply praise. Writer is using a tongue-in-cheek style. Irony is achieved through such techniques as hyperbole and understatement. 3. Invective: Name calling, harsh, abusive language directed against a person or cause. Invective is a vehicle, a tool of anger. It is the bitterest of all satire. 4. Mock Encomium: Praise which is only apparent and which suggests blame instead. 5. Grotesque: Creating a tension between laughter…

Words 675 - Pages 3

Federal Theatre Project

Theatre Project (FTP) was a New Deal project to fund theatre and other live artistic performances in the United States during the Great Depression. It was one of five Federal One projects sponsored by the Works Progress Administration (WPA). The FTP's primary goal was employment of out-of-work artists, writers, and directors, with the secondary aim of entertaining poor families and creating relevant art. Background The FTP was established August 27, 1935, after a legislative and administrative…

Words 833 - Pages 4

Example Of Pathos Argument

Becky’s beagle barked and bayed, becoming bothersome for Billy. 7. Allusion-a figure of speech that makes a reference to, or a representation of, people, places, events, literary work, myths, or works of art, either directly or by implication. Ex: He was a real Romeo with the ladies. Romeo was a character in Shakespeare’s play, Romeo and Juliet, and was very romantic in expressing his love for Juliet. 8. Amplification- The act or result of amplifying, enlarging, or extending. Ex: The professor gave…

Words 1321 - Pages 6

GLOSSARY OF LITERARY TERMS Essay

free from limitations or qualifications (“best,” “all,” “unique,” “perfect”) adage—a familiar proverb or wise saying ad hominem argument—an argument attacking an individual’s character rather than his or her position on an issue allegory—a literary work in which characters, objects, or actions represent abstractions alliteration—the repetition of initial sounds in successive or neighboring words allusion—a reference to something literary, mythological, or historical that the author assumes the reader…

Words 2178 - Pages 9

Assembling Your Policy Brief

health care reform legislation signed into law by president Obama in March 2010 which included change elements that require most individuals to secure health insurance or pay fines, made coverage easier and less costly to obtain, suppression on invective insurance practices, and…

Words 2232 - Pages 9

Essay on Bullough Psychical Distance

with Art, certain trains of thought by no means devoid of interest or of speculative importance. Perhaps the most obvious suggestion is that of actual spatial distance, i.e. the distance of a work of Art from the spectator, or that of represented spatial distance, i.e. the distance represented within the work. Less obvious, more metaphorical, is the meaning of temporal distance. The first was noticed already by Aristotle in his Poetics; the second has played a great part in the history of painting…

Words 4312 - Pages 18

English Essay

be true. qua: in the capacity or character of; as. invective: insulting or abusive language. bowdlerize: to remove or modify the parts considered offensive. fait accompli: an accomplished and presumably irreversible deed or fact. pettifogger: a petty, unscrupulous lawyer; also, who quibbles over trivia. vagary: an extravagant, erratic, or unpredictable notion, action, or occurrence. idyll: a poem or prose work depicting rural or pastoral life; also, a carefree episode…

Words 2673 - Pages 11

Literary Terms Essay

or injecting humor. Angst—A term used in existential criticism to describe both the individual and the collective anxiety-neurosis of the period following the Second World War. This feeling of anxiety, dread, or anguish is notably present in the works of writers like Jean Paul Sartre and Albert Camus. Annotation—Explanatory notes added to a text to explain, cite sources, or give bibliographic data (by the author or student). Antithesis—A balancing of two opposite or contrasting words, phrases…

Words 3652 - Pages 15

Essay on SAT Vocabulary Word SMART

SAT Vocabulary word SMART abash – v. to make ashamed; to embarrass abase – v. to belittle; to diminish abdicate – v. to step down from a position of power or responsibility abject – adj. hopeless; extremely sad and servile; defeated; without hope abnegate – v. to deny oneself things; to reject; to renounce; giving up oneself abortive – adj. unsuccessful abscond – v. to escape without permission abrasive – adj. rubbing away; tending to grind down abridge – v. to shorten; to condense absolute…

Words 6701 - Pages 27