Involuntary Manslaughter Case Essay example

Submitted By Delaneyxxx
Words: 1581
Pages: 7
Open Document
Delaney Hodgson
Chicarelli
P.O.D.
26 November 2014
Kansas vs. Billy Scott and the Drunken Latina Alcohol is one of the greatest causes of death worldwide— it’s a poison, especially when given in excess by someone who only cares about a person’s money. Bartender Billy Scott was convicted of Involuntary Manslaughter, after allegedly killing Juanita Goodpasture, who died after consuming a red, yellow, and green alcoholic drink aptly named “The Stoplight.” Scott challenged his conviction on the belief that Goodpasture caused her own death by voluntarily drinking in excess, and continued to argue his side throughout the remainder of the case. When discussing Manslaughter, one must know the difference between the degrees of it, and how a person is decided to be charged with which. A separate crime from murder, manslaughter charges depend on the concept that the accused person did not mean to kill but brought about the death through illegal or irresponsible behavior. The word “kill” connotes proximate causation— not merely a peaceful, natural death. There are three types of Manslaughter, the first being Vehicular Manslaughter. This is a charge which can be used to prosecute someone who kills another person with a motor vehicle as a result of negligent or illegal driving. To gain a better understanding, someone who makes the rather dumb decision to drive drunk and causes a crash, where the result is the death of another person, may be charged with vehicular manslaughter. The second type of Manslaughter is Voluntary Manslaughter. This is the killing of a human being in which the offender had no prior intent to kill, and acted during the heat of the moment. Also, this person could possibly be under circumstances that would cause any reasonable person to become emotionally or mentally unstable. It is sometimes referred to as a “non-negligent manslaughter.” The following is an example of Voluntary Manslaughter. Dan comes home to find his wife in bed with Victor. In the heat of the moment, Dan picks up a golf club from next to the bed and strikes Victor in the head, killing him instantly. (“FindLaw: Voluntary Manslaughter Overview”)
The last of the three types is Involuntary Manslaughter. This is the unintentional killing of a human being that was committed during the carrying out of a lawful act in an unlawful manner. Let’s use poor old Dave in our example once more. Dave comes home to find his wife in bed with Victor, again… In order to drown out his sorrows, Dave heads to his local bar and gets intoxicated. Not thinking, he jumps in his car and strikes a pedestrian, killing him almost instantly. Rule number one, don’t drink and drive. Rule number two, don’t hit pedestrians. (Unless it is Victor, and then you can because he is sleeping with your wife.) Moral of the story, poor Dave would ultimately get charged with Involuntary Manslaughter because his wife is unfaithful. In case it hasn’t reached a full understanding, the following pages are going to be a prolonged example of our case defendant’s charge: Involuntary Manslaughter.
Billy LeRoy Scott was a 34 year old bar owner living in what seemed like the prime of his life. He owned The Point, a local bar that received good business, including that of Juanita Goodpasture, who was a regular at the establishment. Upon entering the bar, Juanita commenced drinking almost immediately, where her mother and sister joined her for a night of fun. She then participated in a drinking contest. This involved a red, yellow, and green concoction called the Stoplight Challenge. (“Jail Time”) The three women were drinking at the bar when Scott served the red, yellow and green drink to Goodpasture, according to testimony.
After drinking presumably too much alcohol, Goodpasture decided it was best to go home. Before she could even make it to her door, she collapsed in the lawn in front of her home. Whether she died over night, or promptly when she hit the ground, Juanita was found dead the next
Show More

Related Documents: Involuntary Manslaughter Case Essay example

The law on involuntary manslaughter is in urgent need of reform Essay

The law on involuntary manslaughter is in urgent need of reform, discuss (50 Marks) Involuntary Manslaughter is defined as ‘an unlawful killing where the Defendant (D) does not have the intention, either direct or oblique, to kill or to cause grievous bodily harm (GBH)’. The actus reus for Involuntary Manslaughter is similar that to Murder, that is, causing the unlawful death of another. There are 3 ways of committing involuntary manslaughter; Unlawful Act, Gross Negligence and Reckless Manslaughter…

Words 1125 - Pages 5

James Crumbley's Trial: Involuntary Manslaughter

convicted of involuntary manslaughter. James Crumbley was found guilty on all four counts of involuntary manslaughter. Each count represents one of the four students murdered by his son, Ethan Crumbley, during the school shooting. James Crumbley faces a potential maximum sentence of up to 15 years in prison for each count of involuntary manslaughter. Since there are four counts, the maximum sentence could be 60 years. Manslaughter is a felony under Michigan law. The maximum penalty for manslaughter in Michigan…

Words 198 - Pages 1

State Vs. Sitting Crow Case

Through reading chapter seven of the textbook, in addition to the State v. Sitting Crow Case, I learned an immense amount of information relating to the different types of homicide. The first question on this discussion board asks what the difference between murder and manslaughter is. As defined in the textbook and in our lecture video, murder is the unlawful killing of an individual with malice. When we examine this definition, we can break it down into several parts. The first part of this definition…

Words 663 - Pages 3

Essay about Crimes Against People

not limited to, offenses such as murder, manslaughter, battery, and assault. Although stalking is considered a crime against a person, it does not require the threat or use of physical force. I will provide you with a more detailed overview of the above stated offenses and the respective punishments for crimes that are committed against people. The material covered will be as follows: Murder- Felony Murder Voluntary Manslaughter- Involuntary Manslaughter Simple Battery- Battery-…

Words 1258 - Pages 6

Essay on Unit 3

offences against the person ➢ Defences ➢ Critical evaluation of law on the offences against the person Summary of non-fatal offences:- |Crime |Actus Reus |Mens Rea |Cases | |Assault |Causing the victim to fear |Intention or subjective |Logdon v DPP | | |immediate, unlawful personal |recklessness…

Words 3486 - Pages 14

Defence Of Criminal Law

defences to murder, their crime can be reduced to voluntary manslaughter. Voluntary manslaughter is where a partial defence to murder is successfully pleaded. The partial defences to murder can only be raised where the defendant has been charged with murder, not any other charge including involuntary manslaughter. The two partial defences to murder are; loss of control and diminished responsibility. A defendant is convicted of voluntary manslaughter if he/she had the full mens rea of the killing along with…

Words 4918 - Pages 20

Timothy Jones, 22 Was Found Guilty Of Residential Burglary And First-Degree Murder

could face a minimum of 20 years and a maximum of 60 years in prison. The purpose behind the punishment is incapacitation of Mr. Jones so he is removed from society, making it impossible for him to commit further crimes against anyone else. In this case the judge has several different choices he could impose for sentencing Mr. Jones. 1. Capital Punishment – Most serious crimes (general first-degree murder) 2. Indeterminate Sentence – Sentence offender with a minimum and maximum amount of time…

Words 536 - Pages 3

Essay on 3 DR

Procedural aspects 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Only available to charge of murder Burden of proof on the defence (s.2(2)) Standard of proof on the “balance of probabilities” (R v Dunbar (1957)) If successful, results in conviction of manslaughter (s.2(3)) Pleas of guilty to manslaughter may be accepted if the evidence is “clear” (R v Vinagre (1979)) Homicide Act 1957, s.2 (new version) (1) A person (“D”) who kills or is a party to the killing of another is not to be convicted of murder if D was suffering…

Words 1122 - Pages 5

George Zimmerman's Murder Case

On July 13, 2013, the murder case of George Zimmerman primarily fell into the hands of Judge Nelson. George Zimmerman allegedly shot and killed Trayvon Martin in a gated community in which both Trayvon Martin and George Zimmerman lived. Zimmerman was head over the community neighbor watch as also stated in the murder case. Throughout the trial, there were multiple eye witnesses as well as 911 calls made towards the scene. One of those key witnesses was Rachael Jeantel. Rachael was a friend of Trayvon…

Words 410 - Pages 2

Oapa: Criminal Law and reasonably Prudent Parent Essay

Following this interpretation the common law may, as shown by the cases of Stone and Dobinsoni, Gibbins and Proctorii, and Instaniii, imply a duty of care in situations where the defendant has voluntarily assumed responsibility for another’s welfare. By contrast, in Sinclair, Johnson and Smithiv the defendant’s conviction for manslaughter was quashed because he had merely done “a desultory attempt to be of assistancev”. In our case scenario Dot is under a duty of care, having voluntarily undertaken…

Words 2189 - Pages 9