Iris Young Paper

Submitted By u0832244
Words: 2307
Pages: 10
Open Document
Over the course of the nearly 70 yearlong conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, two entirely different plans have been proposed numerous times as solutions to the conflict. The first solution, being the more popular and widely accepted, is commonly referred to as the two-state solution. This proposal calls for the establishment of a separate, sovereign Palestinian state in the West Bank, Gaza, and in some cases East Jerusalem which would live alongside the state of Israel. The second proposed solution to the conflict called the one-state solution calls for the establishment of a single state in what is now Israel/Palestine and would belong to no particular nationality or religious group. A third, but far less popular, alternative exists in which Israelis and Palestinians live together in a bi-national federation. Iris Young argues in favor of this third approach through her concept of sovereignty and self-determination. Taking sovereignty as the focus, I will critically evaluate the one and two-state models in terms of their viability and advocate Young’s proposal of a bi-national federation as the best solution to the conflict. In her article Self-determination as non-domination, Ideals applied to Palestine/Israel, Young differentiates between her concept of self-determination as non-domination and the more common concept of self-determination as non-interference. Self-determination as non-interference adopts state sovereignty as its model, and understands self-determination as one group’s control of a sphere, in which others have no authority. A key element of this model is the distinction between inside and outside. “For the group to be self-determining means primarily that outsiders do not interfere with the decisions and actions made by those governing institutions over what goes on inside the jurisdiction (Young, 144).” Young disagrees with this common conception of self-determination and she points out some of the problems with it. The main weakness of the self-determination as non-interference model that Young points out is the issue of domination. One of the main reasons that groups seek self-determination is to avoid domination by others. The self-determination as non-interference model does in fact address the issue of domination, but it is domination from outside that it addresses not domination from within. “A concept of self-determination that means primarily non-interference with the internal affairs of a sovereign government implicitly allows for domination within, to the extent that it forbids outsiders from interfering if they observe such internal domination (Young, 145).” As Young points out, the problem isn’t just that this model only addresses domination from outside and not from within, but it actually creates another problem which is that preventing outside interference can actually be harmful to the self-determining peoples because it would prevent outsiders from stopping domination from within.
To address the issue of domination that the non-interference model ignores, Young proposes her own model of self-determination which she understands as non-domination. On the non-domination model, self-determination means autonomy. According to Young, “the self-determining entity should be able to set its own ends and able to act towards their realization, within the limits of respect for and cooperation with other agents whom one interacts and with whom one stands in relation (146).” This conception includes a presumption of non-interference, but this presumption can be disregarded in order to prevent the domination of one unit by another and to prevent some members of a self-determining unit from dominating other members of that unit from within. The most popular approach to solving the Israel/Palestine conflict is to adopt the two-state proposal calling for the establishment of an independent Palestinian state that would exist alongside the state of Israel, with each state having clearly
Show More

Related Documents: Iris Young Paper

Tutorial Notes: Iris Recognition In The Media

tutorial are available online: www.cse.nd.edu/~kwb/IJCB_2014_Tutorial.pdf Publications related to iris recognition: www.cse.nd.edu/~kwb/publications.htm Iris Recognition Tutorial @ IJCB 2014 September 29, 2014 Iris Recognition in the Media Iris Recognition Tutorial @ IJCB 2014 September 29, 2014 Iris Recognition in the Media Iris Recognition Tutorial @ IJCB 2014 September 29, 2014 Iris Recognition From Basics to Research Frontiers Kevin W. Bowyer Chair, Computer Science & Engineering…

Words 7254 - Pages 30

History And Use Of Biometrics

--------------------------------4 II. Types of Biometrics A. Physiological--------------------------------------------------------------------------------4 DNA fingerprinting------------------------------------------------------------------------5 IRIS Recognition--------- -----------------------------------------------------------------5 B. Behavioral------------------------------------------------------------------------------------6 Voice biometrics----------------------------------------------------------------------------6…

Words 2954 - Pages 12

Essay about Data Protection Act 1998 and Biometric Data

schools, sixth forms, colleges and 16-19 academies. Biometric data means personal information about individuals physical or behavioural characteristics that identify an individual for example: finger prints, facial shape, hand measurements and retina or iris patterns. Automated biometric recognition system uses technology to measure an individuals physical and behavioural charteristics by using equipment that operates electrinicaly. Information from an individual is combained with biometric information…

Words 1334 - Pages 6

History: World War Ii and Franco Essay examples

fauno, released in the English-speaking sphere as Pan’s Labyrinth. This film draws parallels to Franco’s world through the eyes of Ofelia, the young : The introduction sets up the context for an overall question of focus and addresses why the topic is new and important. 2: The writer poses an intersting and engaging set of research questions. 3: The paper is “thesis-driven;” this is a good, clean thesis statement that suggests an answer and sets up the argument that follows. 4: The writer introduces…

Words 6773 - Pages 28

Intersectionality In Higher Education

EDHP 552: Final Paper Introduction In higher education, the political difference that is present among students and staff is so wide and vast that we forget the inequality and privilege that some students might receive over others. The concept of intersectionality and socio-economic rivalry are important for student affairs administrators in First Year Experience (FYE) programs when addressing the intersections of racial/ethnicity and the citizenship status of first generation college students.…

Words 1352 - Pages 6

Essay about James Joyce Research

throughout his life but despite his problem, in his childhood years, he overcame them and got a good education to become a writer, whose stories are study today. James Joyce, a great writer, has composed a vast amount of stories that have entertained young people everywhere. He is well known for his experimental use of language, symbolic parallels and extensive use of monologue. Born James Augustine Aloysius Joyce on February 2, 1882 in Dublin, Ireland. Coming from a big family he was the eldest of…

Words 1937 - Pages 8

Sensation: Color and Absolute Threshold Correct Essay

3 Sensation and Perception Key: Answer, Page, Type, Learning Objective, Level Type A=Applied C=Conceptual F=Factual Level (1)=Easy; (2)=Moderate; (3)=Difficult LO=Learning Objective SG=Used in Study Guide p=page MULTIPLE CHOICE The ABCs of Perception Learning Objective- 3.1 What is sensation and how does it enter the central nervous system? 1. ______ are the raw data of experience, based on the activation of certain receptors located in the various sensory organs. a)…

Words 16146 - Pages 65

Essay on Biometrics and the future

first recorded use of biometrics dates back to the 14th century when the Spanish explorer Joao de Barros witnessed Chinese parents pressing their children’s inked fingers and feet onto paper allowing them to differentiate one child from another (Roberts, 2005). By doing this, the Chinese solved a way to tell apart young children from one another. This is one of the earliest uses of biometrics; it is still used today when children are born. Through Barros’ travels, he also noted that Chinese businessmen…

Words 1992 - Pages 8

Essay about Albinism

eyes because of the absence or defect in the enzyme that produces melanin. Melanin is responsible for pigment in plants, animals, and protists. Albinism in man has been described by many Greek and Roman writers, and the first accurate scientific paper about it was written in 1908 by Sir Archibald Garrod. Most people only think of humans in the case of albinism, but in reality, it affects humans as well as plants and animals. In plants, Albinism is the total or partial absence of chlorophyll.…

Words 2407 - Pages 10

Case Study: Impact of Reading Remediation Instruction to Non-Readers Essay

A CASE STUDY ON THE IMPACT OF READING REMEDIATION INSTRUCTION TO THE NON-READER PUPILS OF SUN VALLEY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL: AN ASSESSMENT A Research Paper submitted to the College of Education, De La Salle University Dasmarinas, Cavite In partial fulfillment of the requirements in Issues and Trends in Education To Dr. Ayuk A. Ayuk ARLITA P. VELOYA December 2012 Background of the Study "Any kind of education is a matter of training the brain. When poor readers are learning to…

Words 3985 - Pages 16