Is Passive Euthanasia Morally Wrong

Words: 1625
Pages: 7
Open Document
Should a person decided to kill, or let a person with terminal diseases to die without any medical treatment. This is a big question that many doctors have to take into consideration in their life whether is right or not. The one thing I really admired about doctors is the strong courage they have when one of their patients die on the operating rooms, or when they decided to take someone's life due to a terminal illness. The strong will they have to keep going with their professional careers not letting the suffering and pain of their patience to interfere with their personal life. Due to their work they will have a moment in their life where the life of a patient will be in their hands and they will have to choose between passive, and …show more content…
The first example, is about Smith, who drown his six-year-old cousin in the bathroom to gain an inheritance. When the child was taking a shower, He sneaks into the bathroom and drowns the child. The second example is about Jones, He will also gain an inheritance if something happens to his six years old cousin. He planned to sneak into the bathroom and drown the child, but he enters the bathroom and he sees the child slip and hit his head and fall face down in the water. He is happy to see this and do nothing to save the child. James Rachel compared these two examples with medical case, and he concludes that passive Euthanasia and active Euthanasia are the same. If these two options are the same that mean abortion is the same as well because the mothers decide to kill the baby when the baby is still alive inside her womb is not this same as passive euthanasia. It is not, to me is different because the causes that relies the action is not justified to be nominated to be as active euthanasia. I' m not agree with what James Rachel said because killing is an act that a person make to bring death to a patient while doing nothing mean that you don't act to bring the death to a person, the patient die due to his own illness to me both actions are totally different. The patients have the right to decide how to end their own life, and this makes passive Euthanasia, and active Euthanasia different. A patient that is …show more content…
An example is from the essay," The way we do it, the way they do it" by Margaret P. Battin. She examined euthanasia practice in three societies, Netherlands where physician performed Euthanasia, Germany where suicide is allowed, but active euthanasia is not, and the united states where passive euthanasia is allowed, but active euthanasia is not. She concluded that physicians assisted suicide, and it works best for the united states as end of life practices. I agree with her conclusion only if a patient that is agonizing require to die. In another way it will be best if active euthanasia and passive euthanasia were legal because it will be better for a terminally ill patient to have a better option of dying. He is the one who will decide how to dies doctor only need to provide information and counseling if needed Either both options been assisted by a physician or not been assisted by physician are different ways of facing
Show More

Related Documents: Is Passive Euthanasia Morally Wrong

Active Euthanasia Argumentative Analysis

According to the BBC’s guide of Ethics, active euthanasia is when a medical professional purposely does something to cause the death of their patient. Passive euthanasia occurs when the patient dies due to the medical professional choosing not to continue doing things necessary to keep the patient alive. Some examples of this include turning off life-support, disconnecting a feeding tube or not distributing life-extending drugs. There is an argument about whether there is a moral difference between…

Words 1416 - Pages 6

Ethical Arguments Against Euthanasia

Ethics & Euthanasia Introduction The Hippocratic Oath states that no doctor of medicine will give deadly medicine to any on if asked, nor suggest any such counsel, this is part of their moral and ethical obligations as trusted medical professional, and is a standard measure of care. Euthanasia in Greek means easy death, and is the act of painlessly killing a patient suffering from an incurable and painful disease or in an irreversible coma. Therefor that reason is why Euthanasia is not an acceptable…

Words 1377 - Pages 6

Voluntary Euthanasia Essay

Euthanasia, whether in a medical setting (hospital, clinic, hospice) or not (at home) is often erroneously described as "mercy killing". Most forms of euthanasia are, indeed, motivated by (some say: misplaced) mercy. Not so others. In Greek, "eu" means both "well" and "easy" and "Thanatos" is death. Euthanasia is the intentional premature termination of another person's life either by direct intervention (active euthanasia) or by withholding life-prolonging measures and resources (passive euthanasia)…

Words 365 - Pages 2

study guidetest 3 Essay

alteration of sperm and eggs, or early products of conception, such that the changes become permanently encoded in the sex cells of the resulting adult. ● Positive gene therapy ● Negative gene therapy ● euthanasia ● active euthanasia ● passive euthanasia ● voluntary euthanasia ● involuntary euthanasia ● physician-assisted suicide- that isn’t itself a bad or impermissible result to aim ● Triage- Emergency triage foreseeably leading to the deaths of the untreated. ● Eugenics-enhancement -- altering genes…

Words 2492 - Pages 10

Euthanasia Moral Dilemmas Essay

ENG 102 Miles 5 December 2013 Euthanasia Moral dilemmas are always conflicting choices in everyone’s life. The constant struggle between what is right and what is wrong will probably never end when it comes to legal matters. What one topic of moral/legal righteousness is, would be Euthanasia, or assisted suicide. Not just assisted suicide, but doctor assisted suicide, or mercy killing as some like to call it for a darker point. There are types of Euthanasia, the opposing view to which it is…

Words 1611 - Pages 7

The American Medical Association Essay

The American Medical Association holds that active euthanasia is impermissible, due to it involving the intentional termination of a human life by another human. Philosophers have argued for and against this stance, discussing the moral permissibility of such an action. James Rachels, a well-known contemporary philosopher, argues that active and passive euthanasia both require an action by the doctor. Thomas D. Sullivan combats Rachels’ view by looking into the moral significance of the intention…

Words 3857 - Pages 16

Essay on 28 Euthanasia III

Medical Ethics Handout 27 Euthanasia III Recall: Active Euthanasia – performing an action that directly causes someone to die. Passive Euthanasia – allowing someone to die by not doing something that would prolong life. The Difference Thesis – All else being equal, killing someone is morally worse than letting them die. Rachels grants that there is a genuine difference between acts of killing and acts of allowing to die, but does not think that there is an essential moral difference between the…

Words 1156 - Pages 5

Suffer No More Essay

More Dying is one of the most important events in a human’s life. The Euthanasia process does not necessarily acknowledge a right to die, but an easier way. The term comes from the Greek expression for “good death.” Euthanasia is the termination of very sick people’s lives in order to relieve them of their suffering. There are two types of Euthanasia, active and passive. Active Euthanasia is death by commission. Passive Euthanasia is death by omission. If people would put aside the idea that death…

Words 1755 - Pages 8

Physician Assisted Suicide Arguments Against Euthanasia

raises questions with defining the meaning of death and how it compares with the life. With euthanasia and physician assisted suicide morality issues arise tangled with legal and policy debates. All terms used to describe killing and dying are often controversial. However according to some, while death is considered to be bad or evil, euthanasia is considered to be good. Nevertheless suicide and euthanasia is not consistent with any medical practice and contradicts physician's oath to provide care…

Words 1171 - Pages 5

Final Essay

(Aristotle P24) Soul, which is a being that takes in nutrients and can grow, a Sensate Soul, which is a soul that can “[experience] sensations” (Aristotle P 25) such as touch, and the last soul is the “Rational” soul, one that is “either active or passive: passive in so far as it follows the dictates of reason, active in so far as it possesses and exercises the power of reasoning” (Aristotle P 25). When it comes to the issue of abortion, the fetus, at any stage of pregnancy has at least a “Vegetable” soul…

Words 2246 - Pages 9