I would bring for supplies edible fruit and food for the voyage; and also enough to last until we begin to hunt and farm as well as discover what food plants are near us. I would bring as much seed as I could buy for farming. I would bring cooking pots of the day for the cook, which I believe were then cauldrons and skillets. I would bring textiles to be sewn into clothing. I would bring grain and flour, the flour mainly to bake bread. I would bring a Bible to be read when somebody wanted to hear it.
For location, I would have chosen a "middle state", for it's moderate climate. The states known as middle states are New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Virginia. They are neither New England states, which are too cold, nor southern states, which are hot enough to make some people suffer.
For growth, I would have us all build one big building that could house us all, if need be.