Maggie’s presentation about detective stories allowed me to appreciate the extent of how surprising the motive and realization of the crimes are in “Death and the Compass” despite Borges’ adhesion to hallmark elements of the genre. While still honoring the murder mystery writers before him with allusions, Borges criticizes the overly analytical detective for his strict interpretations of minor details. Lonnrot, foiling the “dim-witted police” commissioner, meets his