Essay on Killer Genetics

Submitted By tinawazen
Words: 2052
Pages: 9
Open Document
The Killer Genetics: Inherently Criminal or Socially Declared
Kristina Wazen

Thursday, March 27, 2014
100924208
SOCI 1002D
TA: Rhys Williams
Professor: Tamy Superle
“We must not say that an action shocks the conscience collective because it is criminal, but rather it is criminal because it shocks the conscience collective. We do not condemn it because it is a crime, but it is a crime because we condemn it” (Durkheim, 1972: 123-4)
Throughout the years, professionals from many fields such as criminology, sociology, psychology etc., have attempted to understand criminality, criminal behavior and deviance in different ways. Questions have always come up but the most thought of and controversial question is whether or not criminal behavior is genetic or environemtal and what are the dangers that come along with suggesting that criminal behavior is biological.
Crime is not biologically inherent nor does it have biological characteristics but is a product of society therefore leaving crime with no essence, accept one which is social. The behaviors leading up to a crime may have biological and psychological aspects surrounding it but criminals are not born, they are a product of their environment. The dangers of suggesting that biological characteristics can help explain crime is one of much controversy.
In the sixteenth century attempts to understand criminals as well as criminal behavior began with an Italian physician, Giambattista della Porta who was infatuated with the understanding of human physiognomy (facial features). Della Porta argued that “thieves tended to have sharp vision and large lips.”1 His theory and research was later carried on by a man named Cesare Lombroso. Lombroso assumed that “being criminal was somehow to be explained through identifying particular characteristics of individuals.”2 His view on a criminal was that they were a separate species and showed different mental and physical traits than other human beings. These characteristics included things such as the asymmetry of the face, lip size, particularities of the palate, imbalance of the hemispheres of the brain, and much more. His thought process was that “criminals were born, not made.”3 Unfortunately, Lombroso’s theory that criminals have different characteristics would allow for discrimination in today’s society towards races with such features. For example, a common trait found in African Americans and people of color are larger lips. According to Lombroso’s theory, if an individual were to have larger lips, than they would automatically be deemed a criminal.4This in turn allows for the idea of ethnocentrism to flourish. Ethnocentrism is “the tendency to regard one’s own culture and group as the standard – and thus superior- whereas all other groups are inferior.” 5 Being that only specific races share the characteristics or features discussed in Lombroso’s theory, other individuals of races that do not share these characteristics will find themselves superior to others because they are not considered to be criminals.
According to an interview with CBC news titled “Killer Genetic: Investigating Adam Lanza’s DNA”, well renowned geneticist Robert Green discussed the potential harmful outcomes that may occur when suggesting that criminals have a so called “mutant” gene. As stated in the interview, Robert Green suggested that testing for a so called “mutant” gene to explain why people commit crime can potentially send the wrong message to the public.6 It has the potential to allow for stigmatization of the individual diagnosed with what would be called, “the killer gene.” 7 The label or stigma attached to the idea that an individual has a mutation in their genetic makeup, allowing for a higher risk of committing horrific crime will no doubt have a negative aspect to it, similar to the stigmatization of an individual with schizophrenia. According to labeling and stigmatization theories, people will
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Killer Genetics

John Wayne Gacy Research Paper

Gacy, one of the most prolific serial killers in America, who killed an estimated 33 men and boys, was known for having a very abusive father and an awful childhood. Many speculate that his childhood could have influenced these murders and the way he killed his victims. Serial killers are influenced by both traumatic experiences and also genetic factors: childhood trauma and events can cause a child to seek relief through activities of violence, many serial killers use childhood events that impact their…

Words 940 - Pages 4

Essay on The Ruthless

the cold blooded, psychopathic, serial killers that surround us in this world. And as of October 19, 2013, Florida has the second most amount of victims, following California, from serial killers (FGCU Serial Killer Database). All the way from “Jack the Ripper” to Ted Bundy, everyone struggles with the question why? What made these monstrous individuals do the things they did to their victims? Researchers have found that due to a lethal combination of genetics, a difficult home life, and sometimes…

Words 1153 - Pages 5

Brain Dysfunction Essay

to violence. I do maintain my position that even if the same Neurological and genetic factors that lead to crime are present in a person the lack of a healthy environment is what will cause those neurological and genetic factors to manifest themselves into crime or violence. The video also discusses the region of the human brain that can be linked to crime/evil. I do believe now that people can be born with genetic factors that…

Words 894 - Pages 4

Genetic Neural Sonar

The Genetic Neural Sonar was created by neuroscientists at the University of Maryland to map inherited gene based abnormalities in brain structure and chemistry. The proposed GNS can determine if an individual brain has the kind of abnormal genetic structures that scientists, such as Dr. Starkweather, believe are responsible for predisposing people to commit violent crime. The scientists believe that those who possess this type of brain structure may have a significantly greater chance of one day…

Words 501 - Pages 3

Nature Vs. Nurture In Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

Nature versus Nurture, genetics versus environment. In the book, “In Cold Blood,” it is seen everywhere. Between the killers, Perry Smith and Richard Hickock, Nancy and Kenyon Clutter, and even, Herbert Clutter. It is even seen in everyday life, with twins being put up for adoption and separated at birth. They have the same genetics but different environments that they grow up in. In the book, “In Cold Blood,” by Truman Capote, the debate between Nature vs. Nurture is seen with the murderers, Perry…

Words 569 - Pages 3

Differences Between Serial And Psychopathic Killers

The argument between whether or not a serial or psychopathic killer is born or made has been around for quite some time. It’s still hard to determine, but killers are often made through nurture. Murderers have been around for as long as humankind can remember. With a lot of research being done on this subject, it is clear to us that killers often have some brain differences between someone who is considered normal. Killers are often made through nurture due to traumatic experiences, however,…

Words 701 - Pages 3

Ted Bundy's Philosocial Theory

Ted Bundy was a product of his environment, family, mental state, biology, and unknown genetics. When Ted Bundy found out his entire life was a lie, it caused a negative impact on his mental state. From a smart athletic boy, Ted Bundy turned into an antisocial psychopathic rapist killer who felt as if he was an alien among humans. Unable to feel what others felt, he took theater classes in order to further manipulate people into his twisted games where the other player became a victim of assault…

Words 290 - Pages 2

Psychopaths: A Case Study

Both the serial killers’ genes and environment that encompasses them modify one another to create a response unique to that individual, making it difficult to pinpoint a dominant variable that causes the murderous behavior. Generally speaking, the same stimulus will not…

Words 1233 - Pages 5

Biology EOC Study Outlines Essay

Biology EOC Study Session 1 SC.912.L.14.52, SC.912.L.18.1, SC.912.L.16.1, SC.912.L.15.8 The Immune System, Macromolecules, Introduction to Genetics, The Origin of Life SC.912.L.14.52 ­ The Immune System Explain the basic function of the human immune systems, including specific and nonspecific immune response, vaccines, and antibiotics. Edgenuity notes: ● Illnesses can be caused by several factors including being exposed to viruses and bacteria. ● There are three components of the immune system: physical barriers…

Words 1262 - Pages 6

Genetic Modification of Food Essay

Genetic modification is the process of changing an organism’s genes to alter its characteristics. The aim is to add a trait that is not already found in that organism. Some enzymes can cut a useful gene from one organism’s chromosome and cut another organism’s chromosome to insert the gene. All organisms use the same language of DNA, so a gene from a human can be removed and placed in a different organism and it will still carry out its function. Using genetic modification to treat illnesses,…

Words 581 - Pages 3