The jury is deciding if the captain of a sinking submarine was justified to kill several members of his crew in order to save the lives of five others. The murder in this story was commited by poisoning multiple glasses of whiskey except for six saved for the married men of the crew and Captain Oram. Similar to Lamb to the Slaughter, the murder is described in a single scentence with not a great amount of detail. This crime was commited out of sacrifice for the ship only had enough air to save five men. Captain Oram decided to save the men with families, ultimately killing himself as well. This is the immense decision that Captain Oram had to make: Die as one or save a few? There is no right answer to this question, as it depends on an individual’s judgment and morals. However, this is the important decision that Oram took it upon himself to