law commission Essay

Submitted By jasminemann48
Words: 1367
Pages: 6
Open Document
The role of the law commission
The Law Commission was set up in 1965 by the Law Commisson Act. Under S3 (1) of the Law Commission Act its job is to keep the law under review. It is the only independant, full-time and government funded body to perform this job. Five commissioners sit on the Law Commission. One is a chairman who is usually a high court judge and the other four are legal experts such as a solicitor. Each commisioner has their own support staff and parliamentary draftsmen. The Law Commission either picks an area of law and then seeks government approval or the goverment can refer them to an area of law such as Criminal Law. They research the area in detail and then issue a consulation paper which includes the current law, the problems with it and the possible options for reform. This allows for interested parties and the public to give feedback and express their ideas. After the response, the Law Commission issue a final report which includes the firm proposals of law reform. They usually attach a draft bill along with the final report in order to show Parliament how exactly the law should be made. If to become law it goes through the Parliamentary law-making process. Examples of a law that was made due to the Law Commission is the Bribery Act and the Law Reform (Year and a day rule). The Law Commission also plays a role in codifying and consolidating the law. They bring together all the law under one topic into one act and all the statutory provisions relating to one area under one act. The Sales of Goods Act is an example of a law codified by the Law Commission. The Law Commision also simplify and modernise the Law. For example the Fraud Act 2006 was simplified. The Law Commission also identify obsolete laws that are no longer used and bring them to Parliaments atttention so Parliament can repeal those acts.
Advantages and disadvantages
One advantage is that the Law Commission is made up of legal experts and is headed by a high court judge which means that Laws are more thorough, well informed and contain less mistakes. It also means that the draft bill they produce is perfect and less unambigious which helps to reduce workload for ministers. Furthermore legal experts aren't victims of the Whips system that is used in Parliament which results in less bias. To add to this, commissioners are changed every 5 years which allows for a range of different viewpoints to be brought onto the law-reform process. On the other hand, Parliament doesn't consult the Law Commission when making laws therefore laws are made without the expertise of the Law Commission. In addition to this, the Law Commission deals with 20-30 investigations at a time which may mean that one investigation interrupts another resulting in less thoroughness and more mistakes made. Furthermore Parliament may re-word the drafts bill which could result in an unambiguous bill and could even change the law making it totally different from what the Law Commission suggested which means their research and knowledge may no longer apply.
Another advantage is that the Law Commission consults interested parties and the public and takes objections into consideration which means that laws are being made for the protection and benefit of the public, rather than the benefit of political parties which decreases biasness. Parliament also benefits from this as it means that they are less likely to get voted out at the next general election. However Parliament is not obliged to enforce Law Commission laws therefore they may not enforce a law if it doesn't suit their political agenda regardless of the fact that it consults. This means that the Law Commission have a lack in power and cannot stop biased decisions from being made. Furthermore the Law Commission have to wait for Parliament to accept their proposals which usually takes a long time due to Parliament having limited time for 'pure' law reform and the lengthy parliamentary law-making process. An example of this
Show More

Related Documents: law commission Essay

Electronic Commerce: Formal Requirements in Commercial Transactions Advice from the Law Commission Essay

Law Commission ELECTRONIC COMMERCE: FORMAL REQUIREMENTS IN COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS ADVICE FROM THE LAW COMMISSION December 2001 The Law Commission was set up by the Law Commissions Act 1965 for the purpose of promoting the reform of the law. The Law Commissioners are: The Honourable Mr Justice Carnwath CVO, Chairman Professor Hugh Beale Mr Stuart Bridge Professor Martin Partington Judge Alan Wilkie, QC The Secretary of the Law Commission is Mr Michael Sayers and its offices are at Conquest…

Words 16921 - Pages 68

Marbury Vs Madison Case Brief Summary

Adams hurried to appoint several commissions, some of which were the justices of the peace for the District of Columbia. He rushed because he felt as if Thomas Jefferson would not appoint any Federalists and would instead appoint his own party, the Democratic Republicans. To prevent this, Adams appointed several “midnight judges”. These “last minute” judges were 16 circuit judges and 42 justices of the peace, one of them being William Marbury. These commissions were signed by President Adams and…

Words 876 - Pages 4

Marbury Vs Madison Case Brief Essay

Marbury was able to receive his official commission, Thomas Jefferson entered office and ordered the Secretary of State, James Madison not to deliver the recent commissions of the previous government to the new appointees. Marbury therefore filed a petition to the Supreme Court to order Madison deliver his commission by writ of mandamus, as the appointment was rightfully and legally his as “when the seal is affixed, the appointment is made, and the commission is valid”. The case, presided by Chief…

Words 549 - Pages 3

Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire Essay

as new laws, new groups, and better working conditions. In New York, a state legislative commission was formed to study the fire and safety of factories. New laws demanded that the bosses of factories must ensure safety of others in and out of the building. Employer groups denounced the new labor code as unfair, impractical and costly, and charged that it would force employers to move to states where the laws were less difficult. Some women have reported to work 20…

Words 507 - Pages 3

Marbury V. Madison: The Most Important Cases In The United States

of State stepped off, they had forgotten the commission in a desk at the office. On the 4th of March, 1801 Thomas Jefferson stepped in the office as the new President of the United States, he ordered the new administrations’ Attorney General and acting Secretary of State to not deliver any appointments, until James Madison, the new Secretary of State had taken his seat. The plaintiff, Marbury held Madison responsible for not delivering the commission, Marburys’ main argument he presented to the US…

Words 926 - Pages 4

Employment Laws Essays

Employment Laws and Compliance To: Tracy Goldman From: XXXXXXX Date: August 10, 2014 Subject: Employment Laws and Compliance I have compiled an employment compliance plan for Bradley Stonefield for the future opening of Landslide Limos. Based on the information Mr. Stonefield has provided here are the major employment laws that will apply to his business. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title I and V of the American Disabilities Act, The Equal Pay Act of 1963 and The Immigration…

Words 707 - Pages 3

European Parliament Essays

sets out explicit competencies of the Union and detailed procedures to be used in each policy field. Art 13(1) TEU- EU Institutions 7 institutions recognized: European Parliament, European Council (added with the ToL) Council European Commission Court of Justice of the European Union European Central Bank (added with the ToL) Court of Auditors. Each institution “…shall act within the limits of powers conferred on it by the Treaties”. Art 13(2) TEU provides that “the Union…

Words 2069 - Pages 9

Essay on Sexual Harrasment

discrimination and harassment A guide to making and responding to a complaint under the Human Rights Act 1993 [pic] October 2010 Contents 1. Introduction 2 The Human Rights Commission 2 2. Understanding discrimination and harassment 3 What is unlawful discrimination? 3 What is indirect discrimination? 4 What are the prohibited grounds covered by the Human Rights Act? 4 What is sexual…

Words 5705 - Pages 23

Essay about EU decision making

Decision making process in the European Union: The EU in brief: At the heart of the decision making process are the EU Institutions, such as: the Parliament, the Council and the European Commission. Sovereignty Delegation (pooling): Member states delegate some of their decision-making powers to the shared institutions they have created, so decisions on specific matters of joint interest can be made democratically at European level. Created in 1950  built single market of goods and…

Words 3874 - Pages 16

Essay on Law and Marbury

to deliver the commissions involving John Adams appointees to the Supreme Court. On President John Adams last day in office he made a series off appointees to the Supreme Court, but it was never delivered by John Marshall, John Adam’s Secretary of State. Marbury believed that the commissions should be delivered by the new Secretary of State James Madison and applied directly to the Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus, which Marbury hoped would force Madison to deliver the commissions. 3. –Has…

Words 338 - Pages 2