Essay on LE Case

Submitted By bolangb
Words: 802
Pages: 4
Open Document
LE Case Costco Wholesale Corp. v. Omega, S.A. (08-1423)
By
Bolang Chen

1. The facts of the case:

Omega is a famous watch manufacturer company in the world. All of Omega watches are produced in Switzerland. Omega sells its products to all of the world through authorized wholesalers and retailers. Each of the Omega watches is engraved with the words "Omega Globe Design” on the back of it. And it means the copyright law in America protects the watch. Costco is a well-known wholesale warehouse store. They purchased Omega watches through an unknown third party company in the New York, and sold these watches in the United States, and the watches price was cheaper than many other American distributor's price. Many years ago, Omega gave Costco the authorization to sell the watches in the foreign market, but they did not give them a mandate for sale in the United States. So, Omega sued Costco to the US District Court for the Central District of California. Omega thought that Costco's behavior has constituted infringement. Although they authorized Costco to sell watches in foreign countries, they did not authorize them to sell in the United States. But Costco said that, according to the 109 (a), called the first sale doctrine. Because Omega allowed Costco to sell them products the first time, they cannot limit Costco to make importation, sales and other acts, which means that Omega has no right to stop Costco from selling their watch. The US District Court for the Central District of California ruled in favor of Costco without explanation

Omega appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. The Court’s final ruling claimed that Omega won. First, the judge considered this case did not apply to the law 109 (a) because Omega is a foreign company that produces goods into the United States, but is not "lawfully made.” Costco then appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States. Finally, The Supreme Court maintained the Ninth Circuit Court's decision and Costco’s violation of the United States’ copyright law on December 13 in 2010.

2. There are several problems in the court judgment process: (1). Most importantly, before this case, there was a similar case called the Quality King case. Can this case be applied to one decision? (2) .Can the bill of 109 (a) called the first sale doctrine be considered legitimate to Costco’s behavior? (3). Is this a reasonable judgment on this case, only relying on the 109 (a) bill?

3 Why did the Circuit Court and the Supreme Court make this decision? First, The District Court for the Central District of California made a judgment only in 109 (a) of the Act, but because 109 (a) Act generally restricts section 106 (3) and 602 (a) Act, and Omega thought the lawsuit was based on these two bills, the circuit court dismissed the original cases. Second, the circuit court referred to a similar case: Quality King. Although Quality King’s case does conform to the 109 (a) Act, they also purchased from third-party markets and sold it in the United States. But the goods
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on LE Case

Essay on Le Case Study

motivational system in its U.S. facilities: Piece rate pay: Factory employees are paid entirely by piece rate, meaning they receive a set amount of money per unit of work they produce. There is no hourly wage or salary that provides a safety net in case they miss work or do not perform well. Produce a lot of highquality units and you can make a lot of money at Lincoln Electric; perform poorly and you receive very little pay at all. One of the disadvantages of piece rate pay is the tendency for employees…

Words 1810 - Pages 8

Aquinas's Second Way

of the five ways. In his book Arguing for Atheism, Robin Le Poidevin contests the second way, or as he calls it, the cosmological argument. Le Poidevin reconstructs the argument, in its most basic form, as such: “Anything that exists has a cause of its existence Nothing can be the cause of its own existence The universe exists Therefore: The universe has a cause of its existence which lies outside the universe.” From this reconstruction, Le Poidevin argues that the first two premises demonstrate…

Words 1095 - Pages 5

Lincoln Electrics Essay

expand into India by investing in a major production facility there? I think that Lincoln Electric (LE) should definitely has a production facility in India because of its growth and foreseen opportunities, but if I were LE I would suggest to enter with a local partner in order to gain knowledge and experience in how the country operates in terms of bureaucracy, labor, culture and so on. LE is known for its high quality products and its technical innovations. On its 60 years of international…

Words 1173 - Pages 5

Le roman pistolaire caract rise ses personnages par leur maniement du langage Essay example

“Le roman épistolaire caractérise ses personnages par leur maniement du langage, par ce qu'ils en attendent et par la façon dont ils se laissent entraîner par les mots.” Discuss with reference to Les Liaisons Dangereuses. The epistolary novel was seen, up until Laclos’ Les Liaisons Dangereuses, as a mainly mono-vocal form of literature. The epistolary novel allowed the reader to imagine the events being described, and, in some cases, the replies of other (unheard) characters in the narrative. However…

Words 2388 - Pages 10

Bryan Polak Essay

Arlen, there is a confusion at hand between whether or not the main character, Billy, killed another character Le Bin Son. Throughout the song Robin and Arlen make very difficult to understand whether or not Billy kills Le Bin Son. The writers use gloomy imagery to convince the reader that Billy will kill Le Bin Son. However, Robin and Arlen have convinced me that Billy has not kill Le Bin Son, he instead chose to pick his morals over another person’s past decisions. The writers convincing came from…

Words 801 - Pages 4

The Mists Of Avalon Character Analysis

Such is the case for Morgan le Fay, an Arthurian sorceress widely recognized for her exploitation of King Arthur and others through temptation and witchcraft. Although the foundational elements of Morgan's character stay consistent through time, the traits that make Morgan le Fay unique in each depiction differ from those of other versions. After analysis of the Middle Ages’ Le Morte D’Arthur and 1983 novel The Mists of Avalon, it becomes evident that differences between Morgan le Fay's character…

Words 562 - Pages 3

Medieval Women

modern society, this comes across as an almost trick question, there is no correct answer that all would agree on. Yet, this does not mean that this has always been the case or, that expectations of women have not changed over time. In fact, the exact opposite is true with the feminine role being vastly different and in many cases broader in the modern era than seen in the past. Europe in the medieval period, is no exception to this, while it is very general to say all people in the Middle Ages thought…

Words 1078 - Pages 5

Write A Rhetorical Analysis Of Why I Write By George Orwell

writes because of at least one of the four motives. Out of many examples that come to mind, a notable work of literature that exemplifies the use of such motives mentioned by the acclaimed Orwell would be “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” by Ursula Le Guin. Written in 1973, the fictional, seemingly plotless short story depicts to readers the what appears to be perfect utopian city of Omelas. Once a reader delves into the essay he or she can apply Orwell’s universal motives to…

Words 1140 - Pages 5

Drugs in LES Essay

East Side (LES) is a neighborhood located in the southeastern part of Manhattan in New York City. The boundaries surrounding lower east side to the west is Bowery Street, to the east is the East River, to the north is East Houston Street, and to the south is Canal Street. The LES used to an immigrant working class neighborhood. It went through major transformation in the mid 2000s and is now home to trendy restaurants and bars. Being part of the oldest neighborhoods of the city, the LES is ethnically…

Words 1516 - Pages 7

Post Negotiation Analysis Les Florets Essay

Post negotiation Analysis of Les Florets Case This case particularly resonates with me because it highlights the problems that arise when two individuals have reference points which do not overlap. An impasse was reached between myself (VP of operations for Les Florets) and the Restaurant owner and this was primarily due to the fact that we both had reference points with a ceiling which we felt we could not exceed. Going into this negotiation as the VP of operations my goal was to primarily…

Words 958 - Pages 4