Left-Brain/Right-Brain Essays

Submitted By jerryjohnson266
Words: 2115
Pages: 9
Open Document
Differences Between the Left and Right Brain

Left, right, left, right--the marching song of the two-mind movement. To hear them talk, you'd think that everyone had a second mind, suppressed by the first. That the vocal left brain dominated the poor artistic right brain. Preventing it from getting a creative thought in edgewise. Soon there will be a consciousness raising movement: Stop referring to the left cerebral hemisphere as the "dominant" one. Invent a more egalitarian term like co-chairperson. Co-chairhemisphere?

Alas. Were cerebral physiology so simple! If there were strong dominating influences, it would make our research far easier. It is unfortunate that "dominance" is a word with two entirely different meanings, even within psychology. When talking about pecking order, dominant refers to an animal that usually wins in a one-on-one encounter, the animal that can approach, threaten, and successfully displace another animal from food, mates, or the best nesting place. In talking about the cerebral hemispheres, however, dominant is merely a shortening of the technical term "language-dominant hemisphere." It is the outcome of a test to find out where language lives in a person's brain, such as injecting anesthetics into the left and right carotid arteries and seeing when the patient stops talking (or the simpler, but not as accurate, test that merely involves having the subject look at a dot in the middle of a screen and then briefly flashing words to the left or right of the fixation point; people with left-brain language will have an easier time with right-sided words since the information goes first to left brain).

Although a few percent of people have right brains that are language-dominant, about 93 percent of us use the left side. A few percent have "mixed dominance," where both sides are used for language (that is, injecting anesthetics on either side will interfere with speech). But the term hardly refers to language dominating art or music: it's just which side is more essential for language than the other.

Shades of gray become black and white when the dichotomizers go into action. But the real problem is that most of the creativity arguments have about as much to do with the brain as does the English language. The structure of the brain probably has a lot to do with the capability for, even the "deep structure" of, language--but brains hardly come in Chinese, Swahili, and English flavors. Like English per se, the creativity and holistic thinking influences probably lie more in the realm of culture than brain structure. And hardly on a particular side of the brain.

A few decades ago, similar suppressed-creativity arguments were floating around. It's just that they were then phrased in terms of contemplative Eastern thought versus authoritarian Western religious influences. More recently, the dichotomous rendition was holistic versus linear thinking. And now the mod metaphor is right brain versus left brain. Except that it is the worst of mixed metaphors, the kind that mixes up metaphor with reality.

Being a neurophysiologist, I suppose I ought to feel that progress has been made: in no other age could it have taken a mere twenty years to shift from a predominantly religious metaphor to a semi-scientific one. But the neurophysiologists and neuropsychologists who specialize in the human cerebral cortex are starting to view the left-righters with something of the wariness which the astronomers reserve for astrology.

In one sense, the picture of the mind painted by the left-righters is rather like one of those magazine illustrations of the human brain and its convoluted surface--one feels quite sure that the artist has never seen a real human brain, either a fresh one or a preserved one. The result of embroidering upon another artist's rendition bears even less fidelity to the original, an artistic version of the spread of a rumor. My favorite painting of the brain's convoluted surface is not
Show More

Related Documents: Left-Brain/Right-Brain Essays

Left Brain vs Right Brain Research Paper

Left brain VS Right brain Matthew Stafford Davenport University 10/25/2012 Right Brain Your brain processes and reacts to certain situations in many different ways. This is directly due to either being left brain or right brain. What is left brain or right brain you ask? People use either side to approach solutions to a variety of problems with different outcomes. People who are left brain tend to approach each problem with an analytical point of view. Right brain thinkers tend to…

Words 962 - Pages 4

Lateralization of Brain Function and Right Brain Essay

(1) Right Brain Rising, (2) Abundance, Asia, and Automation (3) High Concept, High Touch. The second part of this phenomenal book is entitled “The Six Senses,” which is explained by design, story, symphony, empathy, play, and meaning respectively. A Whole New Mind explains two approaches to thinking, and clarifies why one is superior to the other particularly in contemporary times. The following paragraphs in this book review will summarily describes Pinks' notion of a left and right brain, and…

Words 1146 - Pages 5

Brain Hempispheres Essay

The Brain by Hemispheres The brain is the most important component of the nervous system and is by far one of the most complex and fascinating of all organs in the human body. In the last decade, cognition that the left and right hemispheres of the brain exhibit different mental patterns has garnered public attention and resulted in many theories and studies. Different studies and experimentations into these ideas have shown that the two hemispheres of the brain are responsible for different…

Words 1097 - Pages 5

Does The Brain Affect The Right Brain?

not allowed to write with their left hands? if they did they were forced by teachers and parents to use their right hand, they were even spanked and/or hit with rulers. They say that if you were left handed, it was considered “an unconscious revolt against authority” There is also found “The Prevention and Correction of Left-Handedness in Children by J.W. Conway was published in 1935 and we believe also had the subtitle “On Curing the Disability and Disease of Left-Handedness” (Quora). For years there…

Words 661 - Pages 3

split brain studies Essay

Our brain is made up of two hemispheres, the right and the left. In between the halves is the corpus callosum, a thick band of about 200-250 million nerve fibres that allows the cerebral hemispheres to communicate. In the 1960's a certain type of severe epilepsy was only cured by a major surgery that cut this connection, and in doing so stopped the excess signalling from nerve cells spreading to the opposite hemisphere of the brain. This made it possible for the patients who had previously lived…

Words 744 - Pages 3

Chapter 2 Hemispherecity And Handedness Essay

Divided Brain/ Hemisphericity Website Update  Added a great review resource Some neuroscience humor  What did the neuron say to the glial cell?   What did the stimulus do to the neuron after they got married?   Carried it over the threshold If some of Fred Flintstone's neurotransmitters could talk, what would they say?   “Thanks for the support!” GABA-daba-doo! What did the hippocampus say during its retirement speech?  Thanks for all the memories! Our Divided Brain  The…

Words 416 - Pages 2

Ms C0Wgirl Essay

1. How do two halves of the brain operate independently? The theory of the structure and functions of the mind suggests that the two different sides of the brain control two different “modes” of thinking. The left and right hemispheres of our brain process information in different ways. We tend to follow our dominant side and start inculcating characteristics and areas of interest, typical of that side. Each individual perceives, conceives and processes information in a distinct fashion. But if…

Words 683 - Pages 3

Reticular Formation

There were three main parts of the brain: the forebrain, midbrain, and hindbrain. this was talked about in chapter 2, Mastering the World of Psychology. One of those parts is called, Hindbrain, which is the lowest part of the brain. Inside the Hindbrain it has Medulla Oblongata, Cerebellum, Pons, and the Base of Reticular Formation. The Medulla Oblongata controls the breathing, digestion, heartbeats, swallowing and coughing but scientists also say that we would not be able to live without a Medulla…

Words 617 - Pages 3

Lefties Being Smarter

you guessed right), they're all south paws or left-handers. 1 out of every 10 persons of the world's population is left-handed. That gives rise to a number of myths and one which has particularly raised dust for over a century is the myth that lefties are smarter. Most of us at some point would have come across the myth of lefties being smarter, more intelligent or having higher IQ's than their right handed counterparts. ... the logic behind the myth It is believed that the right side of the…

Words 714 - Pages 3

Talk To Baby Language Development

and in childhood, early stimulation is essential for future language and vocabulary success. All babies are born with a brain ready to learn communication of some form. If language is not introduced at birth, the brain does not naturally pick up or learn what it has to do to communicate. Babies need to be exposed to language in the critical period of life or else their brain cannot connect correctly. Here are some suggestions for what parents can do to promote and enrich this essential skill:…

Words 600 - Pages 3