Legal Battle Over Superman Essay

Submitted By timpanzee123
Words: 961
Pages: 4
Open Document
Legal Battle over Superman
As part of the deal which saw Superman published in Action Comics, Siegel and Shuster sold the rights to the company in return for $130 and a contract to supply the publisher with material. The Saturday Evening Post reported in 1940 that the pair was each being paid $75,000 a year, a fraction of National Comics Publications' millions in Superman profits. Siegel and Shuster renegotiated their deal, but bad blood lingered and in 1947 Siegel and Shuster sued for their 1938 contract to be made void and the re-establishment of their ownership of the intellectual property rights to Superman. The pair also sued National in the same year over the rights to Superboy, which they claimed was a separate creation that National had published without authorization. National immediately fired them and took their byline off the stories, prompting a legal battle that ended in 1948, when a New York court ruled that the 1938 contract should be upheld. However, a ruling from Justice J. Addison Young awarded Siegel the rights to Superboy. A month after the Superboy judgment the two sides agreed on a settlement. National paid Siegel and Shuster $94,000 to drop all claims. The pair also acknowledged in writing the company's ownership of Superman, attesting that they held rights for "all other forms of reproduction and presentation, whether now in existence or that may hereafter be created", but DC refused to re-hire them.

In 1975 after news reports of their pauper-like existences, Warner Communications gave Siegel and Shuster lifetime pensions of $20,000 per year and health care benefits. Jay Emmett, then executive vice president of Warner Bros., was quoted in The New York Times as stating, "There is no legal obligation, but I sure feel there is a moral obligation on our part." Heidi MacDonald, writing for Publishers Weekly, noted that in addition to this pension, "Warner agreed that Siegel and Shuster would henceforth be credited as creators of Superman on all comics, TV shows, and films."In 1973 Siegel and Shuster again launched a suit claiming ownership of Superman, this time basing the claim on the Copyright Act of 1909 which saw copyright granted for 28 years but allowed for a renewal of an extra 28 years. Their argument was that they had granted DC the copyright for only 28 years. The pair again lost this battle, both in a district court ruling of October 18, 1973 and an appeal court ruling of December 5, 1974.
The year after this settlement, 1976, the copyright term was extended again, this time for another 19 years for a total of 75 years. However, this time a clause was inserted into the extension to allow authors to reclaim their work, reflecting the arguments Siegel and Shuster had made in 1973. The new act took effect in 1978 and allowed a reclamation window in a period based on the previous copyright term of 56 years. This meant the copyright on Superman could be reclaimed between 1994 to 1999, based on the initial publication date of 1938. Jerry Siegel having died in January 1996, his wife and daughter filed a copyright termination notice in 1999. Although Joe Shuster died in July 1992, no termination was filed at that time by his estate.
In 1998, the copyright was extended again with the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act. This time the copyright term was extended to 95 years with a further window for reclamation introduced. In January 2004 Mark Peary, nephew and legal heir to Joe Shuster's estate, filed notice of his intent to reclaim Shuster's half of the copyright, the termination effective in 2013. The status of Siegel's share of the copyright is now the subject of a legal battle. Warner Bros. and the Siegels entered into discussions on how to resolve the issues raised by the termination notice, but these discussions were set aside by the Siegels and in October 2004 they filed suit
Show More

Related Documents: Legal Battle Over Superman Essay

Joe Louis Research Paper

Joe Louis Defeats the Nazi Superman Tyler Hawatmeh Xavier University History of American Sport Prof. Olberding 16 April 2024 Joe Louis Defeats the Nazi Superman Setting inside the formative years of the 20th century in US professional sports was a major transition. Therefore, the 1930s proved to be a pivotal decade, marked by the onset of unwanted disturbances in society, politics, and the economy. In these troubled times, a black boxer rose through his game to emerge as one of the most popular…

Words 1436 - Pages 6

Essay on Sat Raw Material

一 、 莎士比亚 William Shakespeare (第一段介绍成就凑字数) English playwright and poet William Shakespeare, who lived in the late 1500s and early 1600s, is regarded as the greatest dramatist in the history of English literature. His plays include historical works such as Richard II, comedies, including As You Like It, and tragedies, such as Hamlet, Othello, and King Lear. He had a profound understanding of human nature and human behavior, and he was able to communicate this knowledge through the wide variety of…

Words 3212 - Pages 13

Essay about Edit 1

Alexandra Posca Romulus Maier Final I’m No Superman A common political culture advocates that all Americans do not think alike, which is only one of the reasons why this country is so diverse. These attitudes define how individuals participate, who or what they vote for, and what political parties they support. Because of familial and social experiences, I am primarily an apathetic/disinterested party when it comes to politics, however, keys events such as 9/11, Roe vs. Wade and ISIS do engage me…

Words 3536 - Pages 15

Cold War Research Paper

Hist 211 – History of the Cold War Dr. Mckercher From World War to Cold War A new Cold War? Pro Eastern and Western Ukraine  sanctions against Russia by Western World Conflicts in North Korea and Afghanistan Mostly just conflicts from the Cold War that occurred Cold War Stuggle between 2 superpowers  US and USSR (destined to collide with each other) Bi-polar  describe two competing powers  dozens of small wars (other countries fighting) Cold (not a shooting war)  “peace impossible, war…

Words 7524 - Pages 31