Legal: Police and Criminal Investigation Process Essay

Submitted By jessicacragg
Words: 1570
Pages: 7
Open Document
Assess the extent to which the criminal investigation process balances the rights of victims, offenders and society
The criminal investigation process balances the rights of victims, offenders and society to a reasonable extent. The process itself includes the power of police, gathering evidence, use of technology, detention and bail. A criteria of protecting individual rights, justice and meeting society’s needs will be addressed.
Police powers are chiefly outlined in the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW) [LEPRA]. Police have power to search people, places or motor vehicles, and seize or take evidence. When police powers are exercised though, the officer must provide evidence that they indeed are a police officer, their name and place of duty and the reason for the exercise of power. The Code of Practice for CRIME (Custody, Rights, Investigation, Management and Evidence) is a set of rules which have been created in order to ensure a balance between protecting people’s rights and liberties and effective law enforcement.
The gathering of evidence is essential to the criminal investigation process. Evidence must be lawfully obtained under the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) and can involve, fingerprints, witness accounts, physical evidence and DNA samples. Care must be taken when obtaining and compiling this evidence though as when not done correctly, it could potentially infringe the rights of the alleged offender. This is evident in the case R v Stafford 1991 where Grahame Stafford was convicted of murdering 12 year old Leanne Holland after a three day murder investigation. Prior private investigations found the evidence obtained by the police was questionable, especially that of the interview, which police conducted in a very basic manner. The tyre marks and blood samples were also found to be very questionable in accuracy and context. Stafford’s conviction was quashed after serving 14 years in prison on the 24th of December 2009. In the ABC report 19.12.12 ‘Stafford lawyer calls for Holland murder inquiry’ Stafford’s lawyer highlights the miscarriage of justice placed upon Stafford after a Queensland police review found Stafford should be retried. No other suspects have been charged with the murder leading to the possibility of an offender still being present within society, causing the rights of society to not be protected. Although the gathering of evidence is generally done to a sufficient level, it is possible for the rights of society and alleged offenders to be infringed upon.
DNA testing is an accurate way of identifying offenders in criminal investigations but can also be seen as an invasion of privacy. Under the Crimes (Forensic Procedures) Act 2000 criminal suspects, volunteers and people convicted of a serious offence can be tested for DNA. Intimate forensic procedures (the taking of blood, saliva or pubic hair) and buccal swabs (scraping the lining of the mouth to obtain saliva and cells) can only be carried out on criminal suspects and serious offenders with informed consent or if authorised by court order. This act provides for the establishment of a DNA database which has proved effective in identifying criminals. Regardless of this there has been a lack of DNA laboratory resources in NSW, leading to a two year backlog as outlined in SMH 2.7.09 ‘DNA lab’s two-year lag hampers NSW forensic investigations’. This can infringe on the rights of both victims and society as the alleged offender could be still free causing the victim anguish and creating a threat to society. In the case R v Boney, police attempted a mass DNA testing program by appealing to the men of Wee Waa to voluntarily submit saliva swab tests after a 93 year old woman was raped and bashed in her home. Stephen Boney was among the 500 men to partake in the testing and due to the immense pressure he felt, confessed to the police ten days later. Apart from its accuracy, DNA testing can also have a mental impact on offenders,
Show More

Related Documents: Legal: Police and Criminal Investigation Process Essay

Criminal Investigation Process

The criminal investigation process is a complicated process of the legal system. This system encases police powers, which allows them to detain suspects, interrogate and to search and seize property with the use of warrants and other legal means. Its aim is to fairly and justly gather evidence while accommodating to the rights of suspects, victims, legal professionals and the society at large. It can be disputed that the criminal investigation process is effective in achieving justice as it conforms…

Words 727 - Pages 3

Powers of police in the criminal process Essay

Discuss the powers of police in the criminal process The criminal investigation process is the investigative stage of the criminal justice system. It is where crimes are detected and investigated, and evidence is gathered so that an alleged n offender may be brought before a court. Police have the right to arrest using reasonable force, search and seizure and to issuing special cautions. There are many arguments for and against these police powers. One power…

Words 647 - Pages 3

The Criminal Investigation Process: Key Legal Terminologies

The Criminal Investigation Process: Key Legal Terminologies * Investigation- for the police, this means carrying out research to discover evidence and examine the facts surrounding and alleged criminal incidents. * Arrest- to seize a person by legal authority and take them into custody. * Interrogate- to formally question a suspect in relation to an alleged crime. * Evidence- information used to support the facts in a legal investigation as testimony in court. * Charge-…

Words 332 - Pages 2

Criminal Justice Process

Criminal justice is a process, involving a series of steps beginning with a criminal investigation and ending with the release of a convicted offender from correctional supervision. Rules and decision making are at the centre of this process. Rules Sources of rules in criminal justice include the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights, state constitutions, the U.S. Code, state codes, court decisions, federal rules of criminal procedure, state rules of criminal procedure, and department and agency rules…

Words 1730 - Pages 7

Exploring The Role Of Discretion In The Criminal Justice System

In the criminal justice system, achieving a balance between the rights of victims, offenders, and society is crucial. This balance is maintained through careful handling of both the investigative and trial processes. Central to these processes are the discretion exercised by law enforcement and the use of legal defences. The fundamental purpose of police powers entails the prevention, detection and investigation of crimes. Police powers aid in protecting society from violent offenders, ensuring…

Words 799 - Pages 4

Essay about Scottish Legal System Report

SCOTTISH LEGAL SYSTEM F1A7 34 11/24/2013 Contents Terms of reference My tutor John Allan has requested a report to be produced, which I will provide him with information on: Duties of the Police, the powers of the police and the role of the police Duties of the Procurator Fiscal, the role of the Procurator Fiscal and the powers of the Procurator fiscal The role of the Lord Advocate The role of the Advocate-Depute Procedure In order to produce this report, there was…

Words 1580 - Pages 7

Wrongful Convictions

Innocent Individuals Get Convicted Some of the reasons for wrongful convictions are discussed as under; 1. Inaccuracy of Eyewitnesses Even though man’s fallibility is our established feature, prosecution process still holds testimonies by eyewitnesses as ne plus ultra in dealing with criminal cases. It has been established that eyewitnesses are likely to misidentify real perpetrators and even misjudge occurrences in a crime scene (Krieger, 2011). Crime scenes are more often than not characterized…

Words 1295 - Pages 6

Rubber Rocks Essay

The Criminal Justice System Jackie Powers University of Phoenix Sara Burnette, J.P. CJS/200 December 6th, 2012 The Criminal Justice System Components of the Criminal Justice System There are three basic components of the criminal justice system, the executive, the legislative and the judicial branches of the government. The Legislature Legislature, both federal and state has the responsibility of defining the crimes and fixing the sentences for crimes…

Words 670 - Pages 3

The Purpose and Function of the Sheriff's Department Essay

Criminal Justice 101 Sheriffs Department The sheriff is an officer of the court, and his primary purpose and function is to serve and execute the various legal processes and mandates issued not only by and for the several courts of the state and its subdivisions, but also for the legal community and the general public. Although the authority of the sheriff varies from state to state, a sheriff or his deputies has the power to make arrests within his or her own jurisdiction. Some states extend…

Words 1163 - Pages 5

Criminal Procedure Essay

Criminal Procedure Policy In the United States criminal justice system the criminal procedure policy is begins when a crime is committed and person is arrested for that crime. This person is now known as the defendant and is protected throughout the criminal procedure policy under the United States Constitution. The United States Constitution ensures fairness and justice to all through the Bill of Rights and other Amendments. Additionally, two procedural models help shape the criminal justice…

Words 632 - Pages 3