Legalization Marijuana Essay

Submitted By elisevert
Words: 3988
Pages: 16
Open Document
1. Differences in political philosophy
I. Federalists: (Democrats)
Believed in the need for a strong central government.
Believed that the central government would protect the citizens in a way that the states couldn’t or wouldn’t.
Thought that this was the only way to create a country rather than just 13 states.
II. Anti-Federalists: (Republicans)
Thought most power must remain with the States.
Feared tyranny like the British Monarchy would result from a strong central government.
Said if they were going to do this- citizens must have guaranteed protections against possibility of tyranny
This is crucial because it becomes the Bill of Rights.
III. Patrick Henry was an Anti-Federalist who wasn’t going to sign without a Bill of Rights. Henry laid out his concerns for the changes in Government at the Virginia Ratifying Convention: 1) the Preamble is ordained by “We the People,” and not “We the States,” 2) the Constitution departs too far from the Articles of Confederation, 3) representation in the House is inadequate, 4) the rights of the people are not properly protected by a bill of rights from “the commands of tyrants” and “disciplined armies,” 5) the amendment process in Article V is flawed since it requires more than a majority to amend, 6) Article I, Section 8 supports a standing army and unlimited taxation, 7) the delegates in Philadelphia exceeded their authority, 8) the people of Virginia are unable to change their form of government, 9) there is “the probability of the President’s enslaving America,” and 10) there is “no true responsibility” in the Constitution, specially since Congress will probably fix the elections.

Alexander Hamilton, however, stated explicitly that a Bill of Rights was not only unnecessary in the proposed constitution, but would even be dangerous — which was a reflection of his antidemocratic attitude.

Overall, the framers of the constitution favored a strong national government. Most of the anti-federalists boycotted the convention, such as Henry, or left in protest, like the New York delegates, besides Hamilton.

2.
I.

II. The founders of the constitution wanted to amendment process to be slow moving on purpose. The wanted to create a government that would have durability, even though they also recognized the need for flexibility. Which is why they created the process above.
III. The 3 major roles the US Supreme Court has played in the amendment process are, 1. Nationalizer of the Bill of Rights, 1925 to present, selective incorporation to the states, 2. Instigator of constitutional amendments, and 3. Interpreter of article V.
IV. There is tension between Congress and the Court due to the interpretation of article V, and who gets the say in what amendments should be passed or not. Sometimes the SC makes decisions that Congress doesn’t like and they can overturn it causing obvious tensions.
V. The court has been hesitant to involve itself in the process because of the tensions it has caused. The Doctrine of Justiciability is one of several criteria that the United States Supreme Court use to make a judgment granting writ of certiorari, which is a writ seeking judicial review.

One example is Coleman v. Miller (1939), which involved the actions of the Kansas legislature over the child labor amendment. In 1924 Congress proposed the amendment, which stated, “The Congress shall have power to limit, refuel, and prohibit the labor of persons under eighteen years of age.” At first the Kansas legislatures rejected the amendment in 1925, however, in 1937 the senate reconsidered it and the legislative body split 20-20, and it went to the court. The court then decided that it was not an appropriate place to settle them, and that the authority of the amendment process ultimately was Congress and not them.

Another more recent article V case is that of NOW v. Idaho (1982). The issue was a 1978 act of Congress that extended the original deadline for state ratification of
Show More

Related Documents: Legalization Marijuana Essay

Legalization Of Marijuana

The Legalization of Cannabis The dawn of the twenty first century has ushered in a new age of optimism and wonder. Despite the proclamations of television, all is not well in our part of the world. Our societies have succumbed to the modern holy war on drugs and more specifically, the war against marijuana. Being fought against our own citizens and citizens abroad, an international effort to eradicate cannabis production and use has undoubtedly failed leaving in its wake social unrest and political…

Words 776 - Pages 4

The Legalization Of Marijuana

Cannabis, otherwise known as, marijuana has been around for centuries; dating back to the B.C. era. Marijuana comes from the Hemp plant which was widely grown by in the 17th century for its abilities to make rope, sails, and clothing out of it. By the 19th century, marijuana started to become a popular ingredient medicinal products and were sold to public pharmacies. The use of marijuana didn’t become recreational until the after the Mexican Revolution of 1910, as many Mexican Immigrants poured into…

Words 1164 - Pages 5

The Legalization Of Marijuana

The legalization of marijuana is a popular topic in America right now, but it is my personal opinion that the cons do indeed outweigh the pros. The issue with the legalization of marijuana is that simply put, marijuana is not harmless. It does negatively affect the brain and certainly distorts a driver’s perception which could inevitably result in an increase of vehicle accidents. If it was legalized, usage would of course increase tremendously and it would become increasingly more accessible…

Words 643 - Pages 3

The Legalization Of Marijuana

dark for the fear that it will change your opinion. Marijuana has newfound fame since four states have chosen to legalize it for recreational purposes. This fame has effected the youth in America having them believe that marijuana is harmless. Marijuana is a narcotic and should be treated nothing less then that. Hans Breiter, a professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Northwestern University's Feinberg School of Medicine stated, "Marijuana is the ideal compound to screw up everything for a…

Words 1660 - Pages 7

The Legalization Of Marijuana

people but yet is still legal? While marijuana causes less deaths and cures different types of medical problems but is illegal ? It just doesnt make sense. The legalization of marijuana would help our community, it would keep many of people out of jail then the police could actually start arresting the real criminals instead of the people caught with small amounts of marijuana on them. Also it is safer for you than plenty of legal drugs. The legalization of marijuana has been in discussion for many of…

Words 436 - Pages 2

The Legalization Of Marijuana

as all societies declare their own idea of the real world (Erich Goode Marijuana and the Politics of Reality pg. 83). Marijuana, also known as cannabis sativa has been falsely criticized since the beginning of the century. The legalization of marijuana is a controversial subject; however, there are many positive arguments to support the idea. First of all, it is expensive to keep marijuana illegal. Also marijuana has been proven to be less likely to create crime, it can be used as a medicine…

Words 2379 - Pages 10

Marijuana Legalization Essays

Jonathan Goergen Reasons to Legalize Marijuana The criminalization of marijuana has many stories behind it. Some believe that it was made illegal in the early 20th century because it was meant to play off of anti-immigrant sentiments. Considering that Mexican immigrants introduced recreational marijuana use to the American culture. Others believe it was made illegal because it would put the tobacco industries out of business. The media had a large role in making people believe that usage caused…

Words 1741 - Pages 7

Legalization of Marijuana Essay

Legalization of Marijuana There are many arguments to be had—therefore we must weigh the pros and cons of each argument before deciding to fight for a cause. I believe that marijuana should be legalized because there are more positives allowing recreational use than there are negatives. Marijuana is a drug that can be used for medical treatments, it does not have poor effects on human health. I believe that this battle against marijuana should not be fought because victory over the drug and its…

Words 713 - Pages 3

Legalization of Marijuana Essay

2013 Legalization of Marijuana The legalization of marijuana would greatly reduce drug violence in cities, reduce spending by law enforcement, and taxation of marijuana would greatly help the economic system of the United States. Legalization is a large topic of debate in today’s society. America’s overall view of marijuana is pessimistic however, more and more people are beginning to step forward and express their support for legalization. People are becoming more tolerant of marijuana use; a…

Words 1619 - Pages 7

Marijuana Legalization Essays

April 2013 “Marijuana Legalization: Colorado and Washington State Grapple With Implementing New Laws” http://www.policymic.com/articles/22459/marijuana-legalization-colorado-and-washington-state-grapple-with-implementing-new-laws “President Obama’s Marijuana Problem” http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2013/04/president-obamas-marijuana-problem-2.php Marijuana Legalization in America In November, Colorado and Washington created major ripples in the debate over the legality of the marijuana. Colorado’s…

Words 692 - Pages 3