I believe that Philip would win because all of the media has his side and his peers have said, he was humming at a low volume and also some didn’t even notice.
Almost the whole media has his side. “Dear, Margaret Narwin, I’m a veteran who fought for his country and gave blood and I really hate people like you. From David Maik.”(Avi 169) David Maik is a U.S. veteran and doesn’t like Ms. Narwin for what she did. He has Philip’s side. “Dear, Margaret Narwin… I am dismayed and horrified that in this day and age colleague of mine should suspend a student from school for singing the national anthem. We suffer enough from unfair criticism. By Carlton Haven.”(Avi 169) Another teacher Carlton Haven, is just like Ms. Narwin, but is dismayed by Ms. Narwin’s choices. Carlton is worried for Ms. Narwin, but on Philips side.“To Margaret Narwin… It seems to me that people like you-who don’t believe in patriotism- case the problems. You should find a better profession for your lack of ability. By Linda Dorchester.”(Avi 168) Linda is bashing Ms. Narwin with a hate email, saying you should go find a different job that has the lack ability as you. Linda also mentions that Philip was just showing his patriotism. Linda is on Philips side.…show more content… “Dr. Doane: Loudly? Ken: Well, not really.”(Avi 146)Ken stated to Dr. Doane that Philip wasn’t loud to create a disturbance. “Cynthia: Well, I heard him. Sort of. I mean, it wasn’t loud or anything.”(Avi 149)Cynthia also stated to Dr. Doane that Philip wasn't loud to create a disturbance. “Ken:... The music went on… next thing, Miss Narwin was telling Philip to stop.(Avi 145) This is evidence that Ms. Narwin was creating the disturbance than Philip was because Ken never really noticed
