Life of Pi Essay

Submitted By VNijjar
Words: 1146
Pages: 5
Open Document
“A Story With God is the Better Story” Does Ang Lee do a good job at staying true to Yann Martels novel? Any book reader would tell you that a movie could never be as good as the book. Be it Shawshank Redemption, The Great Gatsby, Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings or any of the good old classics, or as in this case Life of Pi. One main reason is that books and movies are very different things. Movies don’t leave anything to viewer’s imaginations. When reading, a person is creating his or her own movie in a sense and he or she decides many of the important parts: how the characters speak, what they look like and what their surroundings look like. This process of imagining and interpreting as a reader is a creative process that is completely different from a movie. So do I believe that the movie stayed true to the novel? No, not as much as it could’ve and three examples why I believe this are Pi’s love interest, Richard Parker, and the end of the movie. Firstly, one major difference that I have noticed is with Pi’s love interest. In both the novel and the film, Pi is devastated when he learns that his family is leaving their hometown of Pondicherry, India, and heading to Winnipeg, Canada. The movie takes the need of adding a character and giving Pi a love interest that does not appear in the book. In the movie, Pi’s parents are concerned to find that he is practicing Hinduism, Christianity, and Islam all at once. Pi’s mother then tells him to work for a dance class to
2
take his mind off of things, and this is when Pi’s interest for a girl developed. He follows her and her friends one day after class and is caught off guard when she confronts him. Pi manages to smooth things over and takes her on a tour of his family’s zoo. The two eventually form a relationship thus making Pi’s move to Canada much more difficult. A reason why I believe Ang Lee put this in the film is because it shows that Pi is like any other normal kid and likes girls and romance. It humanizes him and makes him relatable on screen. The thing is more people will watch the movie than have read the book so you would think they’d probably want to make him seem very relatable to the audience. In addition, movies are short compared to reading a whole book so there is less ability to relate to an audience, thus having to find ways to make the audience relate to characters. The movie did this by adding in a girl for Pi to love, and to be vulnerable around so that the audience would recognize the significance of adding a character to Pi’s life on screen. As well as they want to increase the excitement since it’s a Hollywood film, since every Hollywood film has some sort of romance going on. They do this because romance blossoming in a movie is the viewers’ guilty pleasure. Secondly, another major difference is between Pi and Richard Parker. Pi’s relationship with Richard Parker changes throughout the book and movie. In the movie, Richard Parker is extremely aggressive and while Pi manages to survive with him for 227 days, he never really trained the tiger completely. In fact, there is one scene in which Pi tries to train Richard Parker by getting him to feel seasick whenever he blows the whistle. But when Richard Parker still showed signs of aggression, Pi just gives up on the

3 training. The book on the other hand, shows that Pi is very knowledgeable about animals because of his experience at his father’s zoo, as well as his father’s teachings. He is very cautious around Richard Parker, but he quickly projects himself as the alpha male and marks his territory on the boat. Pi is also more constructive in his training with Richard
Parker and has him literally jumping through hoops by the end of the book. On multiple occasions, Pi also notices Richard Parker making a sound known as prusten; a noise tigers makes to show they are not aggressive, kind of like a dog whining. Lastly, which I personally don’t agree with is the ending. Life of Pi ends with
Show More

Related Documents: Life of Pi Essay

Life of Pi Essay

the reader. Pi tells us that he continued his religious and zoological studies and was a very good student. He mentions that his religious studies thesis addressed aspects of Isaac Luria’s cosmogony theory. He speaks at length about sloths and observes that their very survival is ensured by the fact that they are so slow and dull; they virtually disappear into the background. We learn that Pi is now working, though he does not say anything about his profession. We also learn that Pi misses India…

Words 969 - Pages 4

Life of Pi Essay

for parents to save money. I mean, uniforms cost $500 max, but if you think about it is way more expensive. Plus, if you think about it, parents would save more money buying uniforms than new shirts, pants, and shoes to replaces old up ones. This essay will explain why students learn to respect each other and why uniforms help families save money. However, there are also arguments to why uniforms should not be implemented in schools. The fact that there would be not diversity and it could lead…

Words 386 - Pages 2

Life of Pi Essay

Discuss the importance of believability in this novel. In Yann Martel’s surreal novel, ‘Life of Pi’, views the measure of how an individual uses their intrinsic knowledge to face up to life’s riveting challenges. Martel portrays the protagonist, Pi Patel, as an individual who explores his own intrinsic identity through imagination, religion & faith as well as the fundamental difference between fact and fiction. Throughout the text, Martel, attempts to question the readers understanding of believability…

Words 1069 - Pages 5

Essay on Life of pi

phrase that follows us through school, work, sport and the rest of life. Why can’t anything be easy? Now, why did I choose to write about Yann Martel’s book and now movie, ‘Life Of Pi’ when it has so many bad reviews and ratings? The film starts off in a small Indian village called Pondicherry in the 70’s. Piscine Molitor Patel, known as Pi lives with his traditional Indian family with a normal lifestyle, much like my ordinary life, here in England. The mystical movie varies throughout between happy…

Words 481 - Pages 2

Life of Pi Essay

Energy Efficiency vs. School Computers By: Michael Gauthier Group: Patrick Gravelle, Lucas Felice, Adrian D’angelo Abstract The purpose of this experiment was to calculate the energy efficiency of a common school computer (both monitor and box) and find out how it can affect the environment. The common school computer we found out that the monitor is 98% efficient and takes up 8.76kW/year and the box is 95% efficient and takes up 26.28kW/year. Our results found out that the common school computer…

Words 665 - Pages 3

Life of Pi Essay

whether it means fighting in a battle or searching for water in a desert. The novel, Life of Pi, written by Yann Martel tells a story about a boy named Pi and a Royal Bengal tiger, Richard Parker, who fight for survival on a lifeboat in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. Throughout the story, many characters show their desire to survive where their life is in their hands and the actions they take are crucial. When the ship, Tsimtsum, sinks, Pi is thrown off the ship into a lifeboat forty feet down and is aboard with 4 other animals: the zebra…

Words 324 - Pages 2

Essay life of pi questions

really receive the better end of the deal? Or did Jerone finally feel like he was wanted and apart of helping someone live their dream? In this essay all aspects of this question will be discussed. Gattaca is a story set, where it is believed that there is future waiting for us where genetically modifying your child is the ‘normal’ approach to everyday life. We are introduced to a character named Vincent Freeman, a child conceived not by genetic means, but through the natural bound, an act of love…

Words 475 - Pages 2

Essay about Life of Pi

Elaina Hardy Bradley English 100 September 23, 2013 Surrounded by Water Times Magazine 4 out of 5 stars The movie adaptation of the best-selling novel by Yann Martel, The Life of Pi, is a bold, beautiful and visually innovative adventure that centers on an Indian boy by named Pi Patel, played by Sarag Sharma, a newcomer in the industry. The film was directed brilliantly by Ang Lee, the director of the Oscar nominated “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon” after several well know directors such…

Words 388 - Pages 2

Life Of Pi Religion Essay

The book Life of Pi is the story of a boy named Piscine Patel and his family. The book explains the struggle Pi faces when he is on the lifeboat. After Pi’s parents decides to sell their zoo in India and move to canada. The family board the boat Tsimtsum with a few remaining animals. Tragedy smacks when a frightful storm sinks in the ship, leaving Pi as the only human survivor. Although, Pi wasn’t alone; with him on the lifeboat was Richard Parker a bengal tiger. As days turn into weeks and weeks…

Words 779 - Pages 4

Life Of Pi Animals Essay

There are always two sides to every story; it is up to the reader to determine how they want to interpret it. This is the case with “Life of Pi” by Yann Martel, where two stories are presented in incredible ways. First, the protagonist, Pi, narrates his experiences on a deserted lifeboat with animals, whereas in a future encounter, he retells the story by replacing the animals with humans. The first rendition with the animals is clearly the better story because it appeals to imagination rather than…

Words 1330 - Pages 6