Life Sentencing Juveniles

Words: 1854
Pages: 8
Open Document
Juvenile’s Subject to Life Sentences Imagine being in a confined concrete room, metal bars, the feeling of a caged animal with hours, days, months, even years going by, and nothing to do. This is the feeling that juveniles have when being stuck in prison with a life sentence, going years without seeing their family because of a crime they committed at a young age. It’s the price that must be paid when committing horrendous crimes. Even at such a young age, there must be a crucial punishment rightfully given to avoid things happening in the future and keep the safety of our country and citizens. This further adds to the question: Why is there so much debate about juvenile punishments, and whether they should be subject to life sentences? There …show more content…
The 8th Amendment is important in understanding a child's right to no cruel or unusual punishment and excessive fines (Colb). The history of Roper vs Simmons is important because it brings the debate about life sentences for juveniles to the surface. Many penalties have been rewritten for juveniles, along with getting rid of sentencing juveniles to life without parole (JLWOP). Around 33 states follow these new laws and ban them completely (Rovner). States that do allow juveniles to be sentenced to life, mostly follow the sentences of 15 - 40 years in prison (Rovner). When looking at the statistics of juvenile crimes “Between 1980 and 2005, 43,621 juveniles were arrested for murder in the United States. This picture is just bleak with respect to arrests for rape (109,563), robbery (818,278), and aggravated assault (1,240,199).” (Stimson and Grossman). This data and history also bring in ethics and values that judges must look at when sentencing a child for such amounts of …show more content…
When looking into the actions of juveniles, many supporters say that the home life a child grew up in is a major factor. Children sentenced to life often grew up in abusive households like Evan Miller who committed a crime at the age of 14, however, his home life was very unstable and by the age of 6, he had 4 failed suicide attempts. His mother was addicted to cocaine, had shot someone, and had been sent to jail (Rovner). The homelife and role models around young children play a big role in their ability to make decisions because they learn this behavior by modeling the ones around them. A recent study on children’s brains shows they fail to realize the consequences of their actions and impair judgment. Supporters will add that youth have disadvantages when defending their cases because of the way their developing brains respond to the pressure of interrogation (Rovner). With this new research, some scientists will add to the argument that juveniles under the age of 18 are at a biological disadvantage when making decisions that will affect them long term, even when acknowledging their
Show More

Related Documents: Life Sentencing Juveniles

Super-Predators Influence Judicial Decisions To Sentence

decisions to sentence juvenile offenders accused of homicide to life terms. In the 1980’s and early 1990’s crimes committed by the Juvenile population increased. Crimes such as drug dealing, murder, assault and burglary. Experts called juveniles who commit crimes super-predators and described them as impulsive, remorseless and violent. Legislators were concerned of the teenage violent wave and their agenda was to prove they’re tough on crime. This inspired extreme sentencing during the super-predator…

Words 692 - Pages 3

Juvenile Life Without Parole Case Study

States stands alone worldwide in sentencing juveniles life without parole. Roper v. Simmons, Graham v. Florida, and Miller v. Alabama are all cases that helped abolished sentencing juveniles life without parole. The reality is that life without parole means sentencing the youth to die in prison. It is one of the harshest penalties that a person can can receive in the United States. In December of 2006 ,the United Nations held a discussion for abolishing life without parole for children and…

Words 1171 - Pages 5

Juveniles Deserve Life Sentences Analysis

Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan claims that if a juvenile is granted “life without parole”, this action violates the eighth amendment and disregards the juvenile’s age, level of maturity, and other factors which could influence the juvenile’s behavior. This is true, for the brain of a juvenile is not as developed as an adult’s. It cannot be predicted if the convicted juvenile will forever remain a threat, and it cannot be proven that all juveniles commit crimes with the intent of committing them…

Words 643 - Pages 3

Should Kids Be Sentenced To Life In Prison Too Harsh

Juveniles are being sentenced to life in prison without the possibility parole for their crimes. Young kids are being tried as an adult for their crimes, but do they deserve to have their freedom taken away for the rest of their lives? Kids are known to be uncontrollable when it comes to their emotions and actions and also known to be immature up to their twenties. Juveniles are also known to make the best candidates for rehabilitation. So is sentencing juveniles to life in prison too harsh? Even…

Words 719 - Pages 3

Graham V. Florida Case Summary

sentenced to life without parole. He was transferred from a juvenile court to a circuit court in which case they were going to try him as an adult for capital murder during a course of arson. In the appeal Two cases were brought up in this sentencing and it was the Roper vs Simons and Grahams vs Florida. The reason Miller brought these cases up was because a minor cannot be sentenced to death and a minor cannot be imprisoned for life for a non-homicidal crime. Is sentencing a 14-year-old to life in prison…

Words 566 - Pages 3

Essay On Juveniles Should Be Tried As Adults

Sentencing juveniles to life in prison When a child kills, does he instantly become an adult? Should a thirteen year old that murder a fifty five year old Detroit barber be charged as an adult? , sentencing juveniles to life in prison for murder and other serious offenses, children over twelve should go to prison for murder and other serious offenses they should still give them a chance to reform their life as they are so young, and also the crime will remain the same no matter who commits it, for…

Words 832 - Pages 4

Juveniles Should NOT Be Sentenced To Life In Prison

Juvenile justice analyzes whether it is justified for a juvenile to be sentenced to life in prison without parole. The supreme court ruling in 2012 determined that it was against the eighth amendment for cruel and unusual punishment. When sentencing a juvenile, their crime should not be the only thing that is taken into consideration. People under the age of eighteen should not be able to be sentenced to life in prison without parole, however, they should still be held accountable for their actions…

Words 793 - Pages 4

Juvenile Justice Essays

March 13, 2014 Juvenile Justice Recently there has been much contention regarding the issue of the punishment of juvenile offenders. In the late 1980’s a series of criminologists anticipated a sharp rise in juvenile crime so politicians began to legislate out of fear by lowering the age that minors could be remanded to the adult justice system. Their primary worry was that juveniles would be released at the ages of 18 to 21. In conjunction with adult mandatory adult sentencing rules, many of the…

Words 683 - Pages 3

Juvenile Rehabilitation Statistics

in adult court and sentenced to life in prison. Juvenile justice is an important aspect of our legal system, tasked with navigating the complex intersection of youth, crime, and rehabilitation. With a focus on young juveniles, who are frequently dealing with several socioeconomic and psychological issues, the juvenile justice system seeks not only to administer punishment but also to provide guidance, support, and opportunities for rehabilitation. While the juvenile justice system emphasizes rehabilitation…

Words 1470 - Pages 6

Confidentiality In Juvenile Court Cases

violent crimes of juveniles, there should be some confidentiality in courtrooms with closed doors so that it prevents the public from seeing the difficult cases because it also helps to handle the societal problems represented in the juvenile court cases. In the case of People v. Smith 470 NW2d 70 the facts where clear. Smith had pleaded guilty to breaking and entering and was convicted because he was a habitual offender which this constituted his fourth offense. Smith’s juvenile records were opened…

Words 356 - Pages 2