Gender Effects Language Use

Submitted By Sophia-Todd
Words: 805
Pages: 4
Open Document
English Language – Sophia Todd

Explore how far gender effects Language use

Text H is a transcript between two teenage friends,Linda and Ed. The subject is regarding Linda’s trip to see the band 'Stereophonics', and it includes an anecdote about the journey home involving troubles with the car.The purpose of their conversation is interactional,to have a catchup and share information about what has gone on in their lives recently.It is occurring in an informal setting, after their shift at work.

Within the conversation one of the firsts things I noticed was that Linda interrupts Ed fairly frequently.For example,when Ed tries to describe what the problem could have been with the car and says ‘cos you’ve got the jacking points underneath the’, he gets interrupted by Linda who replies ‘well no…’ This happens again when Ed is yet again explaining the jacking points and Linda interrupts saying ‘I have no idea’. One reason for these interruptions could be because Linda isn’t interested in the mechanics of the car, and feels that she couldn't join in with the conversation.These examples Challenge Janet Holmes study- The Dominance model, which claimed that men interrupt 96% of the time. This could also be an example of the 'difference model' by Deborah Tannen, as when Linda said 'took ages (1.0) he changed it for us (.)' she was probably seeking sympathy, rather than advice from Ed. Tannen states that 'Women seek comfort and sympathy for their problems, whilst men will seek a solution to the problem'.

Moreover, within the transcript Linda regularly comes across as unsure and vague. She uses a tag-questions like ‘you know?’, approximations of ‘about five minutes’ and ‘about two o’clock in the morning’ and hedging, for example, ‘I dunno’, ‘maybe’, ‘I have no idea’ and ‘um so yeah’. The fact that these are used to convey a sense of uncertainty and vagueness links to Robin Lakoff theory in The Deficit Model where she states that females are more likely to seem uncertain and vague by suing tag-questions and hedging.However these could also just simply be examples of features that occur in informal spontaneous speech, as Linda hasn't planned what she is going to say. Furthermore throughout the text Ed uses more informal language such as 'cos', which is a contraction.This supports Peter Trudgill's idea that males are more likely to seek 'covert prestige' when communicating.

In the conversation Linda speaks 356 words whereas Ed only speaks 101. This supports Louann Brizendine's idea that women are more verbose than men, using almost three times the amount of words that males do. In addition, Coates (1989) produced evidence that claimed that men try to hold the floor and dominate conversations, however Linda dominates this conversation talking about her experience in great depth. Linda is also talking for the majority of the time, which challenges Holmes findings as she displayed evidence that suggested men speak for longer in a mixed gender conversation. Linda is also the one who manages the topic, for example when she begins to talk about her car tyre being deflated, Ed accepts this change of topic. A contradiction to Pamela Fishmans
Show More

Related Documents: Gender Effects Language Use

Feminism: Annotated Bibliography

Abbey, Ruth (ed.) (2013), Feminist Interpretations of Rawls, College Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press. Alstott, Linda (2004), No Exit: What Parents Owe Their Children and What Society Owes Parents, New York: Oxford University Press. Baehr, Amy R. (ed.) (2004), Varieties of Feminist Liberalism. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield. Baehr, Amy R. (2013), Liberal Feminism: Comprehensive and Political, In Abbey (2013). ––– (2008), Perfectionism, Feminism, and Public Reason, Law and Philosophy…

Words 777 - Pages 4

Essay about Big Bend

Campground Restaurant SA Self-guiding trail Lodging and food Private land within park boundary Please observe land owner’s rights. Primitive campsite N TI 385 A G O Entrance Store M Persimmon Gap Visitor Center Nor th 0 5mi 8km 3mi 5km 10 Kilometers 5 0 5 O U N Graytop 5502ft 1677m 10 Miles TA BLACK GAP IN Stillwell Store and RV Park S WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT AREA To Alpine 58mi 94km DO C G…

Words 1068 - Pages 5

Ethics and Ethical Dilemmas Essay

Required Text: Managing Business Ethics: Straight Talk About How To Do It Right (5th ed.). Linda K. Trevino & Katherine Nelson. 2011. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN: 978-0-470-34394-4. The Ethics of Management (7th ed.). La Rue Tone Hosmer. 2011. University of Michigan-Ann Arbor. ISBN: 9780073530543. American Psychological Association. (2009). Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (6th ed.). Washington, DC: Author. (Students should have acquired this book in their first…

Words 1921 - Pages 8

Essay about Hito Steyerl Too Much World

01/10 Hito Steyerl e-flux journal #49 Ñ november 2013 Ê Hito Steyerl Too Much World: Is the Internet Dead? Too Much World: Is the Internet Dead? 11.07.13 / 02:50:22 EST Is the internet dead?1 This is not a metaphorical question. It does not suggest that the internet is dysfunctional, useless or out of fashion. It asks what happened to the internet after it stopped being a possibility. The question is very literally whether it is dead, how it died and whether anyone killed it. ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊBut how…

Words 4547 - Pages 19

Domestic Violence and Fear Essay

accroissent généralement la peur des femmes envers le crime. Les résultats démontrent l’importance de tenir compte de la violence conjugale lors d’études portant sur les peurs des femmes envers le crime afin de ne pas faussement qualifier la peur des femmes d’« irréaliste ». Mots clés : violence conjugale, peur du crime, insécurité, sécurité personnelle Based on findings that suggest women are more afraid of crime than men despite their overall lower rates of victimization, some scholars have suggested…

Words 7182 - Pages 29

Essay about Bisphenol A BPA In U

Environ. Sci. Technol. 2010, 44, 9425–9430 Bisphenol A (BPA) in U.S. Food A R N O L D S C H E C T E R , * ,† N O O R M A L I K , † DARRAH HAFFNER,‡ SARAH SMITH,† T. ROBERT HARRIS,† OLAF PAEPKE,§ AND LINDA BIRNBAUM| University of Texas School of Public Health, 6011 Harry Hines Blvd V8.112 Dallas, Texas 75390, United States, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, 5323 Harry Hines Blvd Dallas, Texas 75390, United States, Eurofins Gfa GmbH Laboratory, Neulaender Kamp 1, 21079 Hamburg, Germany…

Words 5983 - Pages 24

Business Evnironment Responsbility Jou Essay examples

marketing research at the American Collegefor the Applied Art, Atlanta Campus. She has taught marketing at the university level in Chinese for several years. Her research interests include business ethics, equity, and international marketing strategy. Linda Chang is a financial analyst on OTSUKA America. A native of Taiwan, she has an MBA. Her research interests are in the areas of planning and negotiation. Warren French is a professor of Marketing and the I. W. Cousins Professor ofBusiness Ethia at the…

Words 5552 - Pages 23

Cultural Diversity Paper 200 02

Cultural Diversity Health Promotion among Chinese Americans Melissa McLaughlin Maryville University: NURS 200-02 Abstract As a largely immigrant population, Asian and Chinese Americans face economic and language barriers that prevent them from assessing health care, making them more vulnerable to advanced depression and other mental health disorders. The presence of stress for Chinese Americans relating to acculturation may also be a factor in developing depression. Cultural values regarding…

Words 2876 - Pages 12

The Issue Of Violence

Time to own the issue: through the endeavours of non-violent men. With regard to violence men are predominately seen as the problem so they should also be seen as part of the solution (Flood, 2001; Berkowitz, 2004). Not to say that woman cannot be violent but figures for Australia and worldwide indicate there is a 90% chance that if an incident of violence is recorded the fact is it will predominantly be a male who is the perpetrator (Flood, 2011; Hautzinger, 2003). Discovering why men are more…

Words 3179 - Pages 13

Royal Road Essay

Royal Road Johannes Kieding Simmons School for Social Work Royal Road The Basic Facts In reviewing the case of Billy, a few things are clear: Billy’s father, Mr. Jamison, has been abusing his mother by raping her, bullying her, controlling and terrorizing her with threats using a gun. There has also been at least one incident where Mr. Jamison has been physically abusive and terrorizing by coercing Billy -- forcefully holding his head close to a light bulb -- until Billy fainted. It also appears…

Words 2832 - Pages 12