The article talks about “laws against feeding lobsters to inmates more than once a week because it was thought to be cruel and unusual, like making people eat rats.” Now days lobster is sought after and is very expensive. I couldn’t imagine lobster having such a low status. It made more sense when I learned lobster was so plentiful during this time. After large storms, the beaches would be full of dead, smelly lobsters. I think lobsters low status during the 1800s had a lot to do with the way they prepared the food as well. The article says they would cook the lobster dead, then preserve it to eat for later. I think lobster is much better cooked fresh and caught in the summertime when lobsters are hungry and active. I thought the author did a good job giving a lot of information on lobsters before he talked about the big debate among cooking lobsters.
Before discussing the controversial question, the author gives a step by step guide on how the lobsters are broiled. His main point is that the lobsters are supposed to be alive when you drop them in the kettle. This leads to the question asked each and every year. “Is it all right to boil a