Lowering the Legal Drinking Age Essay examples

Submitted By drwho90
Words: 1069
Pages: 5
Open Document
Bottoms Up
Underage drinking has been a huge problem among adolescents everywhere. There have been many disputes over the years on whether or not the legal drinking age should be lowered. Some argue that lowering the drinking age would put more responsibility into the hands of the youth and that they would act maturely towards it, as in Fr. Dennis Tamburello’s article. On the other side of the argument in the article written by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (DHS), it is believed that lowering the drinking age would be nearly catastrophic. They believe that if the drinking age is lowered then teenagers and young adults would just abuse it and become reckless. While both articles give good and valid arguments, the article by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has the stronger argument because it gives the reader more logical than emotional appeals that are relevant to the point they are making.
Although Tamburello is a college professor, this does nothing to prove that he is credible when it comes to the issue of underage drinking. In the article The Legal Drinking Age Exuberates Drinking, Tamburello talks about his experience with college students at Sienna College, where he teaches. His credibility is not very high because his areas of expertise are Reformation studies, Calvin studies, interreligious dialogue, and mysticism. The only knowledge he has of underage alcohol consumption is his experiences with college students and what he has observed. Also his article was written on a personal blog instead of a scholarly journal or magazine. Tamburello also tries to point out that he taught an alcohol-awareness course crafted by the Prevention Research Institute. But, he only mentions this in a brief sentence in the middle of his article and fails to let his reader know anything more about the course he taught or what the Prevention Research Institute is.
On the other hand, The Minimum Legal Drinking Age Should Not Be Lowered is an article written by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, which proves to be much more credible than a college professor. The DHS is the government’s principal agency for protecting the health of all Americans and providing essential human services. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has conducted a lot of research to back up all of the arguments and statistics that they give. Although Tamburello is lacking credibility behind his article, he does a good job on backing up his point with plenty of emotional appeals. He first points out how he believes that the drinking age of 21 endangers lives more than saves them. His reason is that alcohol becomes the “forbidden fruit” to young adults and they think that it will be so tempting for them that they will use any means necessary to obtain it. Tamburello also points out that because he has taught over 20 years at college that he has seen his fair share of underage drinking. He tries to play it off like he knows everything about underage drinking just because he has worked at a college for a long period of time. He also tries to grab the attention of the young adults he may have as an audience by saying how he thinks if an 18 year old is allowed to vote, get married and do other “adult things” then they should be able to drink as well.
The U. S. Department of Health and Human Services’ article does not have nearly as many emotional appeals as Tamburello’s, but that works to their advantage. They point out that if a young adult thinks that drinking will be a good experience, then they will be more likely to drink than someone that does not share their belief.
In Tamburello’s article, there were no logical appeals for his article was mostly based on emotional appeals. With his lack of research to back up any of his arguments that he tries to make, readers may find it hard to actually believe anything that he is saying. Throughout his article, all he does is state his opinion on the issue of
Show More

Related Documents: Lowering the Legal Drinking Age Essay examples

Essay On Lowering The Legal Drinking Age

Minimum Legal Drinking Age (MLDA) laws specify the age of when a person can buy or publicly drink alcohol legally. In 1984, the minimum legal drinking age was raised to twenty-one. Many college students attend parties where alcohol is present. They should be allowed to consume the alcoholic beverages with their classmates without having to worry about getting in trouble. Eighteen year olds are adults and should be able to make their own decision on whether or not they want to drink. The legal age to drink…

Words 1304 - Pages 6

Essay On Lowering The Legal Drinking Age

Lowering the Legal Drinking Age What if the legal drinking age was lowered to 18 again, what would happen to those who drink underage and keep it a secret? Lowering the legal drinking age to 18 would allow young adults to drink in public as multiple websites have said about being in favor of young adults drinking in public without keeping it a secret. Lowering the legal drinking age to 18 “Can be poisonous to the nerve cells and can cause the Hippocampus to be damaged or destroyed,” drinking as a…

Words 744 - Pages 3

Lowering The Drinking Age To 18 Essay

an adult? Shouldn’t you be able to do that? Lowering the drinking age has been a controversial topic for years. There are always two sides to the story, though. On one side, the people believe we should not lower the age because it can cause many problems for the people around us. But on the other side, people believe that we should lower it because it could also help us. The essential question I am researching is, should the minimum legal drinking age be lowered to 18? I am for this because, if…

Words 1531 - Pages 7

Essay On Lowering The Drinking Age To 18

America should lower the drinking age to 18 years old. Changing the age would make the United States fair, and reasonable. America’s legal adulthood age is 18, other countries legal drinking age is 18, and lowering the age can lower dangerous drinking activities. Lowering the drinking age from 21 to 18. Legally, in America a boy or girl becomes an adult at the age of 18. When they turn 18, many rules and restrictions change such as being allowed to vote. Most punishments with the law change. New…

Words 563 - Pages 3

Should Drinking Age Be Lowered To 18?

17/5/24. Should the Drinking Age Be Lowered to 18? The drinking age should be lowered to 18, as current laws are ineffective in preventing underage consumption, and legalizing alcohol for all adults may reduce its allure and promote healthier drinking habits, This paper aims to highlight that drinking age restrictions are failing and in doing so are causing the problem while lowering the age will promote healthier handling of alcohol by young people. Reducing the legal drinking age to 18 would lower…

Words 608 - Pages 3

Argumentative Essay: Lowering The Drinking Age

So here’s the thing, lowering the drinking age would be a horrendous decision. Thirty years ago, Congress passed a bill that raised the drinking age to 21. Despite these efforts, most developed countries allow young people to legally drink at 18 (Griggs). Many people want the legal drinking age to be lowered but if it is lower then it will encourage more teens to drink and it will raise the death rate because of drinking and driving and alcohol poisoning. This topic is important to me because I like…

Words 747 - Pages 3

Essay on LIbertarianism and Drinking

Lowering the Drinking Age to 18 and the Libertarian Principle Lowering the legal drinking age from twenty-one to eighteen would lead to many health and safety benefits to the youth of our society; additionally, it is the logical thing to do considering that adulthood in the United States is eighteen. At eighteen, we are finally allowed a greater degree of freedom. At this age, individuals are able to attend college, able to sign ourselves up for the military, buy cigarettes, marry and adopt,…

Words 1294 - Pages 6

mr. Philip Essay

Date: October 2nd, 2014 Legal Drinking Age should be eighteen. The socio-economic implications of lowering the legal drinking age from nineteen to eighteen. There were recommendations from different stakeholders, groups, and the Saskatchewan Party in 2013 to lower the legal drinking age to eighteen in the province. The results from the resolution turned out that the majority of people voted to maintain the current legal drinking age, which is nineteen. The Saskatchewan Police…

Words 731 - Pages 3

The Pros And Cons Of Lowering The Drinking Age

alcohol legally.”(“Drinking Age ProCon") This quote is from Dr. Dre a well-known producer in the hip hop genre. Alcohol has become a much debated topic in recent years, whether or not it should be consumed by the age of 18 or waiting until people reach the more mature age of 21. Alcohol has influenced enormous amounts of controversy among young people and adults. This debate has a lot of history, pros and cons, and policy making behind it. Legal Drinking age is defined as the age in which a person…

Words 1694 - Pages 7

Essay on Alcohol Law and Drinking Age

Civics Rant Ontario’s legal drinking age is currently at 19-years-old. That puts the province’s legal drinkers one year older than it’s the provinces to the east and west (Quebec and Manitoba), but two years younger than the states to the south. Being in the middle age causes many debates and arguments between raising and lowering the legal age. Many people argue that 19 is way to young to let irresponsible teens under a deathly substance but many people argue that 19 is way to old and that…

Words 554 - Pages 3