Week10 Business-level Strategic
Planning
Learning Objectives
• Types of business-level strategies
– Porter’s typology
– Miles & Snow’s typology
– Product life cycle
• Business-level strategic planning
– Value-chain
– Strategy clock
Week 10
2
Porter’s Competitive Strategies
• Overall cost leadership
– Supply the same product or service at a lower unit cost than competitors
• Differentiation
– Supply a product or service of which one or more attributes are perceived as more valuable
• Focus
– Target certain types of products for certain customer groups or regions
Week 10
3
Cost-leadership
• Cost leader can be obtained through
•
•
•
•
economies of scale simpler product design lower input costs efficient organisational process
• Case: IKEA
• simple, high-quality Scandinavian design (cost-saving in product design) • buying offices in 45 countries (cost-saving in inputs)
• knock-down furniture kits (cost-saving in assembling and delivering) • huge suburban stores (cost-saving in warehousing)
• customer self-service with tape measures, pens and notepaper
(cost-saving in staffing)
Week 10
4
Differentiation
• Differentiation brings competitive advantage
• meet the buyer needs in a unique manner
• create the higher perceived value and able to charge a higher price
• quality differentiation
• Rolex
• customer service
• Singapore Airlines
• value-for-money
• Fisher and Paykel, Mark and Spencer
• brand image
• Coca-Cola, Calvin and Klein
Week 10
5
Focus
• focus strategy brings competitive advantage
• match the features of specific products to the needs of specific customer groups
• geographic region
• ethnicity
• purchasing power
• tastes
• cost focus and differentiation focus
Week 10
6
Stuck in the middle
• Firms with no clear generic business strategy high Differentiation or low-cost strategy
Focus strategy
profitability
Stuck in the middle
low low market share
Week 10
high
7
Miles & Snow’ Typology (1)
• Prospector
–
–
–
–
Risk-taking
Growth oriented
Aggressively seek markets and opportunities
Entrepreneurial style of management
• defender
–
–
–
–
Protect current markets
Maintain stable growth
Serve existing customers
Emphasize efficiency over innovation
Week 10
8
Miles & Snow’ Typology (2)
• Analyzer
– Protect current market share + create market opportunities
– Seek balance between:
• Efficiency and innovation
• Risk-avoidance and risk-taking
• Control and flexibility
• Reactor
– No consistent approach
– React to environmental changes
– Compared to prospector:
• Drifts with events vs. seek out opportunities
• Wait to be influenced/changed vs. influence/change the industry
Week 10
9
Product Life Cycle (PLC) introduction growth
mature
decline
Market growth
Low
High
Low to moderate Negative
Competition
Low
Increasing
Intense
Changing
Overall objective Market awareness Create consumer demand
Defend market Consolidate, share maintain or exit Sales and marketing Production efficiency Major functional R&D concern Week 10
General management and finance
10
Strategies based on PLC
prospector
analyzer
defender
reactor
differentiation
low cost
low cost
focus
differentiation
Week 10
11
Business-level Strategic Planning: value chain
Organization Infrastructure
Human Resources
Information Systems
Material Management support inbound logistics production
outbound logistics Week 10
marketing
& sales
service
12
Value-added Analysis: sporting shoe industry
Value-added
17
3
30
50
component manufacturing assembling
wholesale
retail
35%
30%
15%
100
10%
cost
Week 10
13
The smiling curve
Week 10
14
Business-level Strategic