Essay about Managing Up

Submitted By wmc01
Words: 1246
Pages: 5
Open Document
Federalism: malaise or effective government

Reforms to federalism in Australia have been suggested due to a belief that it is not a source of effective government. Duplication of services, excessive bureaucracy and administration, and confusion around the roles and responsibilities of the Commonwealth and State governments have been some of the key drivers in the calls for reform. Wanna (2007) reported on a roundtable discussion of federalism in Australia that posed the question of federalism being a ‘malaise’.

This essay from a public service Manager will focus on the challenges associated with federalism which have precipitated a negative view of the system of government in Australia. It will then argue that cooperative federalism is currently at work across levels of government and proving to be a source of effective government. Challenges and obstacles

The lack of clarity around the powers conferred to the Commonwealth and the States through the Constitution has led to confusion in the functions, or roles and responsibilities, throughout the different levels of government. The framers of the Constitution wanted to create a national government with restricted powers so as to keep their own areas of responsibility (Singleton et al. 2006:31). Painter (1998) insists that duplication across government has occurred even though the Constitution favours the Commonwealth in these instances.
Duplication of services has been identified as an area of concern for all levels of government. Summers (2006) argues that High Court decisions favouring the Commonwealth, particularly during the Whitlam administration, assisted in the duplication of services by allowing the federal government to delve into areas of state responsibilities like education and health. The ‘Policy Roundtable on Federalism’ summarised by Wanna (2007:279) highlighted the need to reduce ‘the proliferation of parallel or similar departments’.

High Court decisions such as the Engineers case and Uniform Tax case have combined to erode traditional state responsibilities in regard to industrial relations and income tax (Summers 2006). Judicial decisions such as these have led to an imbalance in the financial relations between the tiers of government in favour of the Commonwealth. Althaus & Tiernan (2005) noted the vertical fiscal imbalance created was a frustration for the States.

Policy negotiations between and across the levels of government have contributed a further set of complications according to O’Faircheallaigh et al. (1997:97). This is supported by Althaus & Tiernan (2005:189-190) where intergovernmental negotiations can be seen as a ‘game’ and disagreements can occur due to the financial power held by the Commonwealth.

Mechanisms of cooperative federalism

In an address to the National Press Club on 19 July 1990 then Prime Minister Bob Hawke announced an initiative referred to as ‘new federalism’. The initiative was seeking the three tiers of government to work in closer partnership by addressing ‘sensible, practicable steps to get better cooperation within the framework of the Federal Constitution as it stands’ (Parliament of Australia: 2001).

In a move towards strengthening cooperation between Commonwealth and state governments, the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) was formed in 1992. This occurred as result of a series of Special Premiers Conferences that began in 1990 (Parkin & Anderson 2008). According to Twomey and Withers (2007) COAG was established to initiate reform through national cooperation. COAG has more recently been ‘reinvigorated’ with the ‘opportunity…to take major steps forward for the Australian community’ (Althuas & Tiernan 2009:191).

Twomey (2007:216) believes that major cooperation between the Commonwealth and States in varying areas, is occurring without the knowledge of many Australians. An example of such cooperation is the National Competition Policy which was agreed to in
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Managing Up

Managing Up Unit 1 Psmp Assignment Wanna Case Study Review Essay

Reading Wanna, J 2007, ‘Improving federalism: drivers of change, repair options and reform scenarios’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, vol. 66, no. 3, pp. 275 – 279. Purpose (What is the author’s aim? For example, is the piece descriptive or does it summarise the literature or introduce a new argument? Is the author trying to convince, persuade, or inform the reader? Use a verb.) (59) The author aims to inform the reader of the strengths, weaknesses and opportunities for reform of…

Words 2272 - Pages 10

Essay on Business Studies

either publicly or privately but typically the sole proprietor provides all the capital and takes all the risks. The risks involved are great as the sole proprietor has unlimited liability you have to make all the decisions yourself. Administering/managing is in the hands of the sole proprietor that needs to cover all aspects of the business Partnership: A partnership is an arrangement formed by signing a Deed of Partnership where individuals agree to cooperate to advance their interests. In the…

Words 1033 - Pages 5

Working Capital Essay

The Importance of Working Capital Annette Davis Budget and Finance Larry Simpson ABSTRACT Working capital is managing your capital. It is a reminder that current assets minus your current liabilities. It represents the liquidity that’s available to a business through a financial metric. What’s very important is that if you are in any type of business you are going to have assets, rather they are long term assets or short term, as your company grows so…

Words 1067 - Pages 5

Motivating Employees Case Study Essays

Institute" in Ch. 6 of Understanding and Managing Organizational Behavior. How Does SAS motivate its employees? SAS Institute motivate their employees by setting standards for their ideal workplace. They do so by keeping focus on the intrinsic and the extrinsic motivational methods. The SAS works towards their employees enjoying their jobs so that can how interest and motivation within their job. SAS motivates their employees to once in a while switch up areas within the workplace, so that they…

Words 798 - Pages 4

Rainforest management Essay

it can be useful for making money and improving the standard of life for those who need it, we also have to make sure that we sustain our resources for future generations, so it is important to look at long and short term impacts for each way of managing the rainforest. Brazil is a BRIC (Brazil Russia India China) country, which means it is a major developing economy that is growing at a fast pace, as well as having a huge population. The four BRIC countries produce 18% of the world's GDP and are…

Words 1092 - Pages 5

An Analysis Of The 285 Beltway Of Diversity In Organizations

organization but instead just producing a replica of their “ideal employee”. Ms. Harrington also went on to talk about Roosevelt Thomas’ model for ‘A Way To Organize Managing Differences and Similarities’ and how they all need to work continually in order to keep a sense of effective management. I found it interesting when she referred to ‘Managing Understanding’ as the “285 Beltway of Diversity”. Most organizations may feel as though there is no need for change beyond that point because they may feel that…

Words 510 - Pages 3

Essay on HW2 MT 456

Student Name____________________ Managing Transitions - Chapters 4 1) What is your author’s definition of the neutral zone? 2) How would you describe peoples feeling during the neutral zone? 3) Explain how the neutral zone can be a creative time? 4) What does it mean to normalize the neutral zone and why is that so important? 5) Explain how creating a temporary system or using a transition monitoring team can strengthen the neutral zone. Be specific. 6) Make a bullet list using your…

Words 306 - Pages 2

Managing The Diverse Workforce

Mr. Christesen Principle of Management November Chapter 11­ Managing the Diverse Workforce 1. Diversification should be a form of strategy that all companies should take aware if they are looking to have a vital creativity and innovation in order to become an successful organization. The United States is one of the few societies that have access to this great amount of talents due to it’s difference of diversity. Managing diversity has brought great issues while trying to find recrutement…

Words 817 - Pages 4

Essay about UNIT 2 MERIT 1Explain how the managemen

performance of a selected organisation. Human Resources When Starbucks is managing human resources it is important that management when employing people pick out the right people with qualifications or skills that are required for a specific role that they are advertising for. Its also import when HR select new staff that they receive any training if its nessacary and this is also needed with excising staff to keep them up to date with any new products or procedures that will improve business performance…

Words 712 - Pages 3

Voluntary Sector Business Study Essay

communication throughout the redundancy process. Download 'Resource management: a case study of the redundancy process' (PDF file, 1.2Mb) For further information about the redundancy process, have a look at thestaff retention and loss section. Managing a small cultural organisation in a global recession Helen Meany, Cass Centre for Charity Effectiveness In 2009, Irish Theatre Magazine saw a significant drop in the level of funding it received from the Arts Council. To ensure the publication’s…

Words 517 - Pages 3