Marriage and Janie Essay

Submitted By crystalait
Words: 2057
Pages: 9
Open Document
Janie’s Story of Love: An Idealistic Belief to What Became Real Do you remember as a child watching television and seeing the perfect love story? It is often told in a chronological order of progressive events. There’s a boy who meets a girl and knocks her off her feet. They then grow closer, romance and feelings grow stronger, they learn the ins and outs of one another, they fall deeply in love, boy proposes in a grand romantic gesture, girl says yes, they get married, grow old together, and live happily ever after. You know, the kind of love that seems unfathomable, but you long for it? The type of love so deep that nothing can penetrate it? A love so strong that it’s indestructible and can withstand time and all circumstances? Well this is what Zora Neale Hurson’s character, Janie Crawford, wanted. In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, Janie begins as a meek and naïve young girl who only seeks love. Her idea of love being the symbiotic relationship she observed between the bee and the pear tree blossom in her yard. A marriage to Janie was a man coming along, talking sweetly to her, and taking care of her as she embraced him and conformed to him just as the blossom embraced the bee. Janie wanted to feel the tingling sensation and shiver just as the tree seemed to after the bee and blossom joined in union. This was marriage and how it was supposed to be. Through the progression of Janie’s life as told in Their Eyes Were Watching God Janie holds this idea, but Janie matures and life teaches her that things can’t always be what you want them to be. More importantly, through each of her three marriages Janie sees that in reality the relationship and love she envisioned based on the bee and the pear tree blossom rarely occurs.
“Nobody put anything on the seat of Logan’s wagon to make it ride glorious on the way to his house. It was a lonesome place like a stump in the middle of the woods where nobody had ever been. The house was absent of flavor, too. Then anyhow Janie went on inside to wait for love to begin.” (pg. 39) Janie, at the point before her first marriage to Logan Killicks, was just a young girl. The only life she knew was the one given to her by Nanny. As a mere teenager with stars in her eyes and visions of a love which were sweet and simplistic Janie had no idea what this marriage would really be. Her Nanny had taught her all she had known, so she waited patiently for the love that her Nanny said would come. Janie tried during the whole marriage to grow accustomed to and get settled in her new life with Logan Killicks, but there was one problem: love never came. The sixty acres didn’t satisfy her and neither did the old Logan Killicks. Janie, still young, continued to long for a connection like the one between the bee and pear tree blossom. There was no attraction to Logan Killicks and no desire. There was no spark, no shiver, yet this was what Janie came to know as marriage. Although unhappy, Janie continues to do what she is expected to do as a wife. When Janie begins to acclimate to her current situation and accepts the fate which life has dealt her; a marriage and life with a man she has no love for, along comes Joe Starks. Joe Starks, although still not exactly what Janie was seeking, represented something more than what Janie was currently receiving. The longing of love still remained as she envisioned it, but Joe gave Janie hope of a different type of love not being received from Killicks. He may not have been an object of her lust, but to Janie, Joe was a step up from the life she had. Janie at this point has not yet progressed a lot, but one thing she knows without a doubt is that marriage does not mean love. Janie begins to talk frequently with Joe, and she realizes Joe Starks may still not be what she wants. Janie has reservations because she has now grown into a woman and she stills holds on to some of the things her Nanny instilled in her. The fact that everything doesn’t work the way
Show More

Related Documents: Marriage and Janie Essay

Essay on Marriage and Janie

see” (Hurston 14). II. Another important symbol is that of the pear tree. a. The pear tree presents the ideal relationship between women and men. The key to the novel is Janie's idea of marriage, which is pitted against other, less romantic, ideas of marriage in the book. b. Janie gets her definition of marriage from nature. When she is sixteen, her sexuality awakens as she watches “the mystery” of a blossoming pear tree in her back yard c. Through Janie’s vision, the pear tree presents the ideal…

Words 947 - Pages 4

GUILLOT Their Eyes Were Watching God Essay

likely to end their marriages in divorce. In Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God, all of Janie’s relationships fail due to her need to be presiding. In Janie’s first marriage, the relationship led to failure because Janie had a lack of love for Logan and because Logan did not respect Janie. After a while “She knew now that marriage did not make love. Janie’s first dream was dead, so she became a woman” (25). Janie is almost forced by Nanny to marry Logan when Nanny only told Janie of Logan’s wealth…

Words 595 - Pages 3

Love & Marriage Essay

Neale Hurston"s book, Their Eye Were Watching God, Janie had an adolescent view on love until she learns many lessons through her three marriages. She learned from her marriage to Logan Killicks that she could not learn to love someone. After her marriage to Jody Starks, Janie realized that equality is important within a marriage. When Janie married Tea Cake, she realized true love could be found. Janie learned through her three marriages even though she had bad experiences with love; there…

Words 807 - Pages 4

Their Eyes Were Watching God Theme Analysis

In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston uses cruelty to drive the story of the main character, Janie. Her first two husbands cruelly abuse Janie, which drives her towards her soul mate. Hurston uses cruelty within Their Eyes Were Watching God to expose themes, reveal Janie’s true independent nature, and to drive Janie towards her destiny. One of the ways cruelty is important to the novel, is that it exposes themes. A theme exposed by cruelty is power and control. All three…

Words 310 - Pages 2

Their Eyes Were Watching God Literary Analysis

Zora Neale Hurston’s amazing novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937) follows main character Janie Crawford, a woman who wishes to sculpt her own destiny, on her quest for true love, freedom and happiness. As a young woman, Janie fantasized of love and marriage believing would bring contentment, where “husbands and wives always loved each other” (Hurston 21). Someone who’ll love her physically and passionately; but finally once tasted, she felt her husband Logan slowly “desecrating the pear tree”…

Words 1010 - Pages 5

Their Eyes Were Watching God Relationships

Marriage can be described as a lifelong commitment to someone with immense friendship and love. However, as people evolve, so do their needs and desires, which lead to changes in the relationship. This is illustrated in the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, by Zora Neale Hurston when the main protagonist struggles to find what makes her thrive in a relationship as she grows up. This protagonist, Janie Crawford, has had three marriages from ages sixteen to thirty-seven, each presenting their own…

Words 1481 - Pages 6

Zora Neale Hurston's Struggles In Their Eyes Were Watching God

Throughout the book, Janie marries three different men. Each relationship brings about its own set of struggles and helps to shape Janie’s horizon. Her first marriage, to Logan Killicks, holds particular significance. This marriage highlights the hard choice Janie’s grandmother, Nanny, makes in arranging Janie’s marriage to Mr. Killicks. In efforts to protect Janie from the possibility of being raped by white men, a fate experienced by both Janie’s mother and Nanny, Nanny forces Janie into a loveless…

Words 633 - Pages 3

Zora Neale Hurston's Struggles

Watching God follows the story of Janie Crawford, a defiant colored woman living in Florida in the early 1900s. Throughout her life, Janie experiences various hardships, including abuse in multiple marriages, that help her grow as a person and become more comfortable with herself. Janie’s physical and emotional sacrifices, especially in her relationships with Jody Starks and Tea Cake, allow her to further discover true selfhood. Due to the failure of Janie’s first marriage to Logan Killicks— a much older…

Words 469 - Pages 2

TEWWG Study Guide Essay

not) and impact on Janie How do they challenge her? What does she learn from each? Janie Strong, Independent Living with Washburns & Nanny No sense of self Invisible Nameless Protected Pear Tree Growing up, becoming a women Discovering her sexuality As Mrs. Killicks Starts to look at horizon, hope/possibility/growth Starts to figure out what she wants in a marriage - not working like a mule As Mrs. Starts Treated as an object instead of a human Janie lost her voice in marriage - speaks out in the…

Words 745 - Pages 3

Their Eyes Were Watching God Literary Devices

Driving Moments Behind Janie’s Approach to Love in Their Eyes Were Watching God The clashing views on love and marriage between conformity and that of a young woman’s idealistic dream is developed throughout Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God. Early in the novel, Janie is quickly swept from one aspect of love and marriage (the young woman’s dream) to the other (conformity). The passages on page 11 and 21 show Janie’s early exposure to both sides of love and ultimate the beginning of…

Words 537 - Pages 3